Are bmx bikes good for commuting?

Question

I was wondering...if I bought a bmx

I might learn some simple tricks but...
I'll probably only use it for transport like..going to school or somthing

would a bmx bike be good for this?

also...would a mountain bike be good for commuting

Answer 1

Depends on your route and (perhaps) where you can keep it once you reach your destination.

A BMX is a small-wheel, cramped riding position type of machine. For longer commutes, you'd either have to travel standing up, or suffering through an awkward cramped position for pedalling. It would take more effort to make the trip as well, due to the gearing (or lack of it).

A mountain bike would offer better riding position and better effort-to-pedal efficiency. The larger wheels would help for longer distances too.

However, the mountain bike may stand out more in the crowd of machines at your end destination, which might make it a bit more likely to be 'borrowed' and not returned to you, if you get my drift. The same could be true of the BMX, but is somewhat less likely (if everyone is already using mountain bikes, they're not likely to steal a BMX!).

One more added advantage of the mountain bike is that YOU are more visible to automotive traffic, because you are more upright and higher off the ground. This is not an insignificant consideration when you're riding in an urban environment, particularly during morning or afternoon rush hour. Better to be safe, in my opinion - which means obeying the rules and making sure the drivers can see you!

Lastly - with the larger wheels, it's easier to find a rack you can attach to the frame/axle to carry your stuff, instead of backpacking it all over the place. This can be advantageous, especially if you're hauling heavy textbooks or other 'gear' (musical instruments, sports equipment, extra clothing, etc).

Answer 2

This Site Might Help You.

RE:
Are bmx bikes good for commuting?
I was wondering...if I bought a bmx

I might learn some simple tricks but...
I'll probably only use it for transport like..going to school or somthing

would a bmx bike be good for this?

also...would a mountain bike be good for commuting

Answer 3

It all depends on your commute. If you are planning on going for a few blocks then you surely can use a BMX. If your commute is longer, the low frame of the BMX may be hard on your knees. Also the small diameter of the tires will not allow you to go too fast. Also if you stop pedaling, the bike stops moving unlike mountain or street bikes.

A mountain bike will be useful to commute if you have un-even surfaces to ride on. If you only bike on a paved road for a long distance, a road bike will be the best.

Answer 4

I use my bmx bike for commuting all the time. Since there are no gears its a real workout but I think its a lot more fun to ride than any other bike.

Yeah a mountain bike would be fine, but id prefer the bmx bike.

FYI: The person who said "Also if you stop pedaling, the bike stops moving unlike mountain or street bikes." <--Not true! BMX bikes have bearings that let you stop pedaling

Answer 5

Hey! Do what I did! Get a Dirt Jumper! You will have the best of both worlds. A Dirt Jumper is a Hardtail Mountain bike with a beefed up frame and with usually a 4 to 6 inch travel front fork. These bikes are used for dirt jumping single and doubles like the BMX bikes. I use my bike for Commuting, Urban Assault, Dirt Jumping and Mountian Biking. They are heavier than the standard mountian bike because they are just beefier in all the crucial areas of the frame and the heavy oil/coil single crown freeride forks that are used. One of my friends even put a Gyro on his headset for 360 bar spins. Just my 2 cents. Hope this helps!

Answer 6

What Is Bmx Bike

Answer 7

I use mine for commuting, though I don't live far away from where I work!
I would agree it depends how far you go, for long commutes and if you will be on a lot of busy roads I'd say mountain/road bike, what ever you preference is, for shorter commutes a BMX wouldn't be too bad

Answer 8

If you are comfortable with in and enjoy riding a BMX bike distance, go for it. I will tell you thought that most commuters would not like it. They have smaller wheels which are more inefficient and do not have an extended position for a good spin.

Answer 9

I'd choose a mountain bike over a bmx, then put smoother road tires on the bike.

Answer 10

As Chris answered, it will be a really good work out because you are going to be spinning so much. It also really depends on your size. I am 6'3 so I would have to hunch over the whole way. I use a fixed gear bike but the route is very flat so it works perfectly. If you have a lot of hills a fixed gear may not be a good choice unless you want a real workout.