Muhammad or Jesus ? Who is the better Leader?

Question

Please address this question in a very objective manner. No point being Subjective !

Answer 1

both Muhammad pbuh and Jesus are prophets but if we are going to talk about the better leader it will be Muhammad pbuh for many reason Jesus was never the leader of his people in some war but muhammad built a kingdom from nothing he was the leader of a small part of people who convert to Islam in the beginning.he treated them all the same with time he had an army but he was too intelligent so he knew when to start a war and when not ,he was always defending the right of musilment to live he was the leader in "badr" for example ,but Jesus did not ,,,and if we take a look at people who followed Jesus when he was a live they are too many less than who followed Mohammad pbuh in his life .and Muhammad in Islam we have assonah which mean what Muhammad pbuh said or have done and we have to try to do the same think but there is nothing like that in Christianity in other meaning Muslims followed Muhammad pbuh in his live and after his death and this representing a good leader but Jesus even that he was a prophet o god he couldn't built kingdom which is following god

Answer 2

Wasn't Jesus more of a teacher? I don't know Muhammad's life story but I don't count teachers among the group of great leaders (great people, yes, I have a lot of respect for teachers, but leaders have different qualities).

Edit: I can prove that Jesus was NOT a leader - that story about the two fishes and five loaves was a logistical nightmare. A planner (on staff) could have avoided it by simply not offering food or picking a smaller venue. Speaking of venue...sermon on the mount? We all know how bad a mountain top is for acoustics. The base would have been better because there might have been something like a natural auditorium there.

Answer 3

Better as in WHAT?

You need to lay down the criteria for assessment in order to talk about objectivity. Otherwise all you get are subjective answers.

For example, if by better leader you mean more followers, then Jesus wins hands down. But if by better leader you mean political leadership, Jesus does not win as He was never a poitical figure to begin with. So please ask your question again with the proper standards of measurement.

Answer 4

This depends on the definition of leadership. If leadership is solely determined by the number of followers, Jesus wins by 2 to 1.

Answer 5

2 gary
we r not rejecting the msg of jesus but u people r rejecting his msg he was a prophet of God not a son he never calim that i m God or worship me and suppose u r right then tell me
1-how can God die
2-y there r so many scientific errors in bible
3-Y in the whole bible there is no single verse where he himself say i m God or worship me (i mean the exact words that i hav written)
4-and many other things but 1st answer these
5-i m chalenging u if u hav strong faith on jesus check these sites and then try 2 deny it

Answer 6

To me, both were messengers of the One God who spread the message of His revelation and asked people to worship Him. they are to be revered for they were chosen to perform a noble and a cumbersome task; they are two amongst many messengers sent by the Lord of the Heavens and the Earth and deserve our respect.
Jesus was born of a virgin; the most respected woman according to Islamic scripture. He performed miracles, was blessed with the Gospels and spread the message of the One God among his people and was rebuked for it.
Muhammad spread the message of the same One God, this time with the Quran, which was a confirmation of the revelations before it and was similarly rebuked by some and followed by others.
Let's not compare the two; let's instead learn to establish and sustain harmony as they had intended.
Cheers & God bless.

Answer 7

Both are Prophets and messengers of God. Muhammad pbuh succeeded to establish the kingdom of God on earth with the Grace of Allah and Jesus pbuh will establish again the kingdom of God on earth.

Answer 8

Muhammed was born almost 600 years after Christ.

Then he tried to re-write history and falsify the teachings of Christ:
Muslims (and Islam) say Jesus was a prophet but they reject all His teachings ...

They reject Christ's divinity;
they reject his claim to be the Son of God;
they reject his death on the cross...
they reject His ressurrection..
They reject Jesus is the Christ/ Messiah...
Need I say more...?

Don't be deceived. The Islamic god is totally different than the God of Jesus Christ .

The Bible calls Muhammed a False prophet....
"Who is a liar but he that denies that Jesus is the Christ? He is anti-Christ, that denies the Father and the Son. He that denies the Son, the same has not the Father." (I John 2:22)

Answer 9

Mohammed(s.a.w.)..cos he united and welcomed and lived in peace with Christians and Jewish..prove?one of his wives was christian and one was Jewish.
And u can find a lot of good things about him even in the bible.
Jesus was also a great man a great prophet and teacher..
God chooses them both as prophets cos they were great men..but Mohammed (s.a.w.) is better.

Answer 10

Out of the two only one was the Son of God and rose from the dead.