Who would you rather have on your team?

Question

Payton Manning or Tom Brady? Give the reasons why.

Answer 1

Peyton. There isn't that much difference in their ages.
Both have at least 7 more good years left in them.
They are both good, but if Adam Vinatieri had made those clutch kicks, Brady wouldn't have the reputation that he has now.

Answer 2

Peyton. Tom Brady is not that great of a QB, he has a great team around him. Tom is way overrated. He's pretty much a pretty boy punk in my opinion. Throwing all the short passes he does means nothing, David Carr and the Redskins QB proved it in '06 by tying the NFL completion record in a game, EACH.

Peyton is a well rounded, mature player who studies the game like a bible. He was raised to be who he is. Both the Colts and Pats had older teams and werent playing in 30 degree weather last time, it was a fair match for once, and who won?

Answer 3

All this talk about who Peyton has at WR and who Brady has at WR is pointless. Is it Peytons fault that the colts actually resign their players to lengthy contracts. Peyton makes his WRs great by forming a relationship. Brady could do the same if his WR's were signed for longterm. That being said I would take Peyton. Some one said that the D carried the colts to the superbowl, correct me If im wrong but, didnt the D carry brady to a few of his superbowls. I believe he had a better D then the colts. Seymour,Milloy,Mginnest,Bruschi, Harrison, Ty Law. The colts had a banged up sanders, and freeney. There corners sucked and Cato June was iight. Brady is not even in the same league as Peyton.

Answer 4

Payton Manning because he has the best arm with strength and accuracy and Tom Brady just doesn't have those features

Answer 5

Brady. This postseason he made JABAR GAFFNEY look like a pro bowl wide out. No WR what so ever for Brady, while Manning has 2 of the best in the game.

Plus if he's on my team, then Gisele Bundchen would be around all the time.

Answer 6

Manning. Brady is system QB he needs that system to flourish. I think Brady gets too much credit for the Pats winning, they have been the ultimate team. Manning would flourish in almost any system. Manning is as advertised, he was expected to win and be the best and he has been.

Answer 7

Tom Brady by far. Manning is good, but more of a system Qb. He throws a lot of passes in a dome and has some of the best WR's and linemen ever.
Brady is a one-man show.
All 32 GM's would agree, trust me.

Answer 8

Manning any day. I am so sick of hearing about Tom Brady! He is only a product of Belicheck's system. He is conservative. He didn't have a great career at Michigan, and he hasn't done anything spectacular on his own with the Pats. Put him on a losing team, he is nothing.
On the other hand, Manning is a smarter QB, Better arm, and has helped make his team and his offensive players better. However, If you want the ultimate leader, the guy who has made so many average players great, the guy who has always put his team on his shoulders win or lose.........you want the only 3 time MVP...........BRETT FAVRE

Answer 9

Tom Brady wins the championship...Peyton Manning gets yards...

I pick Tom Brady...EVERY time...

Answer 10

Well....Either, but Tom Brady is younger, has more rings, has proven to be able to play without great talent and big name players, and he's a great humble leader, kind of like Brett Favre in that regard, only with a "weaker" arm.

Tom Brady to Steve Smith...*drool*

Answer 11

Tom Brady because he has three rings Peyton Manning only has one and Peyton Manning gets his good stats because he has two great WR. and Tom Brady hasn't had any great recivers the past couple of years.

and remember he was a 6th rounder.