In this way will SOME person be responsible for ABETTING suicide?check details.?

Question

Some college student of INDIA who is top ranker & very confident boy of the class, is preparing for coming exams in Library;
sitting next to some female class-mate.
Both start talking about their preparation of exams.
He says his preparation is not good & he want to take a **celfose** tablet to die...he looks very normal to her while saying it.
She is completely unaware about what is going in his personnal life as she does not come in his friend circle.
She thinks he is joking or
trying to make her scared or
trying to falsely influence her for sympathy or
trying to flirt with her.
She replies jokingly ;''oh!,really?ok, do it ..then you will contribute in reducing INDIA's population which has become very high''.
Both laughs at this reply.
Next day she listens that he has comitted SUICIDE by hanging & his family was giving him antidepressant psychiatric treatment from 1 month.
IS SHE RESPONSIBLE FOR ABETTMENT OF SUICIDE?

Answer 1

NO
It is clear that she had no suspicion,just fun she could have thought.

Answer 2

no! in this case as the girl was not aware of his mental condition and she had no intention to make him die so she can not be held guilty of abettment. both were very much in a light mood as they were laughing. even when the girl said ''oh!,really?ok, do it ..then you will contribute in reducing INDIA's population which has become very high'' both laughed. so it is clear that in this kind of situation a person having reasonable intellegence will not take the statements seriouly.
this could be the case of abettment by intigation but for abettment by instigation mens rea is a must. but in this case there is no mens rea so this can never be an offence of abettment.
she is not at all responsible for the abettment of suicide.

Answer 3

it is been my adventure as a nurse that if somebody talks approximately suicide, they many times save on with with the aid of. besides the incontrovertible fact that, noone can somewhat are awaiting what a afflicted guy or woman "ought to" do. i could say no, she isn't to blame. And as unhappy because it is that it did in certainty take place, we are able to all say now that particular, she ought to have advised somebody. we've all jokingly stated quicker or later in our lives, that we are gonna bounce out a window, or in spite of )perhaps reason nothings going precise that day)....by no ability which ability it although. In a suicide case, noone is somewhat to blame....altho those close to to him will experience some experience of guilt...thats in elementary terms organic. yet to respond to your question, except this guy or woman definitely witnessed him taking the OD of pills, or slitting his/her wrists, or definitely observed him putting a noose for the motive of killing him/herself and did no longer something approximately it, then no. yet Im valuable theres some ambulance chasing lawyer accessible someplace who will attempt to tutor in any different case.

Answer 4

I don't feel she is responsible for his action at all. Perhaps his family should have kept him a little closer to them considering the stress he was under. Even they are not responsible for his actions. He Is.

Answer 5

Suicide, by definition, is a crime the perpetrator and the victime both commit. There's no one else involved.

Answer 6

Not at all... Although one may argue that she might have influenced his final decision

Answer 7

If your q is to say Y or N i will then say N

Answer 8

Nope...

Answer 9

No

Answer 10

No.