Are "miracles" proof God exists?

Question

For example, some people believe that if one child survives a terrible bus accident, that is a "miracle" and proof God exists. If that's the logic, wouldn't the other 59 dead children prove God doesn't exist?

In order for a "miracle" to occur alot of similar situations must have ended in tragedy.

Nope. I did not do philosophy. I majored in engineering.

Answer 1

Miracles don't proof God exists.

Because you have seen Me, have you believed? Blessed are they who did not see, and yet believed. John 20:19

Proof of God in your life comes when you and your heart have miraculously changed.

Answer 2

If that was a miracle, then logically speaking yes. You are right.

However, it would not be a miracle. People use the term too loosely. Nothing more than nature and the luck of the draw, along with other unknown circumstances is what is being talked about here.

A real miracle (not the one that fraud Benny Hill on TBN claims to perform) would be proof of the existence of God, i.e., deaf hearing, blind seeing, dead raising. None of this other nonsense.

Good point.

Answer 3

first of all, the term God is in all probability the main omit-understood term in the worldwide. God is depicted in historical scriptures as a triangle what's a contender and interior 3 issues that make it a being. those 3 elemnets are + - and impartial. 2 of those + and - create circulate in an potential field. impartial kills the circulate. So, learn what ever you want and you detect this thought. This tetragrammaton with the three elemnets are formulated via 4 letters of the jewish alphabet. YHWH or Yaweh or reported Jehowa. This 4 letters are a classic formula, a mathematic thought in an algebraic formula. The be conscious comes out of the undemanding teachings of the jewish Kabbalah on which all religions are based. non secular powers have controlled to teach the kabalistic expertise in one in all those doctrine that has as a purpose to enslave human beings and for this reason make the preachers stay an undemanding existence with the money of the fools who have confidence them. in case you want an perception in it and how it works, get Jeff Love's e book, "The Quantum Gods", it provides in an undemanding format a speedy expertise of the Kabbalah and this is concepts that designate the undemanding function of the universe wherein we live. we are able to learn for specific all we'd like, there keeps to be an abyss we won't in any respect conquer and the Kabbalah tells that throughout a clean way. This abyss is what replaced into the 1st thought who created all and the place did it come from. only understand this, the Kabbalah provides you with a superb view on what you're and the place you're and what you're here for. And, it is going to assist you be certain in the back of the veil of all religions and there lies. None of all the scriptures are incorrect, the purpose is to interrupt the veil and examine the actual content textile, not the story of toddlers, cabbages and storks that's made for toddlers and fools..

Answer 4

The next question is "which God?" They all have miracles. If you believe in the Christian God, you can't accept the idea that Hindu miracles prove the existence, power and goodness of Hindu Gods. If you are particularly open minded, you might say that Hindu miracles are performed by the true God (yours) in the hope of eventually wooing Hindus away from Hinduism. More likely, you would say that those miracles are satanic counterfeits. How do you know? Because they don't confirm the existence, power and goodness of the true God, i.e. yours. So miracles only "prove" what you believe already.

Answer 5

Yeah, I guess you could say that. A miracle is something unusual and not a normal occurrence. To me, however, a miracle is not needed to proof God's existence. If He choses to save one person, then He will do so. If He choses to leave things be than He also will do that. Either way, whatever God does will be for the good. We just can't always see that right away, during a tragedy. Sadly, the good that comes out of tragedy is often not put in the headlines.

Answer 6

The only thing that is "miraculous" is the fact that so many people still blindly follow these archaic religions that should've died out centuries ago.

Christians keep saying jesus is coming back.... & they say a date... when the date passes they make an excuse for it & say something lame like they miscalculated..... If you got stood up for a blind date would you sit at the restaurant for years saying "Oh, he'll show up one day!" ?? Or would you leave the restaurant & move on with your life??

Edit:
as for your analogy.... i like that. The only thing is.... everyone who's child was not in the crash would see it as a miracle that the one survived. The family of the survivor would see it as "god's miracle" ..... The only ones who would not see it as a miracle would be the ones who lost their children in the incident.

Answer 7

I think miracles are proof that amazing things can happen.
It doesn't mean neccessarily that god exists, I suppose that would depend on your religious beliefs.
Maybe they aren't miracles at all, it could just as easily be down to luck and the hand that you are dealt.

Answer 8

Most people call "miracle" something that they don't understand or have no explanation for. The less educated will "see" a lot of miracles.
Religion strives on ignorance, miracles too.
"Miracles" are proof that many people are uneducated .

Answer 9

Cluster illusion.

People will tend to see what they want to see and not what may or may not be in front of them.
People are idiots.

There are no miracles; there is simply existence going about itself like it has been doing for the past 50 billion years or so... It doesn't give a toss if people have selective attention.

Answer 10

I am hoping for a miracle today
we really need money to pay our bill and we are about to be kick out I got hurt doing nursing work I am a Nursing Assistant
and the work is very hard
now I do not have money for me and my two son to help with the bills if I get a miracle email me and I will tell you if I recieve one today