Are the justifications for illegal immigration the same as the justificaitons for slavery?

Question

During the pre civil war years slavery was "justified" because it kept the cost down on the agricultural products that slaves produced. Afterall, hiring paid workers would have driven up the price of cotton and other such products. It seems that illegal immigration in California is justified because their low wages keep the cost of oranges down. Those who support illegal immigration for no other reason than keeping the cost of agricultural produce and gardening work low are no different than the consumers who demaned low cost cotton during the slave era.

Answer 1

I agree, illegal aliens are modern day slaves, with more freedom of choice and humane treatment . Great comparison!

Answer 2

Slaves didn't have a choice to be in the US, but illegal immigrants do, and they hurt every american citizen when we have to pay taxes for social programs to support them, give up our jobs because they have no choice but to work cheaper than an american, which benefits no one but the employer that hires them. There is always the all popular excuse that they will do the jobs americans won't do, this is a bunch of garbage, those jobs were being done by americans before any immigrant set foot in this country, and would continue to get done if they were deported. Politicians never finish the sentence, Americans will not do the jobs the illegal alien will do, FOR SLAVE WAGES, and we as americans should not be subjected to Gov't greed, and ENFORCE THE LAW. Being in this country illegal is a Felony, so why are the illegals not being prosecuted and deported. I have a very simple solution to the immigration problem: Prosecute all landlords that house them, prosecute all employers that hire them, and make them get unforgeable ID's for those here legally and make it to where their legal status can be electronically verified, and make amnesty for those in violation non-existant, jail time and deportation should be the penalty. I personally don't care that people want to make this country their home, just do it LEGALLY and pay taxes like i do, and in the same proportions as i do.

Answer 3

Since when has the cost of anything been kept down? What planet are you living on? They pay the illegal immigrants low wages so that the CEO's can line their pockets with more money, not keep costs down for us. That's also why so many companies are outsourcing jobs to other countries--because it's cheaper to pay thrid-world workers and it saves the companies money, not us.

Answer 4

No, i think of that is greater alongside the line of sharecroppers. After the Civil conflict the freed slaves that stayed interior the South have been taken great element approximately via plantation proprietors. They knew the freed slaves have been poor and desperately needed artwork and money. so as that they've been employed as sharecroppers on those plantations. they might frequently stay to tell the tale or close to the plantations/farms. they might then artwork on those farms which gave them look after and little or no money. The sharecroppers might borrow money from the plantation proprietors for the crop seed and for kit. they might plant, have a tendency, and %. all the plant life on the plantation(merely like the slaves) yet on the top of the crop season they might might desire to pay returned the plantation proprietors and save what money that they had left. in spite of the shown fact that, in the time of a foul crop season, the sharecroppers could not pay returned the money and can be in debt to the plantation proprietor. this may be a non-provide up cycle because it replaced into not elementary for the families to artwork off the debt and pay returned the money from the present season. they might frequently fall right into a hollow of debt that replaced into impossible to dig out of. The families could not leave till they paid all charges. They have been manipulated via the plantation proprietor. So now he have been given unfastened artwork that replaced into technically criminal as they have been paid......they might merely might desire to pay it returned to the plantation proprietor to repay some debt. i recognize i rambeled somewhat, yet returned to the unique element. The unlawful immigrants are being manipulated via the individuals who employed them. it particularly is low-fee artwork, and the staff can artwork long hours for little pay. Now are not getting me incorrect, unlawful immigrants thieve jobs from human beings. My stepdad lost many activity opportunities to unlawful immigrants. yet that still does not make it suited. that is not slavery with the aid of fact they are being manipulated not compelled to artwork. The slaves have been compelled to artwork.

Answer 5

You might be pushing the metaphor a bit too far, but I think you are correct. Cheap labor is what corporate America loves best. A fair and livable wage is somehow a dirty word in a time when CEO's and top executives are literally raking in money. It's really obscene.

Corp. America sends good jobs to Mexico and then hires illegals here in the US. And of course China is the recipient of good American jobs as well, because their workers actually live on site, work 12 hour days and are content to make no money.

It's disgusting...

Answer 6

Not exactly because these guys volunteered their services and in many cases purposely chose to work for less. The slaves didn't have a choice. Secondly it is not benefitting me because nothing they are doing is lowering my price......it's additional money in the pocket of the employer or tax free money in their own pocket. The illegals are free to go anytime they want. Business is using it as an excuse or a threat.......because they still want their huge profits. They'd rather squeeze it out of us than to pinch away a little of their profits.

Answer 7

Perhaps such justifications are a prelude to legalized slavery. The US has a well established history of such practices. To read a short history of those programs, go to Bracero Program at Wikipedia.com. There is much more about the program in the research department of your local or college library. I highly recommend you read about the history of the Bracero Program.

Answer 8

There's no justification for illegal immigration. It's "illegal" and that's the end of it. You can accomplish the same thing (controlling costs) with legal immigration through the already existent guest worker programs. We're letting Mexico dictate what we do here in America and that's unacceptable.

Answer 9

You are right to a point. During slavery, the slaves were brought here unwillingly and were sold as stock. Today's illegal immigrants pay to come here in most instances and most but not all are free to roam from one location to the other. They are not sold as stock.

Answer 10

Very interesting analogy. I think it fits for the people who want cheap exploitable labor. However, Many farmers cant get us citizens to work for any wage, or so they say. I imagine if they raised the wages and the prices, there would always be some farmer using illegal labor to sell cheaper.

Answer 11

slaves were brought against their will.
illegal immigrants break into this country.
they don't HAVE to be subjected to the treatment they get by coming into this country. but because they are uneducated and desperate what else can they do?

if i wasn't paying taxes for the illegal immigration problems in this country...more specifically being a resident of california..i would have no problem paying extra for my produce.