Muslims was there ever a prophet of God who disagreed with the word of God and the words of the prophets?

Question

Why is Muhamamd not in agreement with the word of God and the prophets?Moses taught the tree of life. Abraham that the lord would provide himself a lamb. Isaiah that the Messiah would be a Savior for his people. John the Baptist that Jesus was the lamb of God. Jesus taught he must fufill the prophesies of Isaiah and that no man comes to the Father but throught he Son.

cr Muhammad did not agree with Isaiah when Isaiah teachs the Messiah atoned for sin did he? or Abraham when Abraham taught the same by declaring the lord would provide himself a lamb?
or John the Baptist when he said of Jesus behold the lamb of God? or Jesus when he sid I and the Father are one or where Jesus claimed he msut fufille the prophesies fo Isaih 53 which says the Messiah would atone for sin? Does the Quran agree that Jesus died for our sin? then obviously Muhammad did not agree with God and could not be a prophet of God.

Wisdom Jesus did not disagree with an eye for an eye it is God's rightousness. Jesus did offer his flesh to pay this penalty of death and the penalty was paid. Therfore we are taught to go beyond the law.

nooer Jesus is one with the Father and the Holy Spirit they are one God and it is the teachings of the Gospel and of Jesus Christ and Moses.

Nunya have your ead the actual words of the prohets Isaiah 53 for instance?

Nadia Allah did say he agreed with the revealtion he handed down to the prophets and his book and told you to agree with it too. unfortunately ti is not ina greement wiht him nor are any of God's scriptures or prophets that existed before teh Quran

Tony M. does Allh agree with the words of Moses, Jesus and Isaiah that preceded the Quran have you actually read the words of the prophets?

Victor You are absolutely correct even the Quran teachs Jesus was the Word.

DB those prophets who agree with the word of God are refered to as prophets of God. Moses said those who disagree are false prophets.

ayyoub have you read the words of the prophets or only the Quran which disagrees with them?

Badmus Moses taught the tree of life.
Abrham taught that God would provide himself a lamb. Isaiah taught the Messiah would atone for sin. John the Baptist taught Jesus was the lamb of God. Jesus taught eh would fufill teh prophesies of Isaiah who said eh would atone for sin...Is Muhammad in agreement with these prophets?

hurriacane no prophet of God ever taught there was more than one God you are correct as we believe that Christ is a part of the whole of God. The Father, Son and Holy Spirit are one God. teh fact reamins that God did provide himself a lamb and this lamb of God is Jesus Christ who did atone for sin. Thsi is the words fo the prophets that Muhammad and the Quran are not ina greement with.

SouA If the word of God was corrupt at the time of the Qu'ran why didnt Allah teach against it instead of telling you to agree with the revealtion?

Mr. Stick no one is offended we hear these same alleged contradictions often and many have been answered here by myself and other Christians. Here you can find an answer to all 101 alleged contradictions for the sake of time and space... If you need further help with any of these please feel free to e-mail or message me anytime. http://debate.org.uk/topics/apolog/contrads.htm
Thanks Sterngen!

Answer 1

According to the Quran, every group of people received a messenger, by whom they will be judged. These messengers proclaimed the same basic message, to serve God and turn from evil.

The message of each prophet is the same according to Islam, therefore Muslims accept all the earlier prophets and their message. In the stories of the prophets in Quran, the prophets essentially deliver their message and are rejected by the people.

According to Islam, the Jews and Christians rejected Mohammad, like they rejected the earlier prophets. The message of these earlier prophets was lost, only to be restored by Mohammad, who is the last prophet.
both Christianity and Judaism have been set aside because they broke their covenants with God. The Christians associate Jesus with God (Shirk) and the Jews associate Ezra in the same way. The Jews however, do not believe Ezra is the son of God, so where Mohammad received this information and included it in the Quran is in question.

In the earlier “revelations” Mohammad looks favorable to the books of the Jews and Christians, the Torah and Injil (Gospel). He refers to them “the book of God”, “the Word of God”, “a light and guidance to man”, “a decision for all matters, and a guidance and mercy,” “the lucid Book”. He even challenges his message, the Quran, to be compared with the revelations of the Jews and Christians.

Later the Christians and Jews are charged with tampering and with God’s word by concealing the word.

Muslims have only the word of Mohammed. How can they be sure the words of the Prophets have been lost.

Christians have the reasurance from God. We have the words of all the prophets in the OT. He told us his word can not be changed.

Answer 2

You are a fool.

Your mixing the Bible with the Qur'aan.

No Prophet disobeyed the final message of God.

The Prophet Muhammad always obeyed the Word of God. What are you on about?

Your making a fool out of yourself. Stop putting the Bible and the Qur'aan together. The truth (the Qur'aan) does not mix with stories and lies from historians (that's what is mainly in the bible).

And you beleive in the Trinity? Which is a lie in Christianity. Something which is made up.

Contradiction #1
Who incited David to count the fighting men of Israel? (a) God did (2 Samuel 24:1) (b) Satan did (1 Chronicles 21:1).

Contradiction #2
In that count how many fighting men were found in Israel? (a) Eight hundred thousand (2 Samuel 24:9). (b) One million, one hundred thousand (1 Chronicles 21:5).

Contradiction #3
How many fighting men were found in Judah? (a) Five hundred thousand (2 Samuel 24:9). (b) Four hundred and seventy thousand (1 Chronicles 21:5).

Contradiction #4
God sent his prophet to threaten David with how many years of famine? (a) Seven (2 Samuel 24:13). (b) Three (1 Chronicles 21:12).

Contradiction #5
How old was Ahaziah when he began to rule over Jerusalem? (a) Twenty-two (2 Kings 8:26). (b) Forty-two (2 Chronicles 22:2).

That’s 5 out of the 101 which I have

Apart from contradictions....what do you call these?
http://www.islamawareness.net/Christianity/inbible.html

About the Trinity?
There is no Trinity...its fake....it's not mentioned in the Bible..... you will never find the word trinity int he bible!!!

http://www.bismikaallahuma.org/archives/2006/a-logical-reasoning-refuting-the-concept-of-trinity/

Simple as ABC....where can you go wrong :)

Heres something for the Jehovah Witnesses...
http://www.webshowplace.com/question/101quest.html

Why don't you Christians read this perhaps...
http://www.answering-christianity.com/x_rated.htm

http://www.answering-christianity.com/101_bible_contradictions.htm
Although there are more than 101....

GOD's stupidity is smarter than all of us?!
http://www.answering-christianity.com/101_bible_contradictions.htm

http://www.answering-christianity.com/ac6.htm#links

*I apologise if anyone takes this answer offensive. That is not my intention, and I never do. I'm sorry to those who find this offensive.*

Answer 3

Jesus disagreed with the word of god in the Old Testament a lot, as well with the prophets. Moses specifically states that a man should be killed for gathering firewood on the Sabbath, Jesus disagreed. The OT states a tooth for a tooth, and an eye for an eye, Jesus disagreed. The OT states hate your enemies, Jesus disagreed. The OT gives dietary restrictions, Jesus said it is not what goes in your mouth, it is what comes out of your mouth that will defile you. Judaism promoted strict adherence to the letter of the law, Jesus disagreed.

Victor, Been there, not much truth to be found, sorry. Tons of contradictions though!

Answer 4

All prophets and messengers came from the same One God, Allah Almighty so they all follow his message to human beings and that message was always to worship One god and never to associate with him parteners, unfortunately this message was everytime corrupted by people who came after the prophets and changed their divine books by their own hands that's why God had to send other messengers to correct the mistakes for Jews God send Jesus (PBUH) and for all humanity God send Mohammed (SAAS) as the last messenger and prophet for mankind, Allah promised in the noble Quran that he would preserve his last book from human changes and it challenges the unbeleivers if they could ever change it or bring something similar to it, till this day no one has come to try or to dare doing that.

[Quran 2.23-24] And if you were in doubt about what We have revealed to Our servant, then bring forth a book like the Quran; and call your witnesses (scientists) to prove it contrary to Allah, if you were truthful. 24 But you cannot and will never (be able). So beware of a fire whose fuel is men and stones prepared for blasphemers.

Answer 5

In the name of Allaah, Most Benefit, Most Merciful
All praise is due to Allaah, the Lord of all worlds
May Allaah's peace and blessing be upon His prophet, his family and companions

Peace be upon those who follow the true guidance!
1. All prophets and messengers taught the same: tawheed(arabic for: belief in One God who is in Arabic called ALLAAH)

2. Only the details of the prescribed religions changed, the shari'ahs. The belief didn't change (how could it!) but the concrete ceremonies changed.

3. Muhammad SAWS is Allaah's Messenger, by saying Muhammad SAWS didn't convey us the truth, you'd say Allaah is a liar.
And peace be upon those who follow the true guidance!

And all praise is due to Allaah, the Lord of all worlds
And may Allaah's blessing be upon His Prophet, his family and companions

Answer 6

In the Holy Quran,no prophet was stated to have dissagreed with the word of God, the few one that disobey God command seek for forgiveness when they realise that they have gone against God command eg Adam and Eve in the garden of eden.Please state the word of God that Prophet mohammed (SAW) was not in agrrement with God.

Answer 7

No, the Word of God was to worship none other than Him, ascribing divinty to noone but Him. All the prophets preached this, including Moses, Jesus, Abraham( which was neither a jew nor a christian) and Muhammad peace be upon him.

Answer 8

Muslim can pray for them to recuperate and be cured, and not go through. Muslim can pray for them to locate instruction, and be guided to the the actuality. Muslim can pray for them to stay a healthful existence. transforming into ill and ill is a attempt, and trial, to make certain who will pass, how we are able to react, and is a reminder for us in many techniques. no you could tension something onto all people, no longer something could be compelled, incredibly faith, and if somebody will become a Muslim, with out being confident, then how can that's frequently occurring? faith, theory, and prepare is severe. plus it truly is a vertical courting between God and each and each Muslim."

Answer 9

I think your knowledge of Islam is too limited. You can't be a Muslim until you believe in all prophets and messengers ( Moses, Abraham, Jesus Christ, etc.). How do think that Mohammed disobeyed God? He says I'm the slave of God. I think you have to read a lot about Islam to know how they consider others prophets.

Answer 10

No I wouldn't believe so. And what are you talking about Muhammad not agreeing with the words of God? He might have questioned him, and God clarified his reasoning. That is something you should ask your local mosque.