It seems no one here can answer these 3 questions, Without quoting some crap of the bible. Lets see if you can

Question

1. How can god create matter from nothing, Scientific law proves (With physical evidence) That matter CANNOT be created or destroyed . 2. If god created everything, then he must be outside of everything... Therefore he is nothing . 3. If god is all good, and he gave us all free will to do whatever we want. If a child in the road got run over by a maniac... Where is the childs free will? There was nothing it could do to prevent it? (Knowingly)

To whoever can answer these questions WITHOUT quoting the bible or saying crap like "With god anything can be done)

The you get best answer, Even if i don't agree with it

To story junkie, Apparently god is all knowing right, He somehow knew he was going to create life and death before he even discovered it... Which is also impossible

Answer 1

There is no God and so there is no answer.

Answer 2

1. How can god create matter from nothing, Scientific law proves (With physical evidence) That matter CANNOT be created or destroyed . 2. If god created everything, then he must be outside of everything... Therefore he is nothing . 3. If god is all good, and he gave us all free will to do whatever we want. If a child in the road got run over by a maniac... Where is the childs free will? There was nothing it could do to prevent it? (Knowingly)

To whoever can answer these questions WITHOUT quoting the bible or saying crap like "With god anything can be done)


1.I find funny how you compare the two God vs. Science.
2.If God did not matter to you, why try so hard to find out what we have to say.
3. You can not compare free will to a childs death. That doesnt even belong in the same sentence.
4.Your searching for something and you want to pretend like you dont care, but you do.
6.Science vs God has been going on for centuries and will continue when we are gone.
7.But why when Twins are born they do better together than in seperate incubators. Can Science Answer that ??
8.Why when newborn babies are born start to only react when they hear their mother or fathers voice.hmm I guess Science has all the answers.

Answer 3

1. If there is a God, He is outside all laws because He CREATED the laws. Science only says that matter cannot be created because THEY can't create it. They forget they're not God!
2. Just because something is outside of everything doesn't mean it's nothing. You're trying to apply human laws and logic to something that, if indeed it exists, is distinctly NOT human.
3. The person who ran down the child had free will. It's a shame that ONE person's free will can destroy so much. Hitler had free will, and look what he did with it. Perhaps it would have been better for millions of people if HE had been run over as a child.

Look, we see through a glass darkly. All we know, as far as life and death is concerned, is what we see around us. We can't see the life and death of every person that has lived, will live, and is living, nor can we see what effect their life and death has on everything else. It's like we're in a dark tunnel, and we can't see more than a few steps behind, nor can we see more than a couple steps ahead (if even that), and we can't look from left to right. We can't even see what effect those on the other side of the tunnel WILL have, or are having, on anyone else. We're just groping blindly for the end of the tunnel.

It's not a happy picture, but it's true.

Answer 4

I'm not a Christian, but I'll give it a go...

1.There's really no such thing as "matter" in quantum mechanical physics. Matter is mostly space. Macro objects are energy particles are held together by nuclear or static forces, and at the quantum level particles are waves, or waves are particles, depending on what the researcher measures. The more energy scientists use to reveal smaller particles, the more the quantum foam produces hints of even more smaller particles! Therefore the basis of matter, can be said to be irrational, and at least for now, the best answer could be consciousness!

2. In the Big Bang Theory the Primal Particle was all energy, had no width, height, or depth, and there was no time, or space -- there was no outside! God was the "outside".

3. The universe is neither good, evil, moral or immoral -- most of these traits are dualities , Like Fe/Male, white/black, yin/yang - these are concepts humans invented , and many of them help us organize ou World View, are really human traits projected on Heaven. God didn't promise riches, or life free from tragedy or pathos-- another human trait outta projected on to Her. (see how easy it is to give an abstract a value?

Therefore,for many, God may or may not exist, but He/She/It is quite Real :-Þ

Answer 5

1. How can god create matter from nothing, Scientific law proves (With physical evidence) That matter CANNOT be created or destroyed


I dont need physical evidence from a man who says this
is how it is and thinks he has proven it. If man is so all knowing , why are they after all of these years still so unaware of all the answers to the universe. With all due
respect who set the measuring stick that says this is this
or that is that.... How can an atom come from nothing?
It was just there? Well I say God was just there, He just is.
How can God create matter from nothing? I dont know how
he did it, maybe I will ask Him some day but I doubt it will
matter much to me how He did it.


2. If god created everything, then he must be outside of everything... Therefore he is nothing .
God is spirit , spirit cannot be contained.

. 3. If god is all good, and he gave us all free will to do whatever we want. If a child in the road got run over by a maniac... Where is the childs free will? There was nothing it could do to prevent it? (Knowingly

God is in control of all things. Even the things we do not
understand presently. We have a will , but I dont see it as
free at least not in the way most people do. I had an 11 year
old cousin who had the IQ of a genius. At his young age
he was just about to start his first year of college. When a
drunk driver struck him by a car and killed him instantly. I
was very close to this cousin and did not understand why
this happened. He was killed right before I was to go visit
him for the summer. He would tell me that at school he didnt
fit in because the kids called him a nerd ect. He would take
his bible to school and get picked on even more. He used
to tell me that he didnt fit in this world. After he died I took
it very hard. I went home after three days of his mother
having him on life support. I had a dream. In my dream an
angel came to me. He was male and light shown around him.
He was naked but I could not see his nakedness from the
white light. He looked at me and said, David is happy now
he is at peace and he is with me. Then the angel layed down
on the floor and folded his arms over his chest and the room
was filled with great peace. Believe what you like, but I know
that I know that God sent that angel to give me peace about
my cousin dying so tradgically.

Answer 6

1. Modern theories and experiments involving quantum mechanics throw the ideas of conservation of mass into some doubt. I suggest looking up quantum vacuum effects and quantum vacumm energy.

2. Yes this seems to be correct. If God, as some Christians claim, exists outside of our space and time then God would nave no way of interacting with our space and time. So in effect God would not exist in our Universe.

3. The whole free will idea comes about because of the problem of predictability. If your God is all knowing about the future then everything is pre-ordained and free will does not exist. In Newtonian physics the idea is mantained by the concept that if you could know the state of the universe at any moment you could predict every following event just like a pool game. The quantum view is that you can not know the state of any particle. if you are certain of its location then you don't know the velocity. If you know the velocity you can't know its location.(Heisenberg uncertainty principle) and even worse is that quantum events are unpredictable and seem to depend upon what the observer is trying to observe. Predictability is not always applicable. If it was then Psychics would be considered normal.
--------------------
Now one of the problems is that people are using 300 year old physics to make their arguments without realizing how much has changed in our knowledge. It would help the levels of discussion greatly if the schools could teach modern science to public school kids instead of being strangled by religions.

By the way, I don't belive God is real. I think God is just an unsuported conjecture, not even a hypothesis, much less a theory.

Answer 7

1. God did not create matter, satan did. He did not create it out of nothing, he had to give up part of himself to make the matter. 2. God did not create everything. He started the creating process by creating The Holy Spirit and co-creating Jesus. Every step in the creative process takes the ones produced further away from God. God has never moved or changed. He is somewhere, just not in the physical universe. God is not a pantheist. 3. There are 3 parts to your last question: A. It was freewill when the child's spirit chose who it's parents would be. B. It was freewill when the child chose to be in that road. C. The child's spirit will return again until it has a chance to accept or reject God. God is just. Thanks for a great question, you made me think this morning.

Answer 8

1. God didn't create matter from nothing. Matter has always existed although science seems to indicate it can be converted to energy and back.
2. This is a meaningless philosophic word game. It's logically impossible for God to create himself. Is it easier to believe that matter always existed or that some intelligent and powerful being always existed or that either popped into existence? God has always existed just like matter.
3. Agency, or freewill is not the same as freedom. People can and do take away other people's freedom. God gave us the power to choose how we will respond to any circumstance. This is freewill. This may not seem fair to you, but earth life wasn't designed to be fair in the short term -- it was designed to help God's children grow and develop by letting them experience both good and bad choices.

Answer 9

It is not logical to ask a question and then put limits on the way people will answer this is illogical and very immature.
Your obvious antagonism towards believers is a sign of your inner confusion.
God cannot be pinned down by human science and you should know this, the laws that apply to us as created beings do not apply to the Creator so my advice to you is to stop trying.
There is no reason to suppose that God has to exist in our demension so yes in this sense He is outside of everything but being God can enter our time and space at will.
The gift of free will does not and cannot stop accidents and in the case you quoted it has nothing to do with the child but the drivers carelessness, free will is the freedom to choose what is right not the right to do anything you want and this is where most get it wrong.

Answer 10

1. Where did matter come from? Was there a beginning to the existance of matter or has it always existed in eternity past? If there was a begining to it, then I guess it was created from nothing.
2. I don't get the logic of that. God existed before He created anything. Then He created everything.

3. If a child dies young, was He or she robbed of a life of free will? Who says free will ends at death? if life continues afterward, then I guess making choices can be part of the afterlife too.

Answer 11

1. I think that God is more or less an entity that just kind of oversees all and lets it play out as it may. Occaisionally, he intervenes, which might be why the dinosaurs croaked. So, I think that things pretty much evolved on their own, over time.

2. God should not be considered nothing so much as he should be considered omnipotent. I do not believe in "God" I believe in something much greater than all of us that exists outside of the physical perimeters. So, he is spiritually inside everything but invisible otherwise. Pfft, Christian logic.

3. The child had the free will, but uncontrolled circumstances by which it died.