I want to ask this question from Muslims?

Question

Quran says believe whatever I have sent to Moses, Jesus and David. Then why Muslims don’t believe Torah, Injeel and Psalm. They believe only Quran. I asked from a Muslim why don’t you believe other books he answered me we believe but these book have been changed and not in real form. Now question is this, if any Muslim says ‘yes I believe in Quran but this Quran is not real one but was changed after the death of Muhammad’. Does with such believe any person be called the believer of Quran? If no then how a Muslim can be called a believer of books with having claim that books were changed. It simply shows Muslims are not following their own Quran which categorically says believe in Torah, Injeel and Psalms. How a Muslim can justify this contradiction in their faith?

fgfgfdsgfdgfd

Quran is confirming all privious books as said in these following verses.
"Say (O Muhammad Peace be upon him ): "Whoever is an enemy to Jibrael (Gabriel) (let him die in his fury), for indeed he has brought it (this Quran) down to your heart by Allahs Permission, confirming what came before it (i.e. the Taurat (Torah) and the Injeel (Gospel)) and guidance and glad tidings for the believers.
( Al-Baqara, Verse #97)

And when there came to them (the Jews), a Book (this Quran) from Allah confirming what is with them (the Taurat (Torah) and the Injeel (Gospel)), although aforetime they had invoked Allah (for coming of Muhammad Peace be upon him ) in order to gain victory over those who disbelieved, then when there came to them that which they had recognised, they disbelieved in it. So let the Curse of Allah be on the disbelievers.
( Al-Baqara,Verse #89)
If Quran is confirming privious book then why Muslims are not ready to confirm? If cruppted then why God confirmed?

Answer 1

I would firstly tell you to show me proof that the Quran has changed..Of course you will not be able to. Even scholars in biblical studies in the United States could not prove it. I would secondly tell you I do believe in The Torah and Bible as long as they are authenticated versions with little changed since the first publication of them.

Answer 2

I am not a muslim. But to answer your question about whether muslims contradict themselves then yes they are contradicting. They do believe in all holy books and respect all books. But you forgot to mention that the quran also says that the holy books have been changed by man and also says that god has preserved quran until the day of judgement.
A factor (I beleive) that helped quran stay preserved is that the language it was written in (1400 years ago) arabic is still used to this day so it didn't need translation, unlike Injeel and Torah which was written way back in the post-biblical time with a diffrent language and had to be translated through the thousands of years, which was bound to have caused confusion in the texts.

But there are so many similarities between all the holy books which is one of the reasons why i have started to believe that all these religions have the same god because so many similarities isn't just pure coincidence!!

If you are confused then you should go to google.com and search these out yourself.

Answer 3

Had Muhammad ever read the books of Torah, Solomon's proverb, or Gospel? How could he read, he was an illiterate.

He didn't notice that gospel forbids polygamy.

Don't answer with transliteration reasons. The Bible translation is authentic, we've got the 1960 years old manuscripts

**********
Hey U who thumbs me down, I;m just explaining the facts that:
1. Muhammad is in illiterate, there's no way he could read Gospel & Torah by the time he claimed angel Gabriel annointed him. He could hardly memorize the 10 commandments.
2. Islam permits polygamy, where christianity & gospel ban it.
3. Gospel is authentic. The authorized english version has no error. We even made the concordance and numerize all the Greek/Hebrew words written on the Bible

Answer 4

It become truly who to steer the Muslim us of a after the leave of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh). Shias say the relations of Prophet (pbuh) ought to take the rule of thumb that's to be like a form of Kingship. Rule a son after yet another. Sunnis evaluate piety and righteousness of someone specially. everyone who's the astounding to be ruled is elected by Islamic way of determining on regularly called a 'Shoora' (Mutual consultation). The companions did Shoora and chosen 'Abubakar (R.A) because the first Caliph of Islam'. There are nevertheless many differances in a lot of non secular concerns.some are major at the same time as many others are minor subject matters. both worship the only God and performance an same Holy Quran and are followers of the astounding Messenger (pbuh). we've the judgement day the position Allah will choose each and every soul and rewards in accordance to one's beliefs and deeds.

Answer 5

If a person carefully go through all the books including Quran, then, he himself will come to the conclusion to which book he should believe at present.
God says in Quran that " Inna Nazzalnal Quraana, Wa inna Lahoo Lahaafizoon" The meaning of this worse is " I have sent the teaching in Quaran and I only will protect it"
God has sent this quaranic worse just to prove that the books which were sent on Prophet Abraham and Prophet Moses or Prophet Jesus (peace be upon them) are changed by the people.
So in the thought of a Muslim does not come that any Koranic worse are changed.
I am sorry to say my brother that one should never quarrel but one should read all the books and understand them and then do firm practice on one in which he believes.
Any way finally no human being is going to punish any human being on this basis. God only has to finalise and punish human beings if human beings had not followed his message.

Answer 6

-God sent the Quran because the previous books were corrupted,and if the Quran were corrupted (it wasn't) God would send another book to correct the the Quran,and so on,but fortunately God promised that the Quran won't be corrupted and that he won't send any more books.

-By the way,we don't even need to read the Bible,we have the latest version of the book from God,and we don't need to look at older versions,we just believe that the Torah and the Injeel were among the books God sent in the PAST and ceased to have any role nowadays.

-I don't think this is very hard to understand,i believe too that there was a book sent with Abraham (pbuh),should i now search for this book because i believe it was from God,it is PAST and i don't need it any more,i have the latest uncorrupted 100% perfect book from God, and God rewrote all the important stuff that were in the previous scriptures in the Quran.

Answer 7

God sent prophets to teach mankind. When a new Prophet comes, he replaces the earlier one. You cant expect people who followed Moses, to follow Abraham. They believe in Abraham but since they are living in Moses' time, its only appropriate to follow Moses. Likewise, when Jesus came, its only appropriate to follow Jesus then to follow John the Baptist (Prophet Yahya).
Among the prophets, He chose a few of them who came with laws to the people. When a Prophet came with a New Law, that law supercedes the previous one.
As such, since the Prophet Muhammad is the Last of All Prophets, he automatically becomes the One to follow. And the Book revealed to him by God, has become The Final Revelation.
Its true that Muslims have to believe in all of God's revelation, provided that they have remained the same as how they were revealed. But, its been proven unanimously that all the earlier revelations have been altered, save the Quran.
So, it only make Sense, Common Sense that as Muslims, we follow the Prophet Muhammad and the Glorious Quran.

Answer 8

ANy muslim says that quran has changed, he becomes nonbeliever directly, i didnt hear a muslim says that. this is very very rare.
believing in torah and enjeel means believe that these books comes for Moses and Jesus, but that doesnt mean follow its content and that because they have been manipulated by people while Quran is not.
So we are following the real bible and the real Torah.

Answer 9

The Koran cannot be reconciled with the Injeel or Torah. If an imam taught the Injeel or Torah, he would be disproving the Koran. Straight up, this is the reason every Muslim will say that they are corrupted.
Jesus himself taught:
My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me- John 10:27.
How was this verse corrupted?

Answer 10

It also says WOMEN are NOT to fight war


but they are teaching boys and little girls

to hate with Mickey Mouse songs and

allowing girls to strap on bombs and die

for Allah.

MORE MUSLIMS should speak out

against these things that full af hate and

death that is NOT tought by Mohammad

or the Quran/Koran.