Are all asian martial arts spiritual???

Answer 1

That is part of the definition of true martial arts. Unfortunately, the way many people teach them, that part is lost.

Answer 2

Spirituality is where you find it.

The short answer to your question is no. Especially if you understand what you mean by spirituality - spirituality doesn't mean tradition, or culture, or philosophy. Those are other things asian arts have in varying degrees. Meditation is something people think of as something spiritual from the asian arts - but there are plenty of people from non-asian traditions that meditate, with or without a spiritual element. It's hard to pin down "spirituality" enough to say martial arts do or don't have it.

I personally think your martial art should be about fighting first and all the other claptrap second - because there's always a certain spirituality to be found in doing something hard, well.

Answer 3

Martial arts are not spiritual, spirituality is altogether another quest, spirituality is inside yourself, you can be spiritual without martial art, A martial art cant make you spiritual, It just so happens that asian religions have influenced the martial arts, but it doesnt make them "spiritual", spirituality is a personal choice, you could spend years in a so called "spiritual martial art" but that in itself will not make you spiritual. I believe you can find a spiritually minded instructor. Even if that art carries a particular philosophy, it dont mean that it is always accurately reflected in the teaching style of an instructor or school, Its definitely a personal pursuit to be spiritual and a martial art itself cant teach you that, spirituality is an approach to a particular style, but not the style itself.

Answer 4

You have to understand asian culture to know that your question is somewhat redundant. Most Asians unlike westerners have not abandoned their traditional beliefs in spirits and still uses it in their everyday life even to this day. Every aspect of Asian life is influenced and affected by spiritual belief whether consciously or subconsciously, be it in business, food, games or relationships. So it is natural for their martial arts to also be partly of spiritual nature. To ask if asian martial arts is spiritual would be like asking if Mexican Foods are spicy.

Answer 5

No... but the vast majority is.

It doesn't really matter though, spiritual or not, a martial arts effectiveness is based on the proper application of techniques against non-compliant attackers.

Answer 6

No.

Tae Kwon Do is very empirical.

Some styles of Japanese Karate are also very empirical such as Kyuokushin and Rembukai.

Most if not all of the 'aiki' styles of Jiu Jitsu are very spiritual.

Judo is slightly spiritual but mostly empirical.

American wrestling or professional wrestling is purely 100% empirical.

Kendo is very spiritual.

Kyudo is 100% spiritual.

Shorinji Ryu Kempo is 100% spiritual.

Answer 7

first element to understand is that you're a spirit and also you're literally not attentive to it. Yoga and martial arts are meant to take you into information. guy even even as unsleeping is type of a nap walker. in simple terms in threat does the information is composed of him. His information is continually clouded via innovations and precisely those innovations are preserving him faraway from his genuine id. in accordance to those platforms the in simple terms element required is information. there is not any favor to trust in a god or a soul. you may see the reality your self. those approaches lets you drop your innovations and be conscious your self straight away. In combating and swordsmanship you could't imagine and act. The action could come out of your intestine. that's why there's a thirst for warfare. human beings become aflame with aliveness. even as they are dealing with lack of life the on the spot is crucial. The alertness is at it really is height. those approaches say know your self, do not trust. once you know stay from that information and amplify it. enter into it further and extra

Answer 8

No. Okinawan based arts are physical. They do have a mental and philosophical aspect but mostly they are based on the physiology of the body.

Answer 9

Yes, but not religious. It does not matter race, age, sex, religion, just sweat it and do it.

Answer 10

not all, but i have seen on movies that they do some spirit rituals