Dog lovers & breeders. . .Pleas Help?!!!!?

Question

I want to adopt a doberman or rottie. . .I grew up with dogs, but this will be my first pup on my own. I wanted to know which would be a better dog start with. I was even considering a tosa inu. Can i please have some advice from expierenced owners, who can give suggestions on which dog would be a great decision? Thanks everyone!

Answer 1

I would say a Doberman...they are sweet and small...but they can hold down the fort if they need too...very protective also...They are easier to train than a rottie...Although i used to have a rottie and everyone told me the are too aggressive..thats not true..its all about how u treat them and Train them...They are great dogs too ! and it just depends on if u want a big or small dog..both are protective ...good luck with your decision....hope this helps

Answer 2

I prefer Tosas, but I'm partial to rare breeds. They're so stoic and powerful looking! They're very brave and loyal - they're also extremely intelligent and quiet. The only issue with a Tosa is that you must train them well from an early age - they are far too large and strong to be unmannerly. You must be able to handle very large breeds to handle these. Not exactly a great first dog. They require an experienced handler.

As was stated earlier, all of those you've chosen MAY have a tendency towards dog aggression due to them being dominant breeds. The Tosa was used for dog fighting as well, but if they're properly socialized, you shouldn't have a problem. Mainly Tosas and Rotties. Rottweilers have also been over bred in many areas due to the popularity issue - people have been breeding for money and not quality in temperment and health. So I would do a lot of research on the breeders available if you choose those.

I would go for a Doberman - I haven't met an aggressive one, although they do have that reputation. In fact, I've taken care of one that was a complete chicken! They're a high energy breed, so they will require plenty of exercise but I think they're the easiest to train. Good luck on your search! :]

Answer 3

I'd say go with the Rottweiler.

Here is my reasoning, and warnings.

Dobermans have been very popular for a long time. This had lead to breeding of dogs that should have been destroyed at birth, or that should have been neutered because of temperment defects. In my opinion these unethical breeders have practically ruined the breed. Unfortunately, the same thing is happening to Rottweilers.

Pick your breed and then do lots of research on breeders. Don't buy from a breeder who does not show their dogs. And be sure to ask for references and contact those people. Also contact the AKC and see if there are any complaints about the breeders.

These are large, potentially dangerous dogs. For safety and the sake of liability, you MUST have a dog with a good temperament. And you must give them good training. Doing anything else would be highly irresponsible.

You should also be aware that Dobes and Rotties are being made scapegoats for illegal dogfights, and stuupid owners who do not control their dogs. Many cities are passing ordinances banning large dogs. Most of these bans are aimed at Pit Bulls, but some include Rotties and Dobes.

And another thing to consider. Where are you going to keep the dog? If you say, "Outside," don't bother to get a dog at all. And big dogs inside can be quite a challenge. My Great Pyrnees is about the same size as a Rottie and her nose can reach any tabletop, and her tail can clear a coffee table in one sweep. At least you don't have that worry with bob-tailed dogs.

I am not trying to discourage you from getting a Dobe or Rottie, just pointing out some things you should consider.

Enjoy your new pup. And remember, whoever said that money cannot buy love never bought a dog.

Doc

Answer 4

Don't force someone to pursue YOUR interests. If you are interested in breeding dogs then you should be the one to breed them. Dog breeders don't make a profit. It may seem like they are but here are things a breeder has to do: Health checks and clearances for congenital defects depending on the breed, prenatal care for the mother, emergency care in case of difficulty whelping, materials and a location for the puppies to be raised by the mother. The mother needs an enormous amount of a high quality food both during and after her pregnancy. Vaccinations for the puppies and then you're stuck with dogs you can't sell. A reputable breeder will be registered with a national kennel club. Continental Kennel Club (CKC) is a registry for puppy mills and unrecognized breeds. Here's the other thing. If there is no breed club in the USA (or whatever country you are in) and you are the only person with this breed you won't have a diversified gene pool. Line breeding is okay only a few times before the gene mutation from inbreeding begins to cause health problems. There are millions or homeless animals and strays that are abused, tortured, killed, starved or dropped off in shelters. THOSE dogs need to be rescued and loved. Save those dogs.

Answer 5

All the breeds you list are wonderful dogs but they all have a tendency to dominance-aggression if they're not trained with a firm and experienced hand from puppyhood. A big challenge for a first puppy.

If you really want those breeds, may I suggest you start with a slightly older dog? By then their temperament is becoming more defined and if you choose carefully, you're less likely to wind up with a difficult dog. Sure, puppies are cute, but it doesn't last long. I've owned many dogs in my life, and those that I got when they were older, I most certainly loved them as much as ones I got as puppies.

Contact breeders, breed clubs, and rescue clubs in your area. Go to dog shows, meet breeders (and dogs!) face to face. Put the word out that you're looking. I'm sure there's a perfect dog out there for you!

Answer 6

Put on your running shoes, you'll be doing a lot of leg work for this one. I am sure you will be able to find either breed at a shelter, but also contact local breed specific rescue groups. They keep pets in their homes and learn their personality, then you could go and fill out a survey to help match you to the best dog for your needs. I have known wonderful dobies and rotts. and I'm sure there is one waiting for you.

Answer 7

it depends what you would like it for.but my personal opinion would be a German Shepard they are obedient clever easy to train beautiful loyal and great Gard dogs and they will Look after you i highly recemend this dog for you and do hope that you will chose a German Shepard as your dog. by the way they cost about $800 new zeal and money but are way worth it.

I give yo my best luck for your new choice of dog

Answer 8

I think both of those dogs can be vicious if u don't train them right. I consider u get a mini schnauzer. they r loving

Answer 9

A shitzu,just throw him a pillow and watch him go!!

Answer 10

Bichon Maltais....I swear you will not regret it