Will the pro-illegals tell me?

Question

If as you say "illegals are doing jobs that Americans wont do" then it only stands to reason that you believe these positions were developed/invented in America by industries and merchants for a labor force other than Americans. The question is...Match the job with the illegal. Tell us all what position was invented and for which foreign national it was created for.
For the record...I am pretty certain that not one single pro-illegal will answer this very simple question.

Answer 1

That whole "Jobs Americans won't do" is complete bull crap.
They only say it because they have no other valid argument to support their cause.

By the way, there have been cases were illegals have been deported by ICE and the jobs are immediately replaced by American workers who really want to work.

Answer 2

A lot of people seem to confuse legal migrant workers with illegal immigrants, as they seem to assume every Hispanic is an illegal immigrant. Migrant workers that come here legally are doing jobs that are hard to find Americans willing to do, not many Americans are willing to spend 12 hours a day picking strawberries, no matter what they paid. Legal migrant workers come through, pick some crops and go home. Illegals come here and stay. No one is pro illegal as far as I know, but a lot of people are tired of the illegal issue becoming justification for anti Hispanic bias.

And as far as companies that purposely sneak in illegals for a cheap labor force, they should stop with the petty fines and shut these companies down, throw the executives in prison.

Answer 3

I never believed this whole "jobs that americans won't do" reason because its not about being american or illegal what it basically comes down to is if you need to support your family and children what jobs are you willing to NOT do. Perhaps its better to rephrase your question into "what jobs will american's do for next to nothing in pay". For example the landscapers (not many americans are willing to be out in the hot sun busting their butts for less that six bucks an hour and long gone are the days when teenagers were willing to mow your yard for at least 10 bucks.now it seems most are busy getting high), Live in housekeepers/nannies (strangely enough a lot of people have these women working for them who enjoy the fact that they practically raise their children,teach them a foreign language at no charge and rarely talk back or ask for days off), and last but not least the crop pickers (same as the first one,rarely complain about the pay being low ,work from sun up till sundown, and whenever they become sick and can't be at work don't demand they still be paid for those days). Well hopefully I answered your question.

Answer 4

For this scenario to work there has to be a corporation willing to discriminate against an American. It says that the employer is knowingly breaking the law. I can not defend breaking the law. The criminal is the employer not the Illegal Immigrant. The person breaking the law should be detained at the cost of releasing the domestic drug users and the employer be fined and a required mandatory jail time assessed. This puts the illegal detained and the person who caused him to be here accountable.

Answer 5

IDK. Possibly due to a lack of real education. The world is full of countries that have been conquered, plundered, raped and pillaged over man's time here. Every person immigrated from somewhere else. No one is truly "native". They just happen to be the indigenous people encountered upon arrival of others. Even the Indians conquered, plundered, raped and pillaged from other Indians... So this nicey-nicey image of all indians being peaceful, sitting around smoking peace pipes is nonsense. The world of their time was barbaric. These fools who spew this ilk are the very vermin who undermine our constitutional rights as Americans!

Answer 6

The phrase should actually be, "Illegal immigrants do jobs Americans won't do BECAUSE labor unions have forced wages up so high that many companies cannot afford to pay Americans to to these jobs."

Think about it. So many "blue-collar" jobs have gone overseas because labor unions have made it very hard for these companies to keep their production costs down. Illegal immigrants provide cheap domestic labor because American labor unions are too greedy to allow any other option.

Answer 7

Its all just more pro lies nothing about their crap is true. You know what else bothers me is the women that marry or are shacked up with a illegal alien and become advocates for the whole Mexican race. They forget they are white and try to as Mexican as they can. They forget that they are legal citizens and dont know s*** about Mexico except what their illegal alien man tells them. I read that bull on here all the time. How can you degrade and disrespect your country for an illegal man. Are you that hard up for a man that you can turn your back on your own birthright?I'm not talking about any one thats legal,thats cool .I can accept that totally.
The price of produce wont go up that much is the illegals are sent home,thats more pro lies . Its just crap the liberal media is feeding the ignorant.

Answer 8

Well, you're kinda right and mostly wrong. Americans will do the jobs that the illegals are doing right now, just not for the wages paid to the illegals. If you want th see $10.00 heads of lettuce and $50.00 flower bouquets, then go ahead and deport all of the illegals.

Answer 9

I think majority of americans are educated and can therefore take jobs that require education...
on the other hand most illegals are illiterate or unskilled and therefore can take those jobs that do not require any education...

Answer 10

Well, I am not on the open borders side but I can tell you this. The jobs weren't created for anyone in particular. They are not a reason but rather a symptom of corporate geed and failed immigration policy.