I have a SOLUTION TO THE KASHMIR CONFLICT???

Question

According to the Pakistani government and citizenry, Pakistan has a rightful and just claim to Kashmir because the majority of the people in Kashmir are Muslims, right???

Well, the Pakistani government is forgetting that India has the world's second largest Muslim population (although they comprise only 12% of the Indian population - 83% being hindu). I think there are approximately 150 million Muslims who constitute India's Muslim minority.

My solution is this:
We can say to Pakistan that we will ONLY relinquish control of Kashmir to yourselves, IF YOU TAKE ALL INDIA'S MUSLIMS, ALONG WITH KASHMIR AND GRANT THEM CITIZENSHIP OF PAKISTAN!!!

I don't mean to sound heartless and I apologise if I have caused any offence. But the purpose of 1947 partition was so that India can become a Muslim free zone.

Do you agree with me??? Ain't I right??? Pakistan should open its borders to India's Muslims and only then get kashmir?

sushobhan my friend you are talking bull, (as usual). The purpose of partition WAS so that Hindus and Muslims can be separated because they were fighting so much. There should NOT BE ONE Muslim in India today

Mr Rajesh R,

That is your subjective interpretation. It is NOT an objective fact. If you look at the propaganda which the Pakistani government spreads, not only in Pakistan but also in the middle East, against India - seldome does the Hindu/Muslim dimension escape the equation. For pakistanis the conflict is one against Hindus NOT Indians. I don't think that you are familiar with the rubbish that is taught in Pakistan schools against India and especially against Hindus

Dear Anastacia,

Firstly, I am not god. I didn't create such a messed up and conflict driven world OK? OBVIOUSLY everyone wants to live in peace and happiness. Nobody wants unecessary quarell. But what can one do??? Simply turn a blind eye to the world's problems and act merry-go-happy as if everything is perfect. That would be self-dellusion. Not all of us live in Alice Wonderland.

Secondly please don't call me a "third class" person cos I am more sophisticated and modern than you will ever be, understand??? Fools like you, automatically denote any race/religion sentiment as being backward and narrow minded without even seriously contemplating what the individual is actually saying and whether or not there might be any truth in it.

Dear scum usa,

you sound like a typical uneducated and unemployed illiterate dog. Rather than wasting time on discussion forums, maybe you should go to the welfare office to pick up your benefit cheque so you can feed your ten trampy children!

Answer 1

Dear
Your Ideas are Good but Childish.......
KASHMIR is NOT a PROBLEM in Itself....
Its All Created By PAKISTAN (a Country of Converted HINDUS who are Now Pretending to be MUSLIMS)

Other Major Problem was Created By Our LIBERAL Leaders Esp GANDHIJI.... who gave the CONCEPT of SECULARISM (DHARMNIRPEKSHTA) in a Country VICTIM of RELIGION Based PARTITION!!!!!!!!!!
Are HINDUSTAN koi DHARMSHALA hai Kya ?????
Hindus Don't have Place to Stay in Whole World Even There OWN Country has been Converted by PSEUDOSECULARS (Congress and Others) into a DHARMSHALA....MUSLIMS/BANGLADESHI/ TIBETENS !!!!!!!
India Should Be Declared a HINDU Rashtra.
Either All the Muslims (CONVERTED HINDUS) should be Brought Back to HINDU MAINSTREAM Or Should be Moved Out of India to PAKISTAN and BANGLADESH if they don't Accept Hinduism.
There is a Need for a Big Movement that MUSLIMS will NOT be Tolerated in this Country Any More.They Should be Packed LIVE/ DEAD in the TRAINS Going to PAKISTAN......In the Same Way ,They Did to HINDUS Living in PAKISTAN !!!!!!!

Hindustani

Answer 2

No, I don't agree.
Your solution is twisting the situation itself.

Kashmir is not a Hindu v Muslim conflict; it is a India v Pakistan conflict.

The real motivation of Pakistan is to paralyze and destroy India (which includes Hindus and Muslims) completely which was evident from the recent train blast. The train was heading towards Pakistan which means certainly there were more Muslims. Still, they blasted the train.

So, even if we do as per your solution, terroism or terrorist activities by Pakistan will not stop, they will continue more vigorously and actively.

Then, what else is the solution. Only time can give a answer for this.

Answer 3

Indis was under a UN Mandate to hold Free Elections in Kashmir to determine it's future. Those elections were to be held in 1955

So India is 52 years late. They have used that time to resettle Hindus into Kashmir so they would be a majority. That is why the Kashmiris turned to force.


By failing to resolve the issue for 52 years, I feel India has disqualified itself as an honest broker. Kashmir should either be independent or Pakistani

Anastasia: You have classes of People?
I assume that you and your friends are First Class People while those who disagree are lower class.
Where do minorities fall on your elitist scale?
Do third and fourth cass persons get shipped to GITMO for disposal?

Answer 4

No. I dont think all indian muslims should be forced out of India. They are true patriotic indians too (maybe some are not). And when the partition happened, all the muslims didn't want to leave. It was that son of a bi tch Jinnah who wanted a partition.And the reason kashmir didnt go to them was because at the time a king was the ruler who didnt want to pick sides. Im not sure what exactly happened but what youre saying doesnt seem right to me.

Answer 5

This is easily said than done!
Actually-if better sense prevails-Musharraf should just keep quiet and leave the fight over Kashmir. The rest of Pakistanis will follow and let the Hindus and Muslims be wherever they are! It is not a fight between Hindus and Muslims-everryone should respect each others religion.

Answer 6

How are you going to tackle the so called secular elements within India. They may like to act god to the Indian Muslims. They will not like to allow a situation where they cannot play the minorities card any more.

Answer 7

well....to some extent u r right. but what about those muslims in india who r very indian and very patriotic about india? there are quite a few such muslims in our country.and they wud love to stay back here and be called indians.

so we can't simply generalise and ask all muslims to go away. remember? india is secular...still!

anyway formation of pakistan was a mistake in the first place...

to please jinnah this blunder of seperating pakistan was done.
and an irrepairabale damage happened to the country called india and it's people.

so may be it should rejoin india and live in harmony.

impossible dream..eh? :-)

Answer 8

no. all the muslims living in india after partition were indian as they regognize themselves. so we should not call or address them as muslims they are indians. so no indian muslim is involved in such nasty work . those are worked by somebody whom we dont know so dont blame our brothers and sisters. i apologise if im wrong anywhere or hurted anywhere.sorry.

british created the diversity within the minds of those some people who forced to divide the nation . -which should not have happened!
now still some people are carring those idiotic diversive thoughts within them and they art hurting all around including themselves. i suppose.

Answer 9

some muslim activists needed a separate state for muslims. That replaced into the reason for 1947 partition. Partition wasn't started to verify a separate hindu state. so a techniques as Kashmir is in touch, it fairly is a factor of India and could stay a factor of India whatever occurs. And concerning to the muslims in India, they are Indians, they are our brothers. you may no longer study them to pakistanis. India is a u . s . a . with fairly super selection of cultures, languages, and religions. Hinduism isn't the identity of an Indian. The identity is Indian-ness. Separateing the country in accordance with religions will merely split aside the country. The presence of India could gradually fade away. Pakistan would call Indian muslims as their non secular brothers, yet whilst it incorporates attractiveness, merely undergo in recommendations what's happenning with taaliban. Edit 01: You communicate approximately Hinduism, and so referred to as Hindu scripts have continuously preached brotherhood, unity, peace. Secondly, the term Hindu replaced into utilized by potential of the europeans to refer the individuals dwelling previous the valleys of river Sindhu. those europeans had no concept what faith those human beings belonged to. The so referred to as Hindu scriptures haven't any descritpion of the term Hindu. Hindusim is a cutlure, a lifestyle. it is not a faith merely because of the fact few human beings around the globe save on with a stupid inhumanitarian course does no longer propose that we could continuously save on with the comparable. And in case you think of employing away Muslims could resolve the countries issues, then please tell me how the hell are you gonna resolve the themes concerning to ALFA's, ULFA's, BODO's, Naxalites, etc.? they are all hindu terrorist companies in India. in case you fairly wanna help the country, then please make the main of a few time in spreading patriotism, unfold the sensation of Indian-ness, the experience of team spirit between Indians. Donot attempt to widen the rifts. all of the excellent... :-)

Answer 10

kashmir(heaven on earth) given to pakistan(hell on earth)???


as far as india's muslims are concerned,they should have be asked to pack up and go west, way back in 1947.however at that moment we were ruled by a fool, influenced by a bigger fool.
i am not trying to generalize all of india's muslims as 'evil' or anything,but the fact remains that a vast majority of india's muslims consider themselves muslims first and indians later.they are more of a burden on the nation's shoulders,or say, a thorn in the development of india.

p.s
i agree that there are many patriotic muslims in india who wanted to stay back after partrition (and were allowed to do so) but at the same time,there were also hindus who wanted to stay back in pakistan.
were they allowed to do so???