Is God imperfect or just impossible?

Question

Let us suppose that this perfect God did create the universe. Humans were the crown of his creation, since they were created in God's image and have the ability to make decisions. However, these humans spoiled the original perfection by choosing to disobey God.

If something is perfect, nothing imperfect can come from it. Someone once said that bad fruit cannot come from a good tree, and yet this "perfect" God created a "perfect" universe which was rendered imperfect by the "perfect" humans. The ultimate source of imperfection is God. What is perfect cannot become imperfect, so humans must have been created imperfect. What is perfect cannot create anything imperfect, so God must be imperfect to have created these imperfect humans. A perfect God who creates imperfect humans is impossible.

Answer 1

God created all souls, which *are* perfect.

As regards the rest of your reasoning ... the definition of "perfect" can vary. What you deem to be imperfect may be absolutely perfect to me.

Answer 2

One could also turn your argument on itself and claim that Man is NOT imperfect and that all that transpires as a result of Man's decisions is perfect, although that sounds ridiculous when you look at what Man does.

If Man is imperfect, which sounds inifinitely more likely, then how is he fit to judge what perfection is? How can an imperfect being conceive of the criteria of perfection and be certain that he or she is correct? How can an imperfect Man conceive of and dictate to other imperfect beings, that which is perfection?

My opinion is that imperfect beings cannot conceive of a perfect one; all human creations must be imperfect. The conception of God and apprehension by humans is of an imperfect God. Thus, if God exists, imperfect Man cannot know God for what he really is and his religious constructs are thereby imperfect. This doesn't prove that a perfect God cannot exist, only that imperfect humans cannot conceive of a perfect creator by this logic. Thus my assertion of the unknowability of God in a state of perfection.

Answer 3

God created humans with free will and we chose to be bad. God is perfect and possible. Is a God perfect who forces you to do everthing as if you were a puppet? God gives freedom and this is used by us to make humans imperfect.

Answer 4

Good question, bad reasoning and assumptions. If something is perfect, why can't it do anything both perfect and imperfect? Does perfect imply no mistakes? Maybe things are not a mistake but part of a perfect plan, which is itself imperfect but reaching for perfection. Afterall, isn't this the idea of evolution, the brainchild of the atheist brain?

Answer 5

God Created good and evil so that means that there will be always two ways , white and black, good and evil, there are two ways: Perfection and imperfection, the big difference here is that we were created to choose one of these ways!!

God is perfect and he created everything perfect get over it!!
it was men who choose evil!!

you are not that clever after all!!

Answer 6

large comprehend-how and massive and huge skill is distinctive than omnipotence. i think of of the theists lose us on an identical time as they % for the "all, none, consistently and in no way" forms of powers. Is the pope infallible? in elementary words with the aid of definition. he's a human, makes errors, real? So if the errors isn't a mistake, because of the certainty he's the pope, then what value does the be unsleeping mistake guard? that's fairly a distinctive meaning that it would be if not for the very straightforward certainty that the pope is infallible. So, i think of of you will possibly be able to end that given the certainty we've in not information each and each ingredient approximately some thing in any admire, its darn on the brink of logically impossible to be all information, all-efficient, or whether distinctive superb powers have been assigned to God. Plus, isn't it quite clean how the assumption of a God replaced into conceived in our realm, over a volume of time, and why it became what it became, and for what purposes? seems very handy for the desires of human beings who might look for for to alter or a minimum of result the habit of others, for the two solid and undesirable purposes. Is there extra effective suited than all human beings comprehend for particular? seems relatively clean extra effective is going on than we've defined so a approaches with in basic terms our present day technologies. Does it shop on with that as a consequence there's a God? in elementary words indoors the minds of the believers......

Answer 7

Good question. Seriously it is, but you are not considering freewill. Once you throw freewill into the equation that changes everything.
It goes back the the old question, "Can God make a rock so big he can't move?"
Well, That can stir up many debates. I personally think yes. That does not take anything away from his power at all. It just says a lot about his character. That he is a just God and choosing not to contradict the freewill he gave to us.

Answer 8

Mankind never messed up this universe or the creation. The Creation is designed just the way it originally was. Have you ever read the Pslams?

Any teaching contrary to such is a man made teaching that has been going around for centuries but is contrary to the teaching of the Bible.

Answer 9

This is just playing with words when you already know the answer. However I think our concept of perfection is in error in the beginning.

Answer 10

"If something is perfect, nothing imperfect can come from it."
Not true.
The illustration of bad fruit not coming from a good tree, does not hold water.
It would seem your concept of "perfect" is a tad erroneous.
Why can't perfect people GIVE UP, relinquish, forsake their perfection?