Should people real ask medical questions and get answers from untrained people.?

Question

And just because one thing was right 2 years ago.
Sometimes they decover they only had half the answer
or it was completely wrong

I agree that someone who had gone through the same thing can share their experiences.

Answer 1

Here are some advantages of doing it this way:

- People answering questions tend to have the time to research the subject a little before answering; a doctor in a busy office has to rely on past knowledge most of the time.

- In the case of rare diseases, you may be more likely to find someone with experience with that disease by asking a large pool of people; doctors may or may not have seen a case of that particular thing before.

- Askers have the opportunity to research the answers to learn more about the subject (and determine if the information given online was correct) before seeing a doctor.

- It is fast.

- It is free.

There are plenty of disadvantages, too, as you are well aware. It should never take the place of seeing an actual doctor in person, of course, but it can definitely complement the care provided by a doctor. So ask away, but do so at your own risk.

Answer 2

1

Answer 3

I asked a very similar question & was blown off basically 2 Doctors 1 RN !drug Researcher & 1 Medical Student. says its wrong for untrained folks to answer any questions in the whole of the Health section unless its just a referral eg. Go to the Doctor I've had some medical training but not enough to answer questions in there, however I slipped up and answered one today Trolls are rampant in the Health section.

Answer 4

If the person giving the answer(s) has information from trained medical people, what's the problem? Some medical information, though the medicine / treatment may be upgraded, remains true through time. For example, it's a known fact that there are multiple types of migraine headaches. People in the medical field are familar with this, and that fact will NEVER change.

Answer 5

Very risky question, unless I know exactly what I`m talking about, I always suggest they get a professional opinion. Even at that I only give opinions on minor ailments. People really take chances asking questions on health issues that may involve a serious condition and some of the replies I`ve read r down right dangerous. I always stress that the opinion is mine and not of a doctor.

Answer 6

Well if they are going to ask the question, "What's wrong with me?", then they are just idiots when they expect a diagnosis. But as for a question like, "What should I do for a broken toe?", well that does not change generally from one person to another, so getting someone elses personal experience is a good way to HAVE AN IDEA of what to do.

Answer 7

Doctors are not gods. They make plenty of mistakes too. So why not ask untrained people. You could find someone who's gone thru what you're going thru. I know that my wife helped a few people with similar symptoms.

Does that mean you should skip the doctor? No. But why not use every mean possible.

Thru a forum we found out that a doctor was prescribing the same treatment to all of his patient (over $10,000/yr). Thru another forum, we found out he was getting a kick-back from the drug company...

Answer 8

You have a point but you have to ask yourself whether medical professionals have ALL the right answers to your questions. One who has some intelligence can look for resources to find answers and better answers than those who have a paper that says they are qualified and from a well known education institution.

Answer 9

Medical answers are generally a persons own personal experience unless you specifically ask a professional. Common sense must be applied even to recommendations made by professionals. If it doesn't seem right, question it.

Answer 10

in all likelihood cuz they are scared and/or do not desire to look like a hypochondriac, and perchance it truly is a stepping stone to them to get some evaluations from friends first formerly they visit the well-being care service. if the question contains something quite severe in spite of the truth that, Answerers in a large number of cases tell the fellow to "bypass SEE a well-being care service" (in a large number of cases in Caps speech, certain), so as that may be the encouragement the fellow needs.