is it rude to tell parents their kids r fat?

Question

I'm sure the parent is responsible for this to some degree. do they care about health or is it irresponsible?

Answer 1

Surely the parent knows their child is overweight. Mind your own business.

Answer 2

I am small and petite and on my mother's side of the family my uncles, my grandfather and my brother are all 6'1"+ and my mother and my aunts are over 5'8". My ex-husband is 6'4" and his sister is 5'9". When my daughter was a baby and people saw us together they would always comment, "My God! What are you feeding her?!"
It really upset me. I didn't feel like I needed to explain to these rude individuals that most of the babies in my family are naturally tall and plump and that I avoided feeding my baby foods with added sugar and that breastfed babies are usually chubbier because it's high in fat!
It wasn't until she was more than 3 years old that she shed a lot of her baby fat and people stopped making comments or asking accusing questions.
You probably don't know the whole situation.
For example, my husband avoids carbs, refined sugar and trans fat and keeps himself on a very strict diet and exercises daily but has a hard time losing weight because of a thyroid condition.
But does he have to explain this to anyone who feels it's their business to proclaim, "You're fat!"?

If you think the parents of this child are not properly caring for them and essentially putting their child's life in danger by stuffing them with junk food then call Children's Protective Services. They'll question the parents and others who know the family, they'll talk with the school, speak with their pediatrician and look at their medical records and properly asses if the parents are abusing or neglecting their child.

Otherwise, mind your business!

Answer 3

hi, properly if it particularly is particularly actual approximately your mum, then i think of she is'nt an relatively incredible guy or woman in any respect. My 13 year previous daughter had a weight issue too, so what she finished grow to be eat all her prevalent nutrients, yet decrease the element length. decrease out chocolates and crisps, yet no longer all at the same time. possibly provide your self a take care of a pair of times a week. She additionally replaced fizzy juice with nonetheless orange or blackcurrant. Then she went for a walk everynight. She has now lost 4 stone, and seems and feels great. Why do no longer you provide this a attempt, yet do it without telling everyone. That way you wont get teased out of your loved ones. i in my opinion experience for you, by using fact it particularly isn't any longer elementary while human beings do no longer settle for you for who you're, relatively your person family contributors. sturdy success and save your chin up, you will get there. remember in case you will shed some pounds, do it sensibly and don't starve your self, by using fact think approximately to eat to truly shed some pounds. i'm rooting for you, i be attentive to you're able to do it!

Answer 4

I think it depends. If you are a P.E teacher or school health professional, it is OK to discuss with parents the concerns you have about their child, and the implications that their size may have on their health. The P.E teachers at my schools have done that before. If you are just some random person who sees a "fat" kid somewhere, then keep it to yourself, you would merely be stating the obvious.

Answer 5

That would be pretty rude. "Hey Sandy - Little Johnny there is looking kind of porky today. Don't you think you should lay off the Twinkies at home?"

I mean, to some extent, I can see wanting to say it. Parents are responsible for their children's health. But I can't see a nice way to say it that wouldn't come off as sounding rude.

Answer 6

Look at it this way, if you had kids and they were overweight, would you want some stranger telling you this?

Mind your own business unless your opinion is asked.

The parents are responsible and its up the the family doctor and maybe teachers to say something to the parents.

Answer 7

I am sure their doctor will talk to them if the childs health is in danger. It would be very rude to tell someone their kid is fat, especially if the kid could hear you.

Answer 8

You probably shouldn't say that to the parent regardless of how much you think it. People are usually pretty protective of their kids. Besides, the parents see their kids everyday...so they already know that their kids are fat.

Answer 9

Are the parents visually impaired, and therefore unable to see that their child is fat? Are you a caregiver to the family (doctor, etc.)? No? Then mind your own business.

Answer 10

If you want to get punched in the face by a raging hippo I would go right ahead and tell them....