illegal aliens, debate. please help!?

Question

so, my history class is debating on illegal aliens. wether we should completely outlaw them on death, or what the consiquences should be. my team, has to defend them, saying that it is ok for them to be here, just that they have to work and such, which is whythey come here. can anyone give me more reasons why they should be able to stay here, even if u arent for them being here, can u think of reasons why it would be ok? thanks if u can. also, pictures of bad conditions in mexico, or even other nations that come over here illegally, pictures are good too! thanks a lot

don't say things that won't help me, if u cna help, please do, if not, i really dont want to read through a bunch of asnwers that are like (2 points!) go do that in the freaking penis section. lol. thanks a lot of u actually can help!

Answer 1

Just some facts for ya!

"Beyond taxes, these workers' production and spending contribute to California's economy, especially the agricultural sector," Gonzalez said.

Immigrants, both legal and illegal, are the backbone of the state's nearly $28 billion-a-year agricultural industry, Gonzalez and other researchers say.

More than two-thirds of the estimated 340,000 agriculture workers in California are noncitizens, most of whom are believed to be illegal immigrants, according to a 1998 study on farmworkers prepared for the state Legislature.

Local farmers say migrant farmworkers are critical to their businesses, and without them they would have to close their farms or move their operations overseas.

Answer 2

All ppl are raised with particular ethical and ethnics although the words priority of ethnic does not compute. What you look asking is debating ones way of life and how they have been raised or the region they have been given right here from to justify ones view on a rule of regulation of an others united states of america. What it comes each and every of how all the way down to is that if one gets a fashion with something why quit it if it reward them and no person stops them. Any rational individual is super conscious in case you will choose to pass to the scale of sneaking precise right into a place they're breaking a regulation. It has now not something to do with cultural, ethnics or something.

Answer 3

HIYA,i`m from the UK and came here four years ago,i married my US girlfriend in LAS VEGAS and we`ve known each other for 15 years plus ,we settled in montana with our kids and built our first house which just before selling burnt to the ground along with our immigration papers,then one year later it happened again only this time it was our temporary accommodation that burnt with again all our paperwork,since then i`ve been diagnosed with MS and i need a hip replacement,all this since we came here for the American Dream.
As a result you could call me an Illegal Alien but for the fact that i have the Alien registration number just not the paperwork and that cost money we can ill afford right now.
hope this is usefull to you.

Answer 4

Well, is your project on illegal aliens, or on illegal aliens from Mexico? The first thing you need to realize is that they aren't all Mexican (although its the largest group of all - legal and illegal - immigration) - they are all different nationalities. And, they don't all come here for economic reasons, or because they are poor - some are religious reasons, some are political reasons, some want to join up with family, etc.

Answer 5

First of all, you're screwed, you're on the wrong team.

I find no good reasons to allow illegal aliens to stay here. The arguments about doing work that American's won't do is incorrect. They overload the welfare, social security and medical systems.

Showing pictures just points out reasons why they should go back where they came from and change THAT situation.

If you pull this off, La Raza will be calling you.

Answer 6

1. The fruits of capitalism requires the absolute and unfettered flow of labor and kapital to where is can be used most productively. Preventing this flow will reduce economic output, consumption, and opportunities.

2. The socialist response of impeding the flow of labor and mollycoddling the pathetic pansy-assed losers also impedes evolution and survival of the fittest.

Answer 7

If they are coming here to work, it's not a problem, because they add to the economy.

If they are coming here to sponge off of the government freebies (you know what they are) then maybe the problem is the government freebies. Who wouldn't risk their lives to go from a mud hut to a free apartment, free food, and free healthcare?

Answer 8

In order to fully understand this issue you have to look at our history with Mexico, and how all this has shaped our country and theirs....

Go to this website, it breaks down the history of the Mexican immigrant in this country....Gives you great insight and answers many questions about both legal and illegal immigration....Best of luck!

http://rs6.loc.gov/learn/features/immig/mexican.html

Answer 9

well i lived in mexico and let me tell you if you want to eat bean and eggs everyday or on somedays nothing. Also it cost so much money down there. Its also not pretty .

Answer 10

Watch this video. See if you can bring it to class and show ppl the results of illegal immigration.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SpomTIkv0V8