ISLAM AND NAZISM: Are the similar levels of intolerance, uniformity, and genocide a coincidence?

Question

In fairness to the Nazis, they didn't committ as many genocides with as many murders as the Muslims (see Arab Muslim Invasions of India - greatest genocide in human history).

Also, Nazis did accept and respect some minute aspects of other cultures and even participated in the Olympics, where Muslims for the most part, reject all non-islamic culture and, despite numbering in the billions, almost entirely reject the Olmpics and the intra-continental commoradery it engenders.

That said, the parallels are astounding. Both cultures believe in totalitarian control and the superiority of their kind (see Dhimminitude and compare to the Arian myth).

Also, the intolerance of the Nazis and Muslims are absolutely the same. I suppose its no coincidence that Muslim SS troops were some of the last to fight for Hitler (google it).

Answer 1

Persians, Greeks, Chinese nomads, Arabs, Portuguese, British and other raiders, with the Aryans being first, all invaded India. I don't understand why you are trying to point out that Muslims did this. Have you ever looked at what happened in Africa? Or do you pick and choose who is right and wrong? It is ok, that Israel invaded Palestine and took their land. No one will say anything about them. Israel is killing people on a daily basis over land. Oh, it is OK that they kill Palestinians right?( because what these Jews suffered from the Germans.)

Answer 2

Islam is the only monotheist religion whos canonical doctrines demand all non-Muslims (kufir) be either converted, reduced to dhimmi status (second class) or death. There are no other choices in Islam. Christianity, Catholicism and Judiasm reformed their respective religions to eliminate the militaristic, mysoginistic and bigoted verses long ago. Islam has not. There is a concept called Ijtihad and it means "the gate" or "the door" and it is the way that the Islamic ulema reopens questions concerning the Koran and sharia. This is the only way Islam can modify or change any of its basic tenents and this "door" has been closed for over 1,000 years. The Islamic clerics, as well as the ulema have stated in no uncertain terms that "Ijtihad" will not be opened, that there will be no study and modification of Islamic doctrine or law now or in the forseeable future. Until that happens, Islam will forever be stuck in the 7th century with no chance to show the world that they are not as dangerous as a lot of us believe. Let me end by posing this question.....since 9-11 over 11,000 attacks by fundamental Islamists have occured worldwide. Show how many fundamental Christians or Catholics have attacked or killed innocents because the Pope, or Christian leaders told them, by using chapter and verse from the Bible to do so.

Answer 3

By lumping any group of people together, and deciding they are evil so easily, you are just as bad as the people you are preaching against.

There were Nazi's that did awful things. There were also Nazi's who fought for Germany because they had to, because their families were collateral, because the German government was to powerful to fight against in their eyes. Not every soldier that fought for Germany during WWII was a monster.

There are Muslims that have down awful things. There are also Muslims that disagree with suicide bombings, that believe in a peaceful society, and want nothing more than to be seen for what THEY are- not this preconcieved notion of what all Muslims are.

You are just as intolerant as those you hate by disregarding who a person is, and instead seeing them as this two dimensial cartoon figure that you can focus your hate on.

Answer 4

slave of 12 gods, that isn't very true!

More Christians than anybody have been killed off, mostly by muslims in most cases. Get your facts straight.

In what is now Turkey, there were once more than a dozen Christian nations. Where are the ethnic groups now that once filled those wiped out nations with native citizens? muslims aided the nazis. muslims inspired hitler with how to treat the Jews, Gypsies, and Kazars, with what they did first to the Armenians, Greeks, and Assyrians in Asia Minor.

The Arabs have been whittling down the Assyrians in Mesopotamia, the Copts in Egypt, and the Sudanese in Sudan.

The list goes on and on. hitler's contibution to the cess pool was but a drop in all of islam's big filling of the pool.

As for the idea that Israel has "Plaestine's" land, most "palestinians"are nothing but Arabs. Arabs never were related to Palestinians. But they wish to run another ethnic group that has many Christian members, and make them all obey sharia, under an Arab umbrella. In Egypt they are trying to swallow the real Egyptians, as also the Assyrians in the land that is rightly Assyria, and the Aramaic people in Syria, and the Cana'anite population of Lebanon, and the other non-Arab peoples in Jordan. They can't stand anyone in Arabia but they are trying to take all the world and make all Arabs.

Arabs were not in Israel until after the death of muhammad.

Answer 5

Social awareness is of the greatest importance but not by comparing whos atrocities are the best . Both nazi mentalities and religious intolerance and ignorance have no place in the future if one really respects the value of morality.
peace and justice have a good life

Answer 6

Um, you forget that many Arab Muslims fought for the allies in WWII.

Further, if Islam is so bad, why do Christian still exist in North East Africa, the Arab Penninsula and Persia.

Your comparisons are way off. Look at what Germany did to the Jews across Europe?

There are still millions of Christians in the Islamic and Arab world.

How many Jews are left in Germany?

Answer 7

First of all I respect people of Christian faith and other faith.

But I have to update your information Nazi Germans were and are Christians.

By the way no Arab Muslim invaded India.

Mahmood Ghaznavi was not Arab Muslim, and by the way His Military chief was a Hindu (Shocked, aren’t you?).

Bombing (Nuke) on innocent citizens of Hiroshima, and Nagasaki was done by Non Muslims, you know who were those?

Ready fields has been burned and drinking water poisoned in Vietnam by NonMuslims, do you know who were those?

Millions Jews in Germany were burned to death by Non-Muslims, do you know who were those?

List is still long and go further long, do want to keep going?

See Hitlers link with Christian Church:
http://emperors-clothes.com/vatican/cpix.htm

Answer 8

I suggest we condemn the deed rather than the doer. Let us take it from Socrates: "My opinion is more or less this: no wise man believes that anyone sins willingly or willingly perpetrates any base or evil act; they know very well that every base or evil action is committed involuntarily." Or we may take it from Jesus: "forgive them for they do not know what they are doing." What I mean is that we condemn the murder, but forgive the murderer. If this is too hard for all of us, how can we have peace in this world?

Answer 9

As a mainline Christian, I find lumping all "Muslims" into a fanatical group to be compared with Nazi's as not only offensive but revealing of an ignorant and un-nuanced reading of history.

Fundamentalist followers of Islam, Christianity, or a political system such as Nazism and Facism are all "terrorists" of one degree or another.

Answer 10

ok, i really liked the last part of the statement, it drives home your point well

"Also, the intolerance of the Nazis and Muslims are absolutely the same. I suppose its no coincidence that Muslim SS troops were some of the last to fight for Hitler"

Saddam Hussein idolized Adolf Hitler to a degree