Did Iran Capture British Sailors in Iranian waters or Were they in international waters ?

Question

which side do you believe ?

Answer 1

The British are a bit more believable

Answer 2

Absolutely I believe the British! The news reports I saw said the Brits were actually in Iraqi waters. This is an act of war. The British military should be beating the hell out of Iran until their military personnel are returned unharmed. And America should back the Brits.

Answer 3

those are disputed waters - the bluejobs in all possibility had orders to stay on the Iraqi part, yet it is exactly the water the Iranians think of is theirs. i can not see why those adult adult males have been spent time to dry - truthfully after final time, in case you know the Iranians are going to make slightly of taking photos you and having a coach-trial, you will not deliver them in except they have have been given the variety of back-as much as make an excellent combat of it? i'm making a gamble they have been bait - it rather is the only thank you to make experience of it. on an identical time as the Iranians are dancing and rejoicing at humbling the Little devil, their take care of's down for in basic terms long sufficient for SAS/SBS to covertly enter the country and do what they should. it rather is an old, old, dodge: their defences see what you like them to be certain (0.5 a dozen sprog sailors up **** Creek and not using a paddle) who're very conspicuously there. Alll attainable Iraninans steam in to make a bust. on an identical time as their interest is diverted, your particular forces nip in covertly for the time of the hollow. (i think this has been utilized in Northern eire some cases to grant a smokescreen for particular forces crossing the border and doing what they had to do in the Republic). a minimum of i'm hoping that's what's occurring - it will make the RN seem much less inept and ineffective... yet oh for a matching incident the place the Iranians set off a reallty decisive reaction and get the $hit kicked out of them...

Answer 4

The British claim the sailors were in Iraqi territorial waters. The Iranians claim that they were in Iranian territorial waters. I think that they were in Iraqi waters because I tend to think that the British are more reliable.

Answer 5

Iran claims that the British have some troubles with a computer virus affecting their navigation systems. I think Britain's ASW computer systems are vulnerable to the same virus. It will be a pity when Iran's six subs fail to report home - cause unknown.

Answer 6

I believe it was a setup. The ship was most likely in Iraqi waters when the Brits boarded her and the captain of the ship allowed it to drift or move into Iranian waters. The arrival of the Iranian boats was all to convenient. The Iranians are desperate for trading material as the UN coses in on them. This so typical of poor middle eastern countries using kidnnaping as a tool.

Answer 7

no they were in Iraq waters. the news showed how the British sailors had just searched an Iraqi ship suspected of carrying contraband. after the British left that ship the Iranian's moved in with battle cruisers. rubber dinghy's and personal side arm's don't beat battle cruisers armed with machine gun's and canons.

Answer 8

There is absolutely no reason to believe Iran. They are just fueling the hate machine in the Middle East.

The UK and US board ships to make sure they aren't doing anythign illegal every day. They know where they are allowed to go.l

Answer 9

I can't believe Iran has any credibility whatsoever in the world. Sad.

Answer 10

The news said that they were near an border line with Iran that has been contested for many years but they really would have known that so they probably were in a place they knew they shouldnt be.