What did prophet Muhamemd mean by saying that god will burn Christians and Jews for the sins of Muslims?

Question

Ther is a prophetic stateent told by prophet Muhammed where he told his companions that god will burn Jews and Christins in hell for all the sins of Muslims so that he can put Muslims in paradise instaed.

http://hadith.al-islam.com/Display/Display.asp?Doc=1&Rec=6397

http://hadith.al-islam.com/Display/Display.asp?Doc=1&Rec=6395

http://hadith.al-islam.com/Display/Display.asp?Doc=1&Rec=6396

Is this fairness from god to punish someone for another one's sins?

Answer 1

Is it fair for Christians to bear the sin of Adam?? Ask them. They say God sent his son to relieve us of Adam's sin, others say God came down himself....anyway, God told us in the Quran:
39: verse 7:
"No laden soul will bear another’s load. Then unto your Lord is your return; and He will tell you what ye used to do. Lo! He knoweth what is in the breasts (of men)."
You are spending a lot of time checking any site that has some shady story about our Prophet. Do you hate him that much?? Enjoy your hatred.

Answer 2

Ok..... Please note that you are not translating the stateent well. and here it is..
Allah will forgive muslims who have burdens of sins like mountains (just because they believe in him and in the prophet) but he will keep the sins on the jews and the christians
and also the only way that allah will burn them is when they make something new that is forbiddin in the islam but due to the muslims poor knowledge we don't know if it is a sin or not so we follow it... in this case the sin is on the jews and on us in the same time so allah might forgive us and he will burn them for making us do wrong....

Answer 3

You've been quoting all sorts of wierd things which you attribute to prophet Muhammad (SAW), I have never heard of him having said something like this, in fact the Quran clearly states that everyone is responsible for his own actions, a son cannot carry the burden of the father nor can a father carry the burden of the son. So stop posting links to sites which no one can understand, being in Arabic and can't verify.

Answer 4

The link is in Arabic, i bet you donot know Arabic.

Theres no such Sahih Hadith. God is just and one of his names/attribues is Adil which means Just.

If the link does infact state that, then you must be knowing there are lots of Anti-Islamic sites. This page should be one of them spreading mis-information about Islam. What does it take to make up the thinks and malign some one, not much effort.

If you have any question about Physics do you put that to Arts teacher. If you are sincere about getting answers on Islam http://www.sunnipath.com

How much it is opposed, the truth will prevail.

Answer 5

You're playing with us, aren't you? relying on the fact that you'll barely find someone here who knows Arabic.. But I'm here for you...

The Hadith is Null, as "Muslim" (the taler) Doubted it's authentication and said ‏لا أدري ممن الشك "I'm not sure I doubt which taler".. And this is written on the front page of the website you brought this Hadith from.. So, either you don't read Arabic, and have a translator that his knowledge to Arabic is equal to my knowledge to Chinese language, or you know Arabic and trying to falsify the facts.. and I can't understand why.

Answer 6

I see that ignorance is so cheap these days! Please don't interpret something nor twist it around. It doesn't look good at all. In Islam, we beleive that no person will carry the sin of another. Everyone is responsible for his or her own deeds.

Answer 7

this seem some christain site i m seeing some other references of hadith from here also that do not exists in real...please check from some muslim scholar if u really intereested to clear ur concept.

Answer 8

Hmmm...

Makes me wonder if you're really Muslim or not.

No dear... In Islam, no one carries anyone's burden.

Every person is responsible for his/her own deeds


Surah Az-Zummar, verse 7 says it nice and clear...

{ وَلَا تَزِرُ وَازِرَةٌ وِزْرَ أُخْرَى}

{No bearer of burdens can bear the burden of another.}


Read your Qur'an if you're Muslim, and if you're not Muslim, it's not nice to lie .


Peace.

Answer 9

Total rubbish, This is not true. Never ever heard of it, if its not in the Quran then its no true.

Answer 10

wher did u read those stuff.no such thing.
God won't burden people with others' sins.
we hv to b responsible with our own deeds.