Are the undocumented pumping our economy ? Do they pay more taxes than citizens?

Question

How can prove they don't pump our economy? They are the largest spender group in the USA. They send money to Mexico but they spend more here in the land of the free!

Yes. They pay a lots of Taxes... Big Money for Uncle Sam. (fresh greens) oh yeah baby!. The Undocumented, Mexicans or NOT Mexicans pay Taxes.

and

They also spend a lot of greens in retail stores and restaurants.
Oh yeah baby! Big Money!
Mucho bueno saborrr~

Answer 1

They are draining us dry, and they are not contributing to our economy. They take more than they give.

They spend only the necessary amount to stay alive and send the rest back to their native country. WAKE UP!

Answer 2

The only way any worker in the USA pays taxes is with a social security number.

Social security numbers are not issued to illegal aliens.

You have never worked a day in your life or you would already know this.

Most illegal aliens work for cash and do not pay any taxes.

Any illegal alien who says he or she pays taxes is using a STOLEN social security number.
Use of a STOLEN social security number is a FELONY, for which the punishment is a $250,000.00 fine and 25 years in federal prison, followed by deportation, after which you can NEVER immigrate legally to the USA , and you can NEVER become a legal US citizen.

So tell some more lies, the only one who beleives them is you.

Answer 3

Anyone who earns money in the US and spends it here adds to the economy. But as someone else said a lot of illegals take money from the institutions in US society such as hospitals and schools. Some illegals also have mental disease which causes them to ask lots of questions on sites like this but not read the responses of those who answer them.

Answer 4

Time to put the bong away and go to bed.You are becoming delusional.
They do not pump our economy,they lower it by working for less wages than an American would.They do seem to like Wal-Mart though,although most times I see them there,they aren't buying anything,just loitering around the electronics department.
Most pay taxes with a fake SS# ,either made up or stolen from a law abiding citizen.

Answer 5

I don't know of any statistics on this but the problem/benefit isn't about "illegal's spending" If they are illegal, chances are they aren't making very much in the first place - but their kids in school, in the health care system, car accidents with no insurance, work to drive up the cost of living here for everyone including immigrants who came here legally no matter where they came from. Also, the cost of labor has decreased exponentially driving many legal Americans out of work or forcing them to work at a rate that can't support themselves much less their families.

Add to this that the Mexican gangs, specifically the Nortenos and Sodenos, are becoming a huge problem rivaling the growth of the Mafia families in the 1920's. As these gangs gained a little power they quickly turned to prostitution, extortion, and illegal drugs. (Alchohol was illegal for several years creating the powerful gang families of their time just as cocain and heroin are creating powerful gangs of our time.)

All these things add up and it is evident that the flood of illegal immigrants are a major cost to this country in our standard of living and our quality of life.

Answer 6

They are not the largest spending group in the country, where did you get that idea. Most pay very little income tax. They sure dont file, and dont have real social security numbers. They do send a lot of their money back to old mexico.

Answer 7

Doesent matter what you think,the fact is illegals are slaves to corporations and to politicians and when American tax payers have had enough of you fruitless cries of cheap labor we still paying $3 A GALLON FOR GAS AND $3 FOR A HEAD OF LETTUCE ,Guess your not so improtant after all,Keep your diseases in MEXICO,Stop expecting AMERICANS TO PAY FOR YOU A FREE RIDE,cause if you dont fight for your own country you will pay the price in mine.

Answer 8

This is the first time someone has the guts or the intelligent to see why immigration can never close it doors
because not to say that American are lazy because it is not
but to admit that without immigrant to work the economy will be at a stand still \\
I am an American living out side of the US
where I live the economy of that Island is taken care of mostly by American
because the big talk for the rich is to say that they have been to ST Barth
I seen American enter L.V store and pay 10x for a bag when the same bag will have cost cheaper in the US just because it is cool to say *I brough it in ST Barth
as much as the Islander sometime unhappy with some of our visitors, American need to understand that the immigrant that come to the US does not steal the jobs but acctual create the needs for those jobs \
more people to builf housing for, more people to eat, more people for K-mart all = ECONOMY FOR AMERICA
****THEIR MORE BUT I DON'T WANT TO KEEP ON****
BY the way Thank for your ?

Answer 9

They are pumping our economy, as you pump gas at a pump, to get everything out of it that you want.

Answer 10

ILLEGAL ALIENS do not pay taxes!They do NOT have Social Security Cards to pay into.They have NO LEGAL right to work here,so they are under the radar as much as possible.Their employer may deduct from their paychecks for FCI,SSi,etc.,BUT not send it in,unless you count sending the deductions to a special holding fund (for themselves)established just for that purpose.Isn't Mexico also free?Let the Mexicans fix Mexico.*Link*