Why somebody can believe Jesus is Muslim??

Question

Is...the last muslim "west" interpretation Quoran, interpretation that according with the centuries had of curse changed to accomodate the interest of the muslim politians in turn...

Jesus never beat women, never told "a good Muslim should not beat women in the face" which indeed Muhammed told.

My good Jesus always made of women a priority and a special being, even having Magdalene as a student and posibly wife, far away from the Islam today which even doesn´t alow women in their Churches...

My good Jesus knew he will Crucified and didn´t ask for protection nor be agressive, won all his conversations by the word, would not agree with jihads, bombs, suicides.

Jesus asked to be benevolent with people, not to cut their hands or feet in case of robbery as Mohammed himself did.

My good Jesus never had been in a military action or expedition, Mohammed was in 80 comanded by himself and commited murder by his own hands and of course Jesus never married a child 6 years old.

So, don´t take it bad, if you believe in Mohamed, good for you, but to belive Christ will come as a Muslim...

My friend, not at all as the translation refered to be jesus is "the people of the book" which meant by those days, the Jewish...

And please, i don´t need to be insulted, i am explaining my reasons, just so... if you can´t answer without insults you can keep it to yourself...

Answer 1

Well, my answer to Muslimrose, always with no offense at all but... Hit the women..Slightly?...to marry a girl of 6 years old a man in his 50s is aceptable because of the hot weather?, you believe in Jesus who was crucied cause he told he was a direct representation of God, but you believe that Mohamed who by the way had a very different life than Jesus...is the last and THE PROPHET?, yes...the mosques are churches basically, aren´t they?
Quoran untoached...all muslims has such expression...if mohammed could not write nor read...who tells you that what it is there is what was said?...untoached...when was written on the "visions" and revelations of a man that even hiself broke his own rules 100s of times...he got married with 10 women...ah..oh..he had revelations about his "pleasures" was ok, other people had to be hand cut or foo cut, cause a "revelation"...don´t make me laugh please.

Tha is why the world has so many problems with muslims, the basement you have is always so twisted, so half truth... Quoran untoached?, what about mary and Marian? your whole religion had been fundamented in Chrisitianity just always adding something more... Jesus coming as muslim?...
the original Quoran says "the people of the book", Quoran speaks about the jewish, this is the way they was called by them...
Quoran untoached...do you believe that a guy that kills in jihad will have 69 virgins in heaven?...really, muslim rose, you have to have a really poor judment to believe in those things writen in the century 3 by guys, by the way...who was there..._
not even a leliable, trustful person of nothing... the story of my jesus was written by some of their students who had a really trustfull life, not in war marrying children... helping poor people.

by the way, the standards of those days in this was the same of these days, but nobody told anything cause your mohammed would cut their heads off. Nice "prophet"

Answer 2

Islam means submission referring to submission to Allah's Sharia law.

Christians believe that Jesus perfectly followed his Father God's will and direction for his life. By that simple understanding, Jesus was a Muslim because he was submissive to God.

However, Jesus was obedient to God, even to the point of dying on the cross. For some reason, Mohammad wrote in the Koran that Jesus didn't die on the cross, but Allah made it appear that way, and deceived people into believing so. This I always find curious, as there is no evidence to support this idea, especially coming from someone (or some spiritual force) about 600 years later. It also portrays Allah as a liar. Christians would consider calling God a liar to be blasphemous, but the Koran describes Allah as the Prince of all deceivers!

Bottom line is if Jesus was perfectly obedient to God's will then he died on a cross. If he didn't die on a cross then he wasn't submissive to Allah's will, and therefore cannot be a Muslim.

If Jesus died on the cross then the Christians are right. If he didn't die on the cross then the Muslims are right, but Allah is a brilliant liar.

(Jesus was executed on a charge of blasphemy for claiming to be God, which was punishable by death it was such a serious crime).

Answer 3

Four edited Gospels do not amount to definitive testimony. You can never be completely sure what he really said and did.
Friends of Christ included Zealots, the "Terrorists" of their day. The high Priest had an ear cut off when they arrested Jesus after the last supper. Not quite as peaceful as you paint him.

Remember Christ rode into Jerusalem upon a donkey and was hailed by people waving palm fronts. The last time this happened was the occasion of David arriving in the Holy City for his coronation as "King of the Jews", sound familar?

Jesus was born in the same town as David, came from the same tribe, was "baptised" by John as David was annointed by Aaron, John was Aaron's descendant, could Jesus have been David's heir?

It would explain much, not least why the Romans killed him - if Jesus really was the King of the Jews then Rome as the occuping power were obligated to eliminate him to prevent revolt.

Only that can explain his method of execution. Crucifixtion was a strictly reserved punishment for enemies of the state, ie Spartacus and his slave army. No blasphemer or thief would have been crucified, they would have been stoned and not by Romans, but by Jews.

So that could potentially leave your Christ in the unenviable position as leader of a rising insurgency who falls in the lap of the enemy. The revolt would have to move on without it's King and at Massada in 66A.D. it came to it's heartbreaking, bloody end when rather than surrender, the remaining Jewish rebels and their families cut their own throats and that of their children.

Answer 4

Sahih al-Bukhari, quantity 3, e book 40 3: Kitab-ul-`Ilm (e book of know-how), Hâdith type 656: Narrated Abu Hurairah: Allah's Apostle stated, "The Hour is purely no longer wide-unfold till the son of Mary (i.e. Jesus) descends among you as a purely ruler, he will ruin the go, kill the pigs, and abolish the Jizya tax. money would be in abundance so as that no one will settle for it (as charitable presents)" —accrued with the help of Muhammad al-Bukhari, Sahih al-Bukhari

Answer 5

There's really such a glare difference between Jesus and Mu hammed. And yet they choose the latter because, according to them, he's the last prophet of God, the current one. But my suspicion is simply for them to set up their own megalomaniac identity to rival the biggest religion of today. To proclaim "the last prophet" alone, he carries a bigger weight than Jesus as the bearer of the latest "truth" and putting that nice period no other religions can now snatched the title and bestow upon their own "prophet" version. Jesus having delegated the role of mere prophet got even sidestepped as an obsolete prophet with Mu hammed entry.

An attempt by other religions or heretics to recognize personality as prophet(e.g. Nostradamus, Edgar Cayce) is construed to be a false prophet in the eyes of the Muslim worlds.

It was really a clever ploy hatched over centuries that make what is Islam today. We can't change that. We can't stopped the fastest growing religion from achieving their quest of making Islam the only religion in the world. They are very motivated. They live no stone unturn. Taking advantage of the every loopholes and weaknesses of the lenient society.

They are allowed to practice their faith and express their religious viewpoint in any Christian countries. But some Muslim countries banned religious practices other than Islam. There government will not allow access deemed anti-Islamic website.

But they can not be blamed for that. It was a seed planted in their mind/heart over centuries of Islamic practices that can not be undone overnight. Stick to your faith and be happy that somehow you are gifted with knowledge to see that glare difference and choose what best represent your ideals.

Answer 6

hey sir , don't say things u don't fully understand.

iam muslim , i love jesus so much , not cuz i don't believe that hs io son of god as u believe , that would mean that i don't believe in him , on the contrary , we muslims are ordered to follow all prophets ,including jesus (peace be upon him).

* islam don't order us to beat women , and this verse u are referring to , beating isn't to till harmness rather it is beating lightly nearly nothing , just as worning and behaving the man's wife.

*we don't have churches , we have mosques , and ther is nothinng no where in islam , that prevents muslim women from going to mosque, on the contrary , the prophet encourged them to and forbide muslm men from preventing them.

*jihad dosn't mean holy war , or murdering ppl , its main meaning is to strive for goodness and peace, and the greatest jihad is self jihad.

*marriage of mother aysha has an explanation , simpley u arenot going to compare todaystandards with 1400 b4 standadards , besides hot climates differ alot from cold climate.

*fighting in islam has its own ethics , and islam showed the limits between treating combatants and non combatants , and it was usually the last resort.

ps: all what i said i have evidence to it .

stop comparing islam to ur religion cuz u won't like what i might show to u.

islam that u don't like many in it , is the only divine religion that is NEVER changed since it was reveled.

read what non muslims said about our prophet, i picked just one example:
"My choice of Muhammad to lead the list of the world's most influential persons may surprise some readers and may be questioned by others, but he was the only man in history who was supremely successful on both the religious and secular level."
(Michael H. Hart, THE 100: A RANKING OF THE MOST INFLUENTIAL PERSONS IN HISTORY, New York: Hart Publishing Company, Inc., 1978, p. 33.)

http://uk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AhN087XUPIHO53hNhj21iuEhBgx.?qid=20061117234957AAGQtqj



*

Answer 7

well as jesus was a jew and his followers became christians then surely mohammed having founded islam was the 1st muslim . so jesus wasnt a muslim

Answer 8

I know Jesus is our Christ, who's mohammed thought he'd retired from boxing years ago.

Answer 9

Because Jesus believe in one God too as do Muslims and Jews.

Answer 10

Well, I am a christian and I can see where you come from, but you have to read all of both books to make any judgement. (appologies if you have)