Are there two Creation stories?

Question

Does Genesis give two accounts of creation? How are these two reconciled?


((This is not a challenge or an attack on Christianity. Just a question.))

I've heard man was made first and last...?

Answer 1

No, there is only one Creation story. There are simply two times it is talked about, with different emphasis in each.

Answer 2

I think that most serious scholars agree that there are actually two narratives in the book of Genesis-- the ALHYM narrative and the JHVH narrative, so named because each of the two accounts uses a different name for God. If you read through the creation story in Genesis, you'll see that it switches back and forth between from one voice to another, often describing the same events twice (though details mentioned in one narrative are often omitted or contradicted in the other). You'll need to look in your Bible's preface, or in a book like Strong's Concordance, to see which Hebrew name for God was used in which passage-- most translations of the Bible render both ALHYM (Elohim) and JHVH (Jehovah) simply as the English "God" or "Lord God," so if you're looking at an English translation you may not be able to identify the transitions from one narrative to the other.

By the way, the book of Exodus (particularly the passages describing the 40 years in the desert and the manna that God provided to the Israelites during this time) also seems to split into two narratives at times, as if two older sources were merged together.

Answer 3

Yes ! Genisis 1 is the more accurate creation story which matches closely with modern day science. (Some of the translation is currently wrong ) Genisis 2 was written by a different author with a lot less insite into the actual creation of the universe.

Answer 4

actually it's just a much longer story than appears in the bible--the two accounts for the creation of man are actually two accounts of the creation of woman, adam had three wives, two of which got edited out

Answer 5

i'm interpreting via Genesis now in my private devotions. I had heard this allegation earlier, and that i observed what some think to be contradictions; in spite of if i do no longer examine them that way, yet see the 2nd financial ruin of Genesis to easily be a extra different rationalization of what became set forth in generalities interior the 1st financial ruin. financial ruin one via financial ruin 2 verse 4 present the creation in chronological order. financial ruin 2 verse 5 and forward bypass into information regarding the backyard of Eden, the formation of Adam and Eve, and likewise the land animals. quite, there's a astonishing coaching on the character of the Trinity once you learn Genesis a million:26,27 with the account of guy's creation interior the 2nd financial ruin; for people who've eyes to work out.

Answer 6

Yep, they probably date from different periods in the redaction of what we now call Genesis, by Jews with different theological emphases. The point is, the Jews who compiled Exodus did not think the two stories were contradictory - they thought they were complimentary. Why can Christians not feel that evolutionary theory is similarly complimentary with Scripture?

Answer 7

There are four different accounts of the ministry of Christ. A little thing like two versions of the Creation myth isn't going to derail things.

Answer 8

There are 2 accounts.
Genesis, chapter 1 is the first account.
Genesis, chapter 2 is a second account.
The first, I believe, are the hi-lights in chronological order.
The second is random, with some detail.

Answer 9

Yes there are two and I don't know how they are reconciled as fact. They are merely two accounts.

Answer 10

Two oral traditions were reconciled the the Bible was finally written down.