House-training the impossible pet?

Question

I need help. My husband and I are parents to three dogs, and two of them took to house training just fine. Our third dog is about a year and a half old, and will not learn. It seems that she understands the concept, but does not see the need to hold it and wait. We are at wits end and are tired of waking up in the morning to poop piles and pee stains on the carpet.

We have tried everything standard and normal we can think of, and have even gone to a few extremes - crating her all night (she just whined for two weeks straight and begged to go out), limiting her feeding time (didn't seem to effect it at all). We're at the point where we are starting to wonder if there is something wrong with her.

Can anyone make a suggestion as to what we can try? We're pretty savvy pet owners, and have read up on this extensively. We can't seem to find a solution - even sprays, moth balls, etc. don't work - she just poops and pees around them. We're going crazy - what do we do?

Answer 1

You should keep her in the crate if you can't pay attention to her to correct the behavior when it happens.

I know she whined in the crate, just like kids whine in their playpens - such is life.

If she can't be trusted, she should be crated until such time as she learns her manners.

You're going to have to get past the whining though, it doesn't bother the dog at all.

Answer 2

My only suggestion, as I have this issue with my 3 yr old poodle, is crating. I read that you have tried this. But stick with it. If she is being loud, put her in another room in the crate. She is going to whine until she gets used to it. Try and make the crate a positive place for her, randomly throw treats in there for her to find when she goes in. When she goes in it, give her treat when you close the door. I'm not saying it will be easy, but BE CONSISTENT. To this day, if I leave my dog alone in the house he will use the carpet as his restroom, but if he is crated when I am gone (and he doesn't mind the crate anymore), I don't have the problem. Just make sure that 1. the crate is not too big (you don't want her going to the other side of the crate and peeing there. Dogs, naturally, will not soil the place they sleep.) 2. As soon as she is taken out of the crate, she goes outside until she "goes". Putting her on a feeding schedule will help too, after she eats, in the crate for awhile and then right outside til she "goes", and then she can have play time. DO NOT let her have free roam of the house until she can be trusted. She needs to understand that it is YOUR house and YOUR rules. She should always be in the same room as you and within site, this will serve 2 purposes 1. you are alpha and 2. you can see what she is doing and prevent an "accident" before it happens. I, personally, hate having to be that strict, but it pays. Like I said, if I am not around the poodle will break the rules even though he knows better. But on a more positive note, I did all this with my other dog and he can be left alone all the time and won't ever "go" in the house. Just be consistent, if you give in and let her do what she wants, and keep changing methods she won't learn, b/c she will think she can do what she wants. I hope this helps.

Answer 3

How big is this dog? Now don't go all ballistic here because even though it may sound harsh it really isn't and I actually learned this little trick from my vet. For some reason some dogs are just very stubborn trust me I know I have 17 of my own. Get some small mouse traps, now I mean the smallest you can find, and if the dog is a toy you can try this at all. Set the mouse traps up around the potty areas. What happens is when puppy gets close the traps snap and scare him. No they are not meant to snap on the dog but their movement will snap them near the dog and it warns them off the potty area.

Answer 4

I am definite plenty of humans right here have sound advice and most work splendidly. What I recommend is to seek professional support. (possibly for you with the intention to keep your sanity - j/okay). Talk to a personal canine coach. Have them come and assessment the canine, the dwelling main issue, the way you and others interact with the dog after which of course train the puppies no longer best in basic obendiance instructions but in specialized areas that suit your wants (messing in the apartment, chewing, howling and many others.). Individual trainers (for me in any case), are a god despatched. It took eight weeks but my three ladies are a ways higher behaved at house, in public and round strangers than ever before. Talk to a coach and go by means of the evaluation. It's worth the time, cash and effort! Huskies and Malemutes are living a long time! Good success

Answer 5

i'm valuable many human beings here have sound suggestion and maximum paintings splendidly. What I propose is to seek for expert help. (consistent with hazard for you as a fashion to maintain your sanity - j/ok). refer to a private canines coach. Have them come and evaluate the canines, the residing subject, the variety you and others work together with the canines and then of direction prepare the canines no longer in straight forward terms in straight forward obendiance instructions yet in excellent components that extra healthful your desires (messing in the domicile, chewing, howling etc.). own running shoes (for me after all), are a god despatched. It took 8 weeks yet my 3 females are far extra clever behaved at domicile, in public and around strangers than ever until now. refer to a coach and flow in the time of the assessment. it truly is truly somewhat worth the time, money and attempt! Huskies and Malemutes stay an prolonged time! stable success

Answer 6

well, i have a daschund hound and a min pin right now and the daschund hound is such a little brat. i walk them both many many times a day so theres no excuse why he couldnt go number 2 outside. he wasnt for nothing so i bought 2 fences from the local pet store, attatched them to make one big circle (the circle is in the dining room). they both will stay there when im not home and when im home and i take them out, i will watch them both like a hawk. and you know what? since i started using the fence they havent gone number inside the apartment not once!! try that, it works

Answer 7

You didn't say if she pooped in the crate.
If not that is still your best answer.
You may need to look at were the crate is located, what she has in the crate with her, and if their is other noise in the environment of th crate.

Answer 8

Do you take her out before it is time for bed?. If she is not eating/drinking before bedtime I would suggest you take her in to the vet. Has she been like this all her life? Or had she just started this?

Answer 9

Try and take it to the vet it might have a bladder problom it is possible