Are German Shepherds good guard dogs?

Question

hi i wanna know if female german shepherds are good guard dogs. I have a female 17 week old german shepherd i wanna know when she will become more protective and her guarding instincts come about like at what age in her life...Please can neone tell me what age she will become protective...and i will give my dog the best care and love so people dont have to give me any long lectures about dog care just experienced people who know....thank you. Also just as a side question which sex of dog is more aggressive and protective to intruders and strangers?

Answer 1

I own a 20 month old male GSD so I have a little experience with this. Ours became fully protective of our family around 12-14 months old ( he would bark at strangers to let me know someone was near our home, however if he knew them he would give one small bark and that was it) as to which sex is better at guarding?...it all depends on the dog and there personality. just my opinion, hope it helped.

Answer 2

My first dog was a belgian Tervueren. She had to be taught to bark and didn't start barking at people ringing the door bell until she was around 6-7 months (and it seemed more like fun to her than actually guarding). Her protection and guard instinct only fully kicked in when she was around two years old. They came automatically, she was never trained or encouraged in this direction. Pure instinct. I have been told that german shepherds mature faster than belgian sheperds, so you will probably notice it a bit earlier.

I've heard some people says that female dogs are more protective and aggressive than male dogs, but I have never observed any real difference myself with the belgian shepherds I've been in contact with. I don't know if it's different with german shepherds.

Remember with this type of dog you need to train the dog to trust your judgement and accept people you have given the thumbs up as friends. Also remember that the dog can't tell the difference between a burglar and your new neighbour.

Answer 3

We had two dogs, a tiny terrier and a German shepherd. That was a fantastic combination. The terrier heard things before the German Shepherd did and her barking would alert the bigger dog.
Our German Shepherd was very protective. She was an excellent guard dog. Our house was the only house in the street that wasn't burgled. I can't remember how old she was, but it was under a year. Certainly I wouldn't expect anything of your dog before it is full grown. And I don't know that the gender of the dog makes any difference.

Answer 4

German Shepherds are naturally good gaurd dogs,your female will need more training than a male will,but she can be just as aggressive as a male,male dogs such as make shepherds make better gaurds.your female wil start showing some aggression and protectiveness by the time she is around 30 weeks or so.

Answer 5

What do mean my protective? Of you, your house, your yard?

GSDs are very territorial, if they are not properly trained, you could have a mess on your hands. You would want her to protect you from an intruder, but the not the mail man. Training has to be handled with care.

Many people get GSDs to be a guard dog, and in their training create an unpredictable, aggressive dog. If you want to get the most out of her training, I highly recommend a dog trainer with GSD experience.

In general, males are the more aggressive of the sexes, but every dog is different.

Answer 6

GSD's can be just right protect dogs, but it's not anything that you could depend upon. Some naturally defend, some want coaching, some simply aren't excited by protecting more than a different breed could, but would warn you to hazard. In case you are worried about thieves and strangers, a protection approach or a digicam could be a better proposal. You will have to look after your dog, and in finding an additional method to defend you both.

Answer 7

There is no which sex is more protective or aggressive,if you have a "Alfa dominant" female she will be on top,a male Alfa same thing.When I answered your question regarding whether or not lots of loving will make her a sissy I told you about our 3 GSD's we have right now,2 males and a female.1 male is Alfa,the other is passive,but,the passive one when alone is just as loyal and protective as the other one,just alittle slower upon acting than the other one.My female is Alfa,and she IS the 4 legged ruler/boss/queen on the farm.Another big issue is confidence,if she is confedent in herself she will be all you need.I hope I've been of some help to you.

Answer 8

YES!

Imagine an alarm system that travels with you, is not easily inactivated, and interprets what it detects with a brain programmed by nature to read body language. Remember that many violent crimes are perpetrated by people known to their victims. People who are likely to be admitted into your home past your current detection system and then suddenly reveal their violent intent. That sudden change is easily detected and challenged by a well bred and trained dog.

The German Shepherd Dog (GSD) is a versatile working-dog, capable of being trained to perform a wide variety of tasks. GSDs are family pets, police dogs, guide dogs, search and rescue dogs, bomb and drug detection dogs, sheep and cattle herders, hunting companions, guard dogs, obedience champions, avalanche dogs, assistance dogs, show dogs, and more. Regardless of their particular role, GSDs are excellent companions provided they receive the attention, training, and exercise they need and feel useful.

on a personal note, my dad has bread and trained these dogs for over 25 years. Trained for guard dog, drugs, bombs, search and rescue etc.... they have even served on the RCMP. These dogs are fantastic for what you are looking for.... Good luck :)

Answer 9

GSD's could nicely be sturdy look after dogs, whether it is not something you are able to count number on. some needless to say look after, some choose preparation, some in basic terms are not attracted to conserving better than yet another breed could, yet could warn you to danger. in case you're frightened approximately thieves and strangers, a secure practices device or a digital camera could be a extra constructive thought. you should guard your dogs, and discover yet in any different case to shelter you the two.

Answer 10

my mom breeds german sheppard dogs and they are great watch dogs and their bark is out of this world . and she will become protective of you as she gets older . the male is definately more agressive and protective towards a female owner . and you will know when someone does not belong there where you live she or he will definately let you know . good luck and i hope I helped.