Rationally, shouldn't consentual adult incest be legalized, and producing children through incest be illegal

Question

Let us set aside sentiment and religious ideas. You and I have no right to force our religious ideas on anyone else. Let us also set aside ideas of gross or disgusting. We have no right to force our asthetics on anyone else.

Seeing that adult brothers and sisters involved in incestuous relationships are not hurting anyone else as long as they do not produce children, shouldn't incestuous marriages and relationships be legalized. However, since they arguably hurt someone by having children, this should be illegal.

What say you. Please no religious arguments, only rational ones. Thank you.

Answer 1

rationally yes,

two consenting adults should be allowed to an incestuous relationship regardless if they are brother and sister.

The fact is though this can be twisted for serious child abuse.

Imagine parents that brainwash their kids from a young age to be with each other as a way to control them.

Not to mention their is a serious cultural taboo that would prevent this from being permitted for the near future.

Answer 2

I understand your good judgment. And it does have advantage. It shouldnt be disallowed with the aid of public disgust as that's opinion, not certainty nor a good reason in the back of not allowing it. Allot of issues disgust me, unfortuantely none of them are unlawful. And so some distance as faith, nicely, that too is an argument of opinion. religious ideals should not be a foundation to % a legal situation. inspite of each and everything, there is meant to be a seperation between church and state. and because religious ideals variety extensively, you ought to in all possibility locate a church or religous perception that experience it particularly is okay to be married, if incest is a element. in all possibility, I stated. with the objective to me, the only one that could have advantage is the organic and organic element. yet lower back, you will have a new child with ailment and stipulations in basic terms from marrying every physique that carrys particular ailments or predilictions of circumstances or ailments and that they are actually not deemed not allowed to have little ones. they are cautioned to not, yet in the top, the alternative continues to be in the couple. So, with all that for the time of techniques, i assume it would be ok for them to marry. in the top, i in my view think of it is with the aid of society greater effective than the different factors or motives you point out. particularly, I do. and you shouldnt be waiting to alter morality

Answer 3

I think you need to give up the drugs!