Spare the rod and spoil the child?

Question

Did children become better adults before all the opposition to parents spanking their children.

Answer 1

Look at it this way, Gershoff came out with his study against spanking children 30 years ago when we had only the occasional "kid in a clock tower with a rifle". 30 years later people are criticising those of us that still spank (but spank properly). More people are out there not spanking their kids than there are that actually spank and NOW you hear about a school shooting on the news practically every day. Bomb threats, death lists, kids killing kids. When are people gonna put 2 and 2 together?

When they passed the anti-spanking law in Switzerland 30 years ago along with Gershoff's study juvenile crime rates were relatively low, since passing that law juvenile crime rates have increased by over 500%!

PROPER spanking is not abuse or violence. The definitions of those words do not even relate to spanking a child. Passive parenting is dangerous and it is creating a society of children and teenagers that have no true boundaries and no respect for authority. It's dangerous ground we tread!

Answer 2

There is a big difference between discipline and abuse. A lot of people take the "Spare the Rod" part way to literal and they beat their kids into submission, as adults these kids have a lot of problems trying to relate to others and usually flip back and forth in relationships trying to find love because they never really experienced it as children. I believe that the best thing to do for children is to keep boundries for them that you know they can keep and as they get bigger the boundries change with them. Right now I have a 7 year old and I can not tell you the last time he was spanked. I think I have only had to spank him 3 times his entire life. It is because we have boundries set for him and since he has heard them from such an early age, he doesn't even try to break them. He asks when he wants something and he uses manners. My 22 month old is in the stage of learning his boundries and there is not spanking involved at all. He is getting it and respecting what isn't his to touch. I believe the best way to parent is to lead by example. Kids watch everything you do, so if your room is a mess or you scream and yell at your wife or husband they will do the same things to other kids or their room will be messy. They tend to feed off of you. Remember a house filled with JOY and happiness and Laughter are households where kids are made to feel safe and loved and they want to keep the peace because they respect it.

Answer 3

I am of the generation where child abuse, corporal punishment, etc, wasn't recognized, and there were many times that my dad would double up his fist and punch me right in the face for disobeying him. He was a tough disciplinarian, and the only feelings I ended up having were humiliation and anger. It affected my self-esteem and drive to become someone. As a matter of fact, I didn't graduate from college until I was almost forty, and I know the late bloomer thing was a result of the physical and emotional abuse my dad inflicted on us (his favorite word for me was stupid).

I don't think violence is the answer to any problem. If we start encouraging our kids from the day they are born, we all win. Kids need to be encouraged, praised, nurtured, and assisted in all they do so as to help them become successful and independent adults. It takes a lot of hard work, nothing short of consistency, and an overwhelming amount of love and faith!

I don't have anything against a little swat on the rump if a little one is doing something that could cause him or her harm. It's when parents punish out of anger and frustration that the problem begins. Our children are truly precious gifts, and we need to treat them as such!

My dad was a good man at heart, but he had been raised in an orphanage in the 1920's, so he had no role model to look to in his own parenting. He simply lacked the skills and knowledge to be an effective and positive parent. Today there are so many programs and classes available to new or soon-to-be parents. I just wish everyone could wait until they know they will be capable parents before they take that enormous step in life.

Have a great day! Annie

Answer 4

This is a personal opinion only.I will put it this way,when I was a teen,if i took a gun to school and shot someone,I hoped the police got me instead of my daddy.The disrespect was taken care of right away.It was a better way to raise kids in my opinion.On the flip side of the coin,there was a lot of abuse.The government started to oppose spanking instead of dealing with the real problem.My mother was an abuser and with people like her,if you take away one method of abuse the abuser just finds another.But to answer your question ,yes,they did grow up to become better adults.

Answer 5

in case you spare the rod, which skill discipline, you'll smash the youngster and they gained't study. I trust between the previous posts that it really is what's incorrect with dissimilar youthful ones perfect now. Their mom and father did not take the time even as they grew as a lot as expose them the right thanks to act. dissimilar them are impolite, obnoxious, violent, and hateful. you observe dissimilar older human beings perfect now that grew up contained in the 1920's, 30's, 40's, 50's and 60's knew the thanks to act. They knew their movements had severe outcomes. in order to spare the rod is to interrupt the youngster.

Answer 6

I think when kids were spanked that they had more respect for adults and they knew how to behave now its like you cant spank me or youll go to jail the kids have all the power and the parents are stuck.

Answer 7

A good adult is one who takes responsibility for themselves and who treats themselves and others with respect. While the media would have us believe differently, adults, in general, have not changed all that much from generation to generation. My kids are respectful, kind, compassionate and listen well and we have never hurt them to "teach them a lesson". We have taught them with the respect and love we wish them to show. Discipline means to teach, and that is what we do. Teaching doesn't involve physical violence of any kind. We don't hit, its not okay to hit your brother, it is less okay to hit someone half your size. We don't use time-outs or any of that stuff, a time-out in our house means a break. We use natural consequences and discussion, it works well, even with our little one. We have confident intelligent boys and I credit our treatment of them with the respect that they feel and show.

Answer 8

you are taking the bible quote out of context. Spare the rod means discipline your child, not beat and abuse them. If you do not discipline you will 'spoil' the child. SPOIL means rotten. God never intended us to abuse our children.

Answer 9

i dont think so.
a lot of kids that have not ben spanked turned out good.

Answer 10

I dont know if its just me, but look at the kids these days.. things that were done at 18 are now done at 10..