If America deports all illegals that were the only breadwinners of their poor families..?

Question

wouldn't that portray you as a cruel nation with no respect to poor people's human rights?

Don't you understand deportation could mean terminating a primary means of survival for some family?

Answer 1

Consider this: When did it become illegal to enter this country? There are laws that were passed but when did they start enforcing that law? Is there anyway to prove an illegal alien has forged documents? Then again they may not catch all the murderers but total enforcement is very hard.

The anti-illegal alien groups have claimed that illegal aliens have taken jobs from legal aliens yet jobs like farm workers go begging for more. They also claim that illegal aliens are a burden on the system, what about all the social security and taxes that they have paid? In other words there is work and benefits that the illegal aliens provide and they want us to overlook this so that we become unjust to illegal aliens.

We know a murderer has to pay a price for his crime, what is the crime an illegal alien has done to society? Does the alien have to pay a price for babysitting your children, gardening your homes, cleaning your establishment and cooking your food? Is that such a bad crime?

Shouldn't we give them time to close up and move back to their country? Are you so afraid they will run away? After being a loyal worker where is your trust?

We must remain a lawful and humane people even evicted tenants get some rights. Advanced warning not tearing up families ruthlessly is more fair. What goes around will come around and may end up not as well as you would want.

Answer 2

sure, I truly have seen it take place. They got here to my production unit and have been given sixty 8 and the 2d time basically have been given 11. in addition they raided 2 different factories in my city and not sure of the suitable # in spite of the incontrovertible fact that that's a initiate. the extremely some ones deported weren't mexican yet have been asian. So No they dont basically deport mexicans yet in actuality maximum folk of illegals are mexican. No remark on the unlawful from eire as I dont comprehend the info of her case. almost an excellent attempt at throwing the race card.

Answer 3

It would certainly PORTRAY us that way in the eyes of a lot of the world. How we are PORTRAYED is different from whether we would ACTUALLY be violating Human Rights by doing that.

I have mixed feelings on this one, I think everyone should obey the law, even if the current immigration system with it's long waiting periods and many problems is badly in need of an overhaul.

I often wonder why there is so little talk of putting pressure on Mexico and other Countries to fix THEIR human rights problems. The answer for them has been "send everyone to the U.S." and even if we should be doing more than we are this is still not right.

Answer 4

Don't you understand that deporting illegals would mean more jobs for OUR poor hungry people? Don't the poor of this country have a right to work & feed,clothe, & shelter their families? The illegals are terminating a primary means of survival for our own poor families by taking the existing jobs.
Do you realize we taxpayers have a double load on us due to them? We have to suport our own people plus the illegal families as well with free medical;food stamps; free housing,etc.
The illegals need to go back to their country & change its laws instead of coming here & breaking ours. If our forefathers could build a safe nation why can't they do the same in their on country? Because it's easier to take advantage of us? I say deport them so our own can have a better shot of the American dream.

Answer 5

If America deports all illegals that were the only breadwinners of their poor families..? ....No.

Things need to be legal. The USA needs to alter immigration so immigants can come the right way and close the borders.

Answer 6

Don't you understand that they are bringing down wages to the degree that the american middle class blue collar workers aren't getting anywhere? Some have worked at the same jobs for 10 years and since the illegals moved into construction and meat packing plants, they can barely make their bills because they are working for the same or less money. They are being let go, so that companies can compete with other companies that hire illegals at less money. It is not our obligation to provide jobs for all the poor from other countries. We can't even provide jobs for the people we have here. With all the outsourcing of white collar jobs going on, we are going to need all the jobs we can get soon.

Answer 7

They shouldn't have large families and they should stay in Mexico. Mexico should work on reducing their population. We should try to help out Mexico, but we need to protect America from poverty also. It is sad that we will have to ignore poverty sometimes, but we can't let it reach America.

Mexicans' human rights are protected in general.

If we let all of these illegals have 6-10 kids that become US citizens, the US will become a poorer country per capita. Illegal immigration will also threaten conservation efforts and drain the natural resources and eventually the rights(such as affordable health care and public school) that Americans enjoy.

We need stop poor people from having more than one child.

Answer 8

There is no human rights to violate the law. Any problems deportation causes the family of the illegal alien rest solely on the illegal alien.

Besides, millions of people live in their own country without breaking our laws.

The majority of the illegals in the USA had jobs in their home country. They are just criminals looking out for themselves (and rarely for their children).

I used to feel as you did then I started talking to the illegals and I realized the real reasons they are here.

Name a country where the people are starving and then tell me how many illegal aliens from that country are deported!

None!

Answer 9

Whatever. I could care less what the international community thinks. I am not going to support a second invasion. I am not going to pay for the invaders like my ancestors did (except with their blood), and unless you have to deal with the illegal invasion at the border like I do, you don't know what you are talking about. So keep your ignorant idealism to yourself, Americans should do what is best for Americans first and foremost.

Answer 10

The Bush administration can only do one thing at a time. They don't have the time or money to spend on our country or the illegals that live here. Right now they are concerned with spending billions of U.S taxpayers dollars to help the breadwinners in Iraq.