Trade offer need your opinions !?

Question

Ok so this guy offered me Nomar, andruw jones, sorianoand zumaya in return for Morneau, vlad and hoffman soo should i accept the trade ? or should i keep vlad , morneau and hoffman ?

oh and yea im in 3rd place in my league

Answer 1

You gotta keep Vlad, Morneau, an Hoffman. They are all money all the time while some of the other guys cant find there stroke this year im sure they will but i wouldnt wanna fall from third an have to battle back.

Answer 2

Keep what you have. if you are in 3rd right now your roster seems fine so why make a major trade. Vlad and Morneau are .320 hitters with plenty of power and RBI machines...Jones and Soriano are more of the same but they wont as a tandem hit for nearly the ave...so you lose this part by a very small margin. Love Zumaya and think he will be a dominating closer....Hoffman IS a dominating closer. Now we get to Nomar...he is an average at best fantasy producer with a long injury history. So now you have to cut someone to get him on your roster...who do you cut (4 for 3 deals arent ever really 4 for 3, they look good until you have to dump other players that maybe you want to keep). Overall it is a pretty reasonable deal but the other guy gets a little better out of it so keep what you have.

Answer 3

Depends on the type of league you are playing in. Morneau and Vlad are rare in that they have above-average power, but also hit for average. Jones hits for power, but his average is less than spectacular. Soriano should be fine and won't hurt in any category. Obviously he'll add speed to the lineup. Nomar will help BA, but other than that, average player, considering how deep 1B is. Hoffman gets the saves while Zumaya gets the K's.

Personally, I'd keep Morneau, Vlad, and Hoffman.

Answer 4

Definitely keep morneau, vlad, and hoffman, hes tryin to offer you ok guys who are slumping right now for great players.

Answer 5

I'd keep Vladamir & Justin Monster Morneau, plus as long as Jones is clocking Zumaya's saves, he isn't worth a lick over someone like Cla Meredith.

Answer 6

Pretty darn even if u ask me. I would keep Vlad and Morneau. They are very good players.

Answer 7

I'd take it just for Zumaya and Soriano. The strike-outs from Zoom-Zoom are worth it and Soriano is sweet, however missing Marleu would be a downer but at this point in the season I'd take it.

Answer 8

you recognize, i'm extremely stunned you're getting in basic terms about all those "choose for it" responses. i'm very hesitant to take this deal, permit me clarify why. one million. you're giving up 2 staggering 25 adult adult males for one million in Longoria, Pena is unlikely keeper worth. i like Evan lots yet Fielder is raking suitable now! 2. 2B is particularly perplexing to fill. given which you keep diverse adult adult males you may save the two Prince and Ian for specific. After Utley, Pedroia and Kinsler the floor extremely falls out. Is Hill for authentic..... perchance, perchance no longer. 3. Pitching is a lots much less annoying place to patch mutually once you draft next twelve months than hitting. 4. i've got had Kershaw in a single league all twelve months, and in basic terms traded for him in yet another.... he's been pitching super yet you're starting to be a 4th participant right here in Vlad. Who could you drop....do you have an obtrusive participant you do no longer? Vlad will often in basic terms DH whilst he returns and can desire to grow to be a very frustrating participant to regulate. bear in mind regardless of skills you drop might desire to be scooped up by potential of the twine vultures and finally publish numbers against you. in the tip, I say you should bypass in this deal. he's making an attempt to purchase low on Kinsler in a Keeper league provided that he in basic terms went on the DL. whilst you're prepared to bypass Kinsler bypass pursue skills on the greater serious 2 communities on your league and spot if u can garner a stud SP. sturdy success.