If all ancient Greek religious beliefs are considered nonsense?

Question

Shouldn't we discount the parts that the Christians adopted from them?

If all ancient Babylonian religious stories are fables, shouldn't we discount the ones that the Jews adopted during the Babylonian Exile?

If all ancient Egyptian beliefs are false, shouldn't we discount the Resurrection, since the idea was taken from the Egyptians and not the Hebrew Bible?

If the ancient Sacraments of Mithras and Dionysus are pointless, shouldn't we consider the modified version that the Christians copied from them equally pointless?

If you laugh at the Ascension of the Deified Julius Caesar to the Heavens, on a comet, as witnessed by many and testified to under oath in front of the Roman Senate, shouldn't you also laugh at the conflicting tales of the Ascension of Jesus, remembered by no one but invented long after he had died?

Answer 1

That's sooo true! i couldn't get any of my friends to answer that question, they all stared at me like i was an idiot!

Answer 2

Why do you believe the ancient Greeks writing about their nonsense comments?

Why believe the fable stories and discount some stories>

Why believe on issues from the old stories of Jews and Egyptian stories?

Why do you believe that Christians copied pointless belief from the sacraments of Mithra and Dionysus?

If you believe the ascension of Julius Caesar to the Heavens on a comet as you said witnessed by many and testified to and under oath in front of the Roman Senate, why don't you b elieve and say conflicting on the ascension of Jesus.

Do you think that the ascension of Julius Caesar is not invented but true and you thin k that the ascension of Jesus is false?
jmt

Answer 3

We should discount parts in places where religious people adopt parts from other religions to place their beliefs on if it were true. Other places that are adopted are for cultural acceptance's [easter bunny,santa,etc..]. Yes Mithra and Dionysus were attributed to an ascension and virgin birth before Jesus was born, But way after it was prophesied that Jesus would be born, therefore who copied from who? One discounts Julius Caesar's diety from the life he lead. 3 marriages, and 4 female lovers. He couldn't live up to his own rules in other area's of his life. Gauss Octavian was only voted diety because he was Julius's adopted son, [great-nephew by blood], But for diety, one must be perfect.

Answer 4

You said, "If all ancient Greek religious beliefs are considered nonsense?

Shouldn't we discount the parts that the Christians adopted from them?"

Indeed, we should provided your first assertion is true. But it isn't true. Every religious belief of ancient Greece is not considered nonsense; you conclusion, therefore, does not follow.

HTH

Charles

Answer 5

collective subconscious is what Karl youthful talks approximately while it includes mythology. He underlies that one and all myths international are particularly lots based upon human targets and targets are created by using human subconscious.So he helps that there is something straight forward in each and every civilization, the collective subconscious, area of human nature inspite of the ameliorations between cultures. This theory can justify why there are similarities between myths of diverse civilizations even nevertheless it could additionally justify why todays religions correspond to myths. you may desire to evaluate each and every faith to affix mythology because of the fact for us they're merely memories of 1000's of years and not something reported or defined might properly be extremely precise, the only component left to evaluate is your theory in god and what you have faith god is

Answer 6

I don't know about calling the above mentioned history 'nonsense', fables', but they are indeed false forms of worship.

Answer 7

Excellent points. Thank you.

Answer 8

well said, i agree 100%

Answer 9

boy you are full of it