who's better VY or MVick ?

Question

who's better in passing and who's better in rushing ?

Answer 1

I think vince young is a better passer, but mike vick is a better scrambler. But i think VY will be more sucsessful in the NFL then vick, because he can throw better and is more of a versitile QB. As vick is a QB who runs alot.

Answer 2

Vince Young will be the better in the passing game by the end of their careers, statistically. They're both naturally gifted and talented. Vick is faster, but that doesn't necessarily mean he's a better runner. Vince knows when to run and when to step up and make a throw. Vick does not have the right work ethic or attitude to ever be as good as Vince.

Answer 3

Right now Vick is better. But give young a year or 2 and he might pass vick. No one is going to beat vick when it come to pure speed and agility. the guy is like a cat. but i think the fundamental problem with vick is 2 things.

1. Vick's height doesnt allow him to see the field clearly, young on the other hand is tall, and should see the feild fine.

2. Vick throws way to hard. So hard no reciever can hang onto the ball. He needs to develope touch, and im just not sure vick will ever develop it. Young doesnt have the best passing motion, but it seems like he does what i takes to get the ball where it needs to be.

Answer 4

Michael Vick is the better rushing quarterback of the two simply because he's faster and more elusive then Vince Young although Vince Young is a pretty good rusher. In terms of passing they both have good arms but Vince Young has better accuracy then Michael Vick. There's my observations.

Answer 5

Vick has shown he can be very dangerous, but he lacks dicipline to stick with the game plan. Young, is very used to working within a system and breaking from it in a pinch. the other difference is the physical, Vick is only 6'1, VY is 6'5 much stronger and durable. dispite is akward style VY is much better passer, Vick has yet to learn touch.

Answer 6

Thats a stupid question who is better in rushing, Didnt Vick rush for a 1000 rushing yards.
I would say they both are average, they neither didnt get much throwing yards and had some few good throwing yards.
If Vick had receivers who didnt drop or can seperate themselve from defenders, have a great coach call, and he can audible. He would be 10 times better

Answer 7

Vince Young is marked for greatness and I believe this year or next year he is going to prove me right. As of now, it is too early to tell but I give the edge to Vick in the running although Young is no slouch.Young will be the better passer and the better player overall in the future.

Answer 8

vy is a natural born winner. That is something that vick just does not posses. I would take Vince Young over Vick any day of the week.

Answer 9

Vick is by far the better rusher. He holds the records for QB's rushing in a game, and in a season. Vick is a better passer than everyone thinks, but his O-Line is terrible, and his recievers drop a ton of well thrown balls. That being said, however, Young will probably wind up being a better passer, because his size and strength will allow him to stand up in the pocket longer. They both have laser rocket arms.

Answer 10

VY Both areas