Shouldn't birds be free to fly?

Question

I feel very sad when I see a bird confined to a small cage. Somehow it seems unnatural.

jessica-are you spamming me?

Answer 1

Captured or Captive Bred Birds

There is no such animal as a “cage bird.” All caged birds were either captured or captive-bred. No bird was born to be in a cage. In the wild, these beautiful beings are never alone, and if separated for even a moment, they call wildly to their flockmates. They preen each other, fly together, play, and share egg-incubation duties. Many bird species mate for life and share parenting tasks.

Unfortunately, the brilliant colors, speech capabilities, and intelligence of these animals has made them the third-most popular animal companion in the United States, with an estimated 40 million birds confined to cages in homes across the country.(1) As a result, many birds do not get the mental stimulation or companionship that they need, and normal bird behaviors, such as flock-calling, biting, chewing, and throwing food, are often unwelcome to unprepared human guardians. The result may be abandoned or isolated birds who, as reported in The Washington Post, “lose their minds.”(2)

Breeding for Profit
In the late 20th century, the popularity of keeping birds as companions resulted in a smuggling business based in Central America. It proved devastating to wild bird populations, and many birds who were caught died during transport or soon after.(3) The Wild Bird Conservation Act stemmed the flow of birds into the U.S. (although it is still a problem in other countries), but breeding operations have perpetuated the myth that baby birds will grow up to become great companions and have also allowed consumer demand to continue.(4) Just as there are puppy mills, there are bird factories, where breeders warehouse hundreds or thousands of nondomesticated birds for their offspring.

To a “breeder,” a bird is a commodity to be placed with a “mate” to reproduce and seldom—if ever—allowed out of the nest box. Birds who are returned to breeders because of behavioral problems are often kept as “breeding stock,” thus perpetuating the problem behaviors in future generations, as birds are bred for color, not for temperament. Birds do not have to be kept in healthy, hygienic conditions or fed high-quality food to produce eggs. Typically, eggs are removed and incubator-hatched, and babies are hand-fed special formulas. Egg removal signals the female to produce another egg, and another, and another ... eventually ruining her health by depleting her body of much-needed calcium and increasing her risk of becoming egg-bound, a condition that is nearly always fatal.

Even in low-profit enterprises, most birds live in small cages, surrounded by the frightening sounds of many unfamiliar birds. A bird who cannot choose his or her own mate may become depressed, especially if separated from a previous partner. Birds forced to cohabitate in small quarters with a “mate” who is not of their choosing may also become aggressive. The frustration and confusion that they experience after being thrust into a cramped environment with a “stranger” is often displayed as “mate aggression,” in which the male mutilates or even kills his female companion.

Enslaved and Stressed
Unlike dogs and cats, captive-bred birds are only a few generations from their wild ancestors, so many of their natural behaviors do not mesh well with human companionship. Birds are meant to fly and be with others of their own kind. Considering that some parrots fly 30 miles per day in the wild, it’s no wonder that confinement can cause birds to have temper tantrums and mood swings.(5) Birds can also be mischievous and highly destructive. In the wild, they typically play in the treetops and chew on branches or leaves. In captivity, birds display this behavior by chewing on walls, door moldings, electrical or telephone wires, furniture, or any other material that they can get to. “Screaming” is really a bird’s way of calling out to flockmates who, in the wild, might be half a mile away. Punishing birds only increases their frustration and makes them more unruly, as they do not understand that their natural behaviors are not welcome in a human home environment. One researcher who spent time in Australia and Indonesia observing wild lorikeets stated, “Parrots are the primates of the bird world …. They are not content to sit on a perch and sing. They actively want to go and manipulate objects all the time.”(6)

Birds imported from the wild are often frightened and high-strung, and both hand-raised and wild-caught birds often become neurotic, pulling out feathers and mutilating themselves, sometimes to the point of death. When ready to breed, many species naturally pluck some feathers to prepare for nest-building and egg-sitting, but when humans interfere with their natural behaviors and disrupt biological and instinctual cycles by imprisoning birds, plucking becomes a destructive compulsion. Plucking can also be caused by physical problems, such as malnutrition or allergies.

Hand-raised birds crave affection and companionship, human or nonhuman, and sometimes do not like to let their human companions out of their sight. They don’t understand the separation that occurs when their humans go to work or, worse, on vacation. Birds interpret the disappearance of a mate or companion as trouble and may think that they are vulnerable to predators. These fears can compromise birds’ immune systems, and they may succumb to sickness or death.

What You Can Do
Please refuse to stay at resort hotels that keep caged birds as “decorations.” Let your travel agent and the hotel managers know that you will not support this cruelty.

Never buy a bird from a pet store or buy companion-animal supplies or food from stores that sell birds. If you or people you know already have birds and are unable to provide them with companionship and space to fly, please consider taking one of the following actions:
• Find out if there is a bird sanctuary or large indoor/outdoor aviary (or an outdoor one in a very warm climate) where you can release the bird. Ideally, you should place birds with members of their own species. Check the climate, opportunities for mating and privacy, and other key factors.
• If you cannot find a reputable sanctuary, consider placing the bird with someone who has other birds of the same species, allows them to live in a free-flight situation, and will never separate them once they have bonded. Also, make sure that they frequent a board-certified avian veterinarian and do not breed birds.

If you wish to keep the bird, find a companion bird of the same or similar species. A list of avian rescue organizations can be found at www.avianwelfare.org. Check shelters, humane societies, animal rights groups, newspapers, and nursing homes—some birds can live for more than 100 years, often outliving their human companions.(7)

Many people do not want to get another bird because they are afraid that the first bird won’t pay enough attention to them anymore. If the bird does pay less attention to his or her human friends, it just proves how starved for same-species attention he or she was. Two birds can actually be easier to care for than one—with the companionship of another bird, they may be less disruptive and destructive. When the birds have become friends, you can be comforted by the fact that when you are not home, they have each other’s company.

The following tips will help keep birds healthy, calm, and contented:

• Before introducing a new bird, take him or her to an avian veterinarian for a checkup. If the newcomer is in good health and free of diseases, put his or her cage inside the larger flight enclosure so that the birds can see each other. Watch to see how they get along. If they seem friendly to each other, open the door of the small cage after a week. The newcomer will come out when he or she feels comfortable enough. Leave this cage in place, door open, for as many days as the newcomer may want to use it as a safe place—until he or she totally abandons it. Until you’re absolutely sure that the birds have bonded, don’t leave them alone or in a situation where one cannot get away from the other. Do not assume that these two birds will definitely become friends. Be prepared to house the birds separately if they do not bond.
• Let the birds fly free for long periods of time every day—spending as much time out of the cage as possible. Convert your balcony or porch into an aviary or build a good-weather aviary in your backyard if possible. Otherwise, provide a “bird-proof” room or rooms, with no ceiling fans or other bird hazards. Include a bird “gym” or nonpoisonous tree branches (such as dogwood, apple, or elm) for exercise.
• Ideally, birds should get between eight and 12 hours of sleep a night, preferably from dusk on, in a draped flight enclosure or a covered cage.(8)
• Eliminate hazards like ceiling fans, pots of water, open toilet bowls, electrical wires, large glass windows and mirrors, places where birds could become stuck, etc.
• The fumes emitted by overheated nonstick cookware and self-cleaning ovens are deadly to birds—never use them in a home with birds. Use ecologically safe products—no strong cleaners, aerosols, artificial air fresheners, or insecticides. If your apartment complex demands that you make your apartment available to an exterminator, you can legally refuse for “health reasons.”
• Keep food and water containers above perches, high enough so that they do not get soiled with droppings. Containers that have become soiled should be cleaned immediately. Some birds dunk food in their water, and those water containers should be cleaned at least twice a day to prevent bacterial growth. Vitamins should never be administered through the water unless the containers can be thoroughly cleaned every couple of hours, as this encourages bacterial growth.
• Wild birds don’t live on seeds alone, so you shouldn’t condemn your companion bird to such a bland and nutritionally inadequate diet either. Offer a variety of fruits and vegetables along with grains, nuts, cooked beans, and seeds. Birds have tremendously fast metabolisms and cannot be without food for long. Different species have different nutritional needs, so it’s imperative that you read up on your bird or consult with a veterinarian. Malnutrition accounts for more than 90 percent of the health problems and deaths of companion birds.(9) Birds need the proper combination of vitamins, minerals, and amino acids to remain healthy. A good supplement can help, although a variety of the proper foods should meet all your birds’ needs. Visit www.passiontreehouse.com for information on birds’ natural diets and how you can mimic them.
• Never provide grit for your birds. This supplement is marketed as an aid to digestion and contains calcium. Grit is not found in the wild and has no place in a bird’s diet, as it can mineralize in the gizzard and cause crop impactions. Fresh organic vegetables such as broccoli and spinach should be offered instead.
• Make sure that your plants are not poisonous to birds. Common plants that are toxic if birds ingest them include English ivy, philodendron, azaleas, and holly. A good avian veterinarian can provide you with an extensive list.
• Provide shallow containers or a birdbath filled with water. Some birds like to be sprayed with water from a spray bottle. After your birds bathe, keep them away from drafts until their feathers dry.
• Nail trims may be necessary but can often be avoided by providing cement swings and perches. Beak trims should not be needed unless there is an underlying health problem. Chewing on toys is necessary and good for birds—an overgrown beak requires a trip to a good avian veterinarian.
• Provide numerous bird-safe toys for chewing and playing, including clean, nonpoisonous wood. Companion-animal supply companies sell suitable wooden bird toys.

Answer 2

In nature birds die all the time. They really are in danger of predation. In my room, they are not going to be killed by a poacher or an eagle or any of their countless other predators.

I don't confine my birds to a small cage. I confine them to large ones. For their safety. It's not safe for all of my birds to be free flighted, they would kill one another.

Dogs were once wild. They became domesticated over a long period of time. Birds just happen to now be undergoing domestication. In the long run, this ensures species survival. Like it or not, there is no more room for them in the wild at this time. Man is destroying the forest. Think how many dogs there are compared to wolves... domestication is a species survival strategy that WORKS.

Almost all of my birds are rescues. There are bad breeders out there, but there are good ones too. Not all take eggs away to be incubated, and many only let their birds have one clutch per season, just like in the wild. Only these kinds would I consider supporting... but there is no need to support them with so many birds needing homes.

Someone can copy and paste some website, but that doesn't mean they know what they're talking about. I don't feel bad about keeping my birds in cages, because if it wasn't for the pet trade, my birds wouldn't even be alive. I like to think they'd choose caged life (where they're being taken care of properly) over no life at all.

Answer 3

Of course they should be. But consider the birds that were captive bred and raised. To release them to be "free to fly" now would ultimately be putting them to either a slow, painful death of starvation or to be easy prey for other animals because they're so ill adapted to the wild now. The problem is that this pet trade can't really be stopped. Where there are birds in stores and homes, there are people trying to breed them. Most are very poorly educated and do it improperly, resulting in not only more captive birds, but captive birds with bad genetics, poor health, and systems that succumb easily to illness.

However, consider the people who take the effort to provide to their captive pet birds large aviary or flight cages, decent diets, regular health visits, proper interaction, mental stimulation, and much free-flying time. It may not be in the wild, in their natural habitat, but it's better than what people used to do - put birds of any size in teeny, tiny round cages where they couldn't stand straight or stretch, and where the roundness caused anxiety and neurosis. Caging birds is very unnatural, but at this point, it's a part of our society. I would say to stay optimistic about it and think about the good, caring owners who do not support this sort of pet trade and would rather rescue birds who are left homeless due to irresponsible owners with birds that can't be returned to the wild.

Answer 4

Free in their NATIVE environment.
However, many pet birds cannot survive the rigors of the wild, native or not. They are used to getting fed, watered, and having a warm, dry place to live, especially those born and hand raised in captivity. To set them "free" into an indifferent world would be a death sentence.

Obviously, there are exceptions. Like the Ring-necked Doves that someone released in Southern Colorado. They have multiplied into large flocks that descend upon and destroy farmer's crops.
Thus, in the US, it is illegal to set non-native animals free, birds included.
.

Answer 5

My three birds have as much freedom as I can safely give them. I don't clip their wings but take extra precautions against escape (I have screen "curtains" over doors that open to the outside world). The type of birds I have actually seem to prefer hopping than flying (they're caiques and it's a caique thing) -- or riding around on me while I do housework. :)

Answer 6

I completely agree. And the same with fish in an aquarium. And even animals in a zoo. They should all be in their natural habitat. If you want to see a wonderful site, go to www.palemale.com and look at the beautiful hawks who have made a nest right in New York City. It will make you feel good.

Answer 7

Cockatiels poop on conventional about each 15-20 minutes. at the same time as they're allowed to have loose flight they eliminate ideal earlier take off and it would not remember the position they're at the same time as they take off, they're going to eliminate. you are able to potty practice your tiel to pass interior the cage or over a trash can by getting acquainted with his/her conventional time between poops and watch for the indicators (backing up, putting his/her tail adversarial to the floor or your shoulder or perhaps with he/she is sitting on). once you comprehend a thanks to examine the indicators and characteristic a good idea of ways in many cases your tiel receives rid of then only take him/her to the cage previously and say "pass potty" or perhaps with command you opt to apply. Then provide praise or a take care of at the same time as the pastime is done effectively! do this in many cases sufficient and lengthy sufficient and do it anytime and ultimately the chook will go back to the cage or different specified potty spot and pass with out prompting.

Answer 8

well if there outside birds yes they will know how to get there own food but if there birds that have been in a cages then NO b/c they wouln't know what to eat and they'll die there use to being feed...

Answer 9

Not all birds are big on flying. Quail only fly to escape enemies and turkeys and chickens just fly to roost.

Answer 10

i think they should be free.

Answer 11

sure y not