English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

Is it possible to learn a Martial Art at home?
Benefits?
Disadvantages?

2007-03-22 16:27:45 · 6 answers · asked by Anonymous in Sports Martial Arts

6 answers

Unless, as mentioned, you're getting private lessons, I wouldn't go for it.
If you mean to learn by yourself, from books and videos and such, I'd say forget it.
You might get some benefit out of it, but more likely than not, it will hardly be worth the effort.
Go to a dojo.
A sensei can correct what you do wrong. Also, an experience teacher will understand what you do wrong and how you can hope to correct it. Also, you get to train with other students so that you refine your tactics in simulated confrontations and get a more realistic grasp of what your strong and weak points are. There is also that atmosphere to the dojo hat goes into the spirit of the martial arts and which you can't get at home. (It's not all technique - I can't really explain it).
But go to a dojo. Most definitely.
I can't think of a single reason why self-learning the martial arts would be better.

2007-03-22 17:13:35 · answer #1 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

Mas Oyama trained in the mountains for a couple years and evidently got pretty good considering he killed bulls and KO'd pro wrestlers in public exhibitions. I've seen a dude box a bear once but the freak show spectacle craze has died down now that the government has its tentacles in everything.

To answer your question, yes. However, if you tell anyone that the totality of your training in the martial arts was in your living room, you'll gain no credibility with others unless you prove your skills some other way. Like combat experience or tournament record of some sort. Bujinkan offers at-home study materials in their particular type of ninjutsu.

It is always better to have training under an expert. Then, once you are an expert, MAYBE you can train yourself.

2007-03-22 16:42:30 · answer #2 · answered by R. Lee 3 · 1 0

There had been no distance studying guides two decades in the past on the web. Thus the solutions right here should not have revel in doing so nor have they obvious the outcome of it. It's a brand new structure, and Traditional Martial Arts continuously frowns upon something new as a McDojo or MMA game fandom. That's simply how it's. So take that under consideration while you learn the solutions. One of the numerous matters you're going to listen here's that you just can not be taught on the web or via books since you want a instructor to "right" your actions. When you presently say that there is a strategy to have the trainer "right" your actions through video alternate on the net, they simply do not suppose it. Thus they do not difference their track and nonetheless say you can not be taught, although probably the most explanations they gave was once honestly knocked off or straight addressed. Point is, individuals would possibly not suppose it till they see it's mighty coaching. But they would possibly not be capable to peer it as mighty coaching till their instructor/teachers do them or in the event that they themselves do them. If they suppose it will on no account paintings, they are going to on no account check it out. Thus as common, people have to wait a couple of generations earlier than new ideas, such because the provider or firearm methods, turns into authorised in the ones circles that keep to culture. To reply your query, distance studying guides require extra independence and energy for your side. It calls for you to have or to broaden well visualization expertise. Basically monkey mimicking what's discovered, which people evidently do as good. As for the exceptional, that sorta is determined by whether or not the teachers realize what they're doing with this studying structure and what they decide on to coach. Gross motor systems are desired, even as best motor systems aren't desired. Martial arts consists most likely of best motor manage activities since of systems built through masters and handed directly to different pupils of the masters. But that is now not the quality strategy to be taught martial arts. If your teacher begins you off on tips on how to use martial arts concepts in gross motor activities, then the structure is a signal of well exceptional. I can not say something else considering that there aren't any main points provided right here approximately the artwork in query or who's educating it. P.S. I can not vouch for the Gracie Academy since I on no account took it, I have no idea anybody who has taken the web direction, and I have no idea something approximately how they do it to keep exceptional. People suppose what they see or what their revel in tells them is right. Online direction studying remains to be experimental at this level, peculiarly for bodily arts, however there are sufficient examples available in the market to end up the Proof of Concept of the speculation into software.

2016-09-05 12:42:33 · answer #3 · answered by wojtowicz 4 · 0 0

I practised karate in japan for 6 years, following a master of black belt 9th degree, then I moved back to Canada. Since my style of karate is kind of rare, there is no related dojo located in my city, so I have no choice but to practice by myself.
Pros, you can do it anytime
Cons, major major one, is that you may not know if yu are doing it the way it should, in a sense of executing a particular technique or a move in a kata.

2007-03-22 17:11:43 · answer #4 · answered by Guru c 2 · 0 0

I have made my Dojoe my home. Every night I wait behind to spy on my sensay performing Sanchin kata in the club shower in the hope that I too can one day master this incredible artform.

2007-03-22 17:00:17 · answer #5 · answered by Taekwondoist 1 · 1 0

yea get privat lessons if you do u will be a black belt in about 1-2 years because they spend all thar time with you.

2007-03-22 17:02:54 · answer #6 · answered by ? 3 · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers