do you agree with smacking a naked butt?do you agree with putting a child over your knee for a spank?

Question

me and my sisters get are skirts and pants pulled down my are mom dad nan and grandad if we are really bad and put over there knees yes i find it painful and if im in public embarising but its affective and we behaive much better now in public and at home since we get spanked. Take today i through a fit and started being sassy in a resteraunt because i didnt want orange i wanted coke but my mum said No so i through the orange on the floor and broke the cup my mum took me to the bathroom and as there was a que she took me to the sinks pulled down my knickers and lifed up my skirt and put me over her knee. The adults were saying that girl deserverd that and the kids were laughing i went down appolagised and my mum maid me sit on my spanked but witch hurt but i deserved it and my grandad spanked my 6 yr old sister on her bear butt in the park as she spat at a kid and then kickedhis mum she didnt get to go back and play and when he asked her what she had learnt she said not to hit or spit

because i just wonder what other people about spanking.

if you were my mother and i did this what would you do?

no i am 11 yrs old and most my friends get spanked the same way as me my grandfather is allowed to punish us only because he is such a close family member i very rarely act out nowbecause i dont like geting smacked especially in public i think before i do things alot more now.

Answer 1

yeah, ur parents can and prolly will whip u until u move out if u dont behave... u threw ur cup and broke it... no effience but how old r u... they are just showin u love in a wierd way but they want to teach whats right so that when u get older u know whats right from wrong...it doesnt teach them to be violent because they will prolly get whipped for beiung violent then they know that thats wrong too... so yeah i completely agree with spankin.

Answer 2

If I was your mother and you threw a tantrum in a public place I would take you out of there and you would get punished at home.
I believe in spanking but not on a bare butt and not if the child is over a certain age. I think if a child is over the age of 5 then they shouldn't be spanked any more and should only be sent to time-out or get something taken away.
I have a toddler who gets spankings but only when he has a diaper on and I make sure it doesn't cause a lot of pain.

I would have grounded you for a week with no phone or TV. You wouldn't be allowed to play outside or with friends.

I don't agree with how your mom and dad are disciplining you.

Answer 3

If you were my child I'd be like in my 70's or 80's. Grow up, if you want to know about people liking spankings as part of sexual pleasure then just ask it. If you are some little kid then trun your parents in for abuse. I fully believe in spankings, but not at or above the age of 9. If you are getting pleasure from your parents spanking you and it makes you do the right thing, then have them get a shock collar for you. Everytime you act badly you can control the switch and do it yourself...


P.S. the only reason why people have a problem with spankings now adays is because it has been turned into abuse. God said "Spare the rod, spoil the child". This is true!

Answer 4

I know that I just answered your similar question on this same subject a few minutes ago. The answer is yes it is appropriate to spank children for unruly behavior even in public. No, it is not appropriate to spank children with their pants down. Only a sexual deviate would do such a thing which I am starting to see this and you as a sexual deviate. Are you even a little girl or a perverted old child molester trying to get exited. If so, I am now going to be watching for you!! Yes, the picture on my profile is accurate.

Answer 5

spare the rod spoil the child????!! the rod dosen't only mead spankings the rod means guidance,teaching educatin dicipline and being punished for doing somethig wrong, i do beleive in spankings but as a last resort. i wouldn't spank my future kids in public, not with anti spankers quick to call the cops when they see a parent punishing their child.

i think spankings should stop whn the child shows s/he is mature enough (like around 13-14) then i'd start groundings taking away stuff etc

((** dosent care about the thumbs down from the anti spankers))

Answer 6

deborah, i think thats your nickname, well im in the uk. you can't get arrested for smacking a child; not your own; unless you leave a bruise. However, im not sure how people would react to pulling their underwear down in public. Im pretty sure that you could be arrested for that. After all; you dont know who is looking at your child in public. Its creepy and sick.

Answer 7

There are other ways to handle this situation...I do not agree pulling down the pants and spanking! However, if you did that to me...I would have made you clean up your mess and apologize to everyone who had to see you acting like an idiot!!

Answer 8

Yes, I agree with spanking a child. There is so much crap that a parent can't spank their child because that is child abuse, that is BULLS$%^. If we hit our kids when they do something bad then we go to jail and if our kids get arrested we are looked up as parents who don't care.

If I gave birth I will discipline my child the way I want whether you think is right or wrong.

Answer 9

if you're 11 you shouldnt be throwing fits in public over something as stupid as soda. If you dont like getting spanked then stop being a brat and listen to your parents.

Answer 10

What is your obsession with spanking? All your questions are about the same thing.

Answer 11

Yes it is OK there is a lot of young adults that should have been done to years ago