genetic engineering and catholic view?

Question

why is this so wrong??

Answer 1

The Catholic Church teaches about genetic engineering:

In moral evaluation a distinction must be made between strictly manipulation, which aims to cure illnesses caused by genetic or chromosome anomalies (genetic therapy), from manipulation the human genetic patrimony.

A curative intervention, which is also called ‘genetic surgery,’ ‘will be considered desirable in principle, provided its purpose is the real promotion of the personal well-being of the individual, without damaging his integrity or worsening his condition of life.

On the other hand, interventions which are not directly curative, the purpose of which is 'the production of human beings selected according to sex or other predetermined qualities,' which change the genotype of the individual and of the human species, 'are contrary to the personal dignity of the human being, to his integrity and to his identity.

Therefore they can be in no way justified on the pretext that they will produce some beneficial results for humanity in the future,' 'no social or scientific usefulness and no ideological purpose could ever justify an intervention on the human genome unless it be therapeutic, that is its finality must be the natural development of the human being.'

-- Charter for Health Care Workers, 12

Here is a site with offical Church teaching on genetic engineering: http://www.marymeetsdolly.com/

With love in Christ.

Answer 2

*Is Catholic* Genetic Engineering has been happening because of the fact the commencing up of agriculture. maximum if no longer all nutrition plant life and kin animals have been genetically changed by way of human interest (breeding, culturing, circulate-breeding, and so on.). in this sense, the Catholic faith has no subject with genetic engineering. cutting-area medical genome manipulation, embryonic cloning, there is and may well be a brilliant debate approximately. concerning human beings, that's on no account permissible because of the fact it would take care of the human guy or woman as an animal. Catholic coaching might agree thoroughly with the arguments in A brave NEW worldwide. with regard to genetically enhancing plant life and animals, this may well be permissible see you later as that's a to blame interest executed to sell the effort-loose sturdy (alongside with ailment resistant wheat, cows that produce drugs of their milk, and so on.)

Answer 3

The Catholic views that were almost forced into my brain while growing up made so little sense and had so many contradictions that I finally came to the resolution that meaning has no meaning when it comes to faith.

Any sort of medical intervention could be construed as messing with God's will, so focusing only upon those things having to do with S E X say more about the attitudes of the Church than their intellectual abilities.

Answer 4

God is the only legitimate genetic engineer. He is the one who decides what characteristics each person has.

Don't you think it's peculiar how animals are "all the same", but each person is so obviously UNIQUE?

We all have a purpose, a reason for being. That reason for being is as unique as the individual. We are all given characteristics that help us accomplish our unique purpose. To interfere with one's genetic makeup is to interfere with one's Divinely assigned reason for being.

Even superficial things like eye color, hair color. Somehow, even the superficial details of our being are part of our reason for being. So, to interfere with something as seemingly mundane as hair/eye color, can have a disasterous effect on one's ability to accomplish their Divinely assigned purpose.

We are not supposed to decide for ourselves what our genetic makeup is. That is for God to determine, and God alone.