USA is like Nazi germany and Mexicans its JEws?

Question

AMerica acts like nazi germany, justifying invasion after invasion, persecuting mexicans and accusing them of all their problems as scapegoats...They feel they are superior and that they ave the universal truth.Just like a superioir race. And americans dont know anything of whats going on outside their country.. will they end up the same way germans did? humilated and defeated?

Please answer all the question not just the part about MExicans! About America invading other nations etc...

pd Im not Mexican..

Tianjing,

just so that the next time you can asnwer a question as arrogant as you did but with sme knowledge, the finalsolution of thejews came in 1943 and the persecution of the jews began at least 10 years before. therefore the Mexicans are not being treated like the jews on the stage of the final solution just now, but they are being persecuted and frowned upon as a whole.

America is in iraq because it needs to secure its oil, and will go and take iran because it needs to build a gas line underneath its land from kazahastan, simple as that. Why didnt you intervene in rwanda, I mean I know its not your duty or your responability, but isnt it odd that you intervene in conflicts where theres lots of natural resources but you dont ere theres nothing but real poverty?
America does have an expansionist policy only it calls it liberating and not expansionism.

Hdean45

will it surprise you if in the near future one of your brilliant congress men proposed that all legal mexicans were a band with ther social security number in it to separate those legal from ilegal?

Answer 1

Looks like your logic is way off and has no basis at all, just another example of someone trying to justify breaking the law and blaming someone else. I guess you think that Americans caused all of these mexicans to trespass in our country and steal the IDs of honest hard working Americans.
The only way that we will be humilated and defeated is if we allow lawbreakers and trespasser stay in our country and turn it into a third world country like the one that you trespassers have ran away from.
VIVA LA IMIGRA!

Answer 2

What we need to do is understand what Nazism actually was.

It included things like Nationalism and belief in an empire. In also had the view that certain people's were superior to others. In fact this was part of the world view for 1000s of years and in somewhere like China it continues to exist fairly strongly.

Many of the values of Nazism were in fact the values of contempory American and Western society taken to its extreme.

We see these elements in the issues with immigration from Latin America, however we can actually look at it from another point of view.

Every generation of mass migration into western countries, such as the United States or Australia have the same feelings.

There is the belief that the immigrants don't share the same values, they won't integrate, they devalue the country in some way and don't deserve to be there and so.

In the United States you could go back to look at the waves of Irish immigration. In Australia past examples include the 1950-70s of southern Europeans suddenly beggining to go to Australia in large numbers (Italians in particular) and in a comparison in Australia you see the 1980s and 90s through to now with a fear of Asian immigration, and a growing fear of immigration from the middle East.

History shows us that in the immigrant countries time heals these wounds.

With Mexico and the US we have a slightly different problem. Mostly because of the amount of immigration, its illegal nature, the type of people illegally coming to the US and the issue of proximity.

Increasing economic and social ties between mexico and the the United states will lessen this impact while changing both countries forever and merging too different but proud cultures. Don't forget the northern yankess still make fun of the southerners.

In other words, don't be too quick to call others Nazis, but Nazi Germany is a lessen which we can all learn from and work to prevent.

Answer 3

If we didn't have the illegals in the country that would damage our way of life. The illegals contribute tremendously to the economy. These people are desperate to give their families a better life. I do not see how you arrive at the conclusion that they have no morals. If by that you are saying that anybody who breaks the law has no morals then there are a hell of a lot of Americans in the same category. Nothing is achieved by using emotive language. You may not agree with the illegals being in the country but your case is not advanced by making bigoted remarks, sweeping generalisations and asserting that : "They damage our way of life" when the opposite appears to be the case. NAFTA was supposed to allow the movement of labor between America and Mexico. If it is not working then there is something wrong with the treaty. Mexicans deserve just as much right to a decent standard of living as anyone else. Just as everyone has a right to life like all Americans. There seems to be too much duplicity in dealing with these matters and it is not helping America world wide. Why is it acceptable for a person to die in Iraq but unacceptable if it happens here. Unless we adopt a more compassionate approach to our fellow human beings our way of life will most certainly be damaged and we will only have ourself to blame. We may try to make the Mexicans our wiping boys but if we continue to do that the situation will never, ever improve.

Answer 4

Without any detail or research- you could make your point.

Illegal immigration has been passively allowed in America since its inception, as America has absorbed illegal immigrants from all over the world on an active ongoing basis.

The situation with mexico though has taken on new preportions as the illegal immigration is out of control and adversely effecting the economy and undermining all principals of citizenship.

Mexicans are victims of their own government in Mexico, which continously and purposely fails them- given a choice, I am sure the majority of them would be more then happy to stay in Mexico if only they could provide a decent life for their families there- But Mexico knows it doesn't have to as long as it can exploit the generousity of the US- and it has pushed the envelope to far now.

Answer 5

I don't recall 35 million anti-education, anti-German Jews rushing Germany's borders from a neighboring country? Does anyone else?

I've seen mounds of evidence that illegals are killing legal citizens and immigrants in addition to their favorite target: other illegals. But let a U.S. citizen accidentally sneeze in the direction of an illegal and it's reported as attempted genocide.

Hitler gassed millions of citizens because...well, really it was because they all managed to get wealthy. They believed in education to the n^th degree and they applied that knowledge.

Everyone I've heard from concerning illegal immigrants want the same thing. It's simple - pick up and go home. Fix your own country. Have some self-respect. No gas-chambers in the works, there.

Have you honestly never considered how completely unconvincing it is when an entire population pretends to be brave in a foreign country [whose government hands them welfare from the money it's stolen from legal citizens] yet they never stand up to their own government?

If these really are brave, strong Latinos, show us. Prove to the U.S. that you're so capable and determined. Stand up to the Mexican and the Central American governments...and win!

You will have my respect. Until then, I see no indication that you've done anything but lie to yourselves; clearly you've fooled none of us on the outside looking in.

The day that those of us who built this country get fed up enough to take it back, all that puffed-up, imaginary "bravery" will deflate like a balloon on a cactus-needle. Sad.




qwerty

Answer 6

Wow. What an accusation. First of all, the U.S. invasion of Iraq was theoretically to go after WMD's and terrorists, and to remove Hussein from power. The invasions by Hitler were for complete and utter take over of other countries to expand Germany's size. The U.S. is NOT doing that. We have NO policy of expansionism.

Hitler believed in the extermination of Jews - it was complete genocide. No one is rounding up Mexicans, and sending them to gas chambers or mass execution pits. We completely accept legal immigrants - Mexican and otherwise. Its illegal aliens, of all nations - that are the problem, and being asked to leave. We don't have laws to be mean, we have laws to protect U.S. citizens and legal immigrants. If someone doesn't like the U.S., its policies, or its laws, they can stay away. No one is being held at gunpoint to come here. And to compare the U.S. immigration law to Hitler's policies of expansionism and mass genocide is an atrocity!

Answer 7

Wow, you sure are full of assumptions and incorrect information.

Deporting people 'back home' to where they would have been if they hadn't broken the law is nothing like what Germany did to its Jewish CITIZENS. We don't want it to be pleasant for people to be here illegally. That would just make more come.

Mexicans certainly protect THEIR immigration laws. and even foreigners LEGALLY there can never vote or hold a government job or gather in a political rally. Why don't you speak of them?

Answer 8

You do history and all persecuted peoples a terrible disservice through your incredible ignorance when you compare America's treatment of Mexicans (I suppose in your wisdom you mean illegal aliens) to the Nazi's "Final Solution". Please know what you are talking about before you make such comparisons. Your total lack of understanding so waters down your point that it would be laughable if it weren't so embarrassingly ignorant.

Answer 9

You say that Americans don't know whats going on out side their country . You don't seem to know what is going on in the U.S.A. and you don't know much about Nazi Germany. We don't have death camps set up to try and exterminate a whole race of people and even the illegals in this country have more rights than the people in Nazi Germany had.

Answer 10

No, the Germans actually killed the Jews. So far I haven't seen a similar policy for killing Mexicans.