Why would America give illegal aliens green cards instead of starting a new guest worker program? #2?

Question

I was not really happy with the answers the first time I asked this question, so I'm going for a second opinion here...

The whole idea is ridiculous! If America needs workers in certain fields, secure our borders, and start a good guest worker program. Let them come legally, and leave legally 2 or 3 year at a time. If they don't follow the rules they should be jailed on a work farm. Any other plan is total bulls,,t! And I'm tired of hearing that these people are only working the jobs that Americans don't want. I can tell you from personal experiance that is also bulls..t! Come on Americans, stand up! You will all be sorry in ten years when it is hard for your kids to find jobs... then you will understand. THEN IT WILL BE TOO LATE! Let it also be known that if the government is allowed to do this once, be assured they will pull the SH.T again.

Guest worker plan and secure the border! Finished!

Answer 1

There is a greater more pressing question. We don’t want illegal aliens here, we don’t want to give them amnesty. Why doesn’t our government represent us?

Answer 2

I trust what you have suggested. different than... The inhabitants of Mexico on the instant's barely 106+ million human beings now. I exceptionally doubt that over the subsequent 2 many years there are going to be a hundred of that 106 million human beings flocking to the U. S. to take part interior the focused visitor worker software. this type of intense inflation of the numbers won't be able to probably provide a real looking image as to what the focused visitor worker software will appear as if 2 many years down the line so it relatively is impossible to furnish a knowledgeable answer to this question.. ought to you please submit a link to the place you acquire your guidance from. playstation Bryan... thank you for the link. I examine the object yet i did no longer see evidence of the place they are coming up with the a hundred million immigrant parent. the background foundation is bringing up a hundred million. no longer Senators McCain or Kennedy. They proceed to quote a hundred million yet there is not any longer something to tutor their assumption. i think of it relatively is a incorrect diagnosis. i may well be attracted to sorting out their reaction in case you have been to pursue the question returned to them. i'm particular no longer all the unlawful immigrants that go our borders are Mexican however the final public of them are. what number of human beings from Gautemala, El Salvador, Nicaraugua, Honduras or Panama do you hear are illegally getting into our u . s . from the south. they are Mexican. One concept which you would be able to contemplate. Why might this corporation cite a a hundred million parent and characteristic it to the proportion of people we've residing right here and not state that their a hundred million parent is virtually a hundred pc of the entire inhabitants of Mexico the place merely about all those individuals are coming from? ought to this is that by ability of affirming what I merely typed makes their diagnosis untrustworthy as a results of fact all of us comprehend a hundred% of the inhabitants of Mexico has no purpose on migrating into the U. S.? Iam no longer disputing what you examine.. i'm disputing what they say.

Answer 3

imagine if all those illegal immigrants in US would pay taxes tomorrow because they become legal... it will help the huge american deficit a bunch... and maybe, bush will be able to spend the money going to Iran.
it's only for the money those people represent in extra tax income... that's no christmas present

Answer 4

You are correct, of course. I stand with you and invite others to reply in kind.

.