Shia are not Muslims and thats final!?

Question

They have some 12 imams and different prophets, they do not follow the Islam Muhammed (pbuhs) did and they are all fakes!

Answer 1

Sunni Muslims in Majority follow the doctrine of Abu Hanifa Al No'man, which was a Sunni Student for Gaufar Al Sadeq the Shiite Imam.. No problem between us, we have to tolerate each other...

The differences between both parties are political and must be erased, regarding religion, Muhammad Al Ghazali the Imam of Sunna met Ayat Allah AlKhoumini and they both praised each other. Muhammad Al Ghazali stated that most tales about Shia are lies.. They don't have a falsified copy of the Quran and don't think Ali was a prophet.. they just have extremists like Sunnis have.. Most moderate Shia refuses this extremisim as well as Sunnis do...

We are all brothers and sisters.. We have one book, pray towards the same Mecca, and have one prophet...

The only difference that Shia have a Book of Hadiths called Al Kafi, which is an Alternative for Al Bukhari for Sunnis.. My opinion that if the two books shall split the nations they must be destroyed. I believe that Al Bukhari as well as Al Kafi Made terrible Mistakes in their books, both was not Arabic, barely speak arabic, And Collected Arabic Hadiths, I prefer Muslim and Abou Horayra as a source.

the Key is:
- cooperate in what we agree upon, and forgive each other for our differences.

Answer 2

hi there I just speak how I see things in general . I (my OPINION) CAN WE not just get alone no matter the religion or does it have to be in a disaster condition.Where everyone gives each other a caring hand. We are all children of god. We will answer to god towards our own actions on earth. question? would god have a hateful heart towards mankind. would he have gone to war to kill . would he let his neighbor die or even give his back to all . I THINK NOT we should be a be an example to others and try not to hate others but help even if it's a smile a thank you or a good morning. I know we as humans are weak our minds the things that are hiden inside. our expression in body talk . how can we judge for when the time to be judge will be by god who are we to say what or whom is fake . In times like ours today is when we must gather together in every language and pray no dirty looks cause one dresses different then the other no matter the color we must make a different so that others and our children can follow in our good will in footsteps. word to the wise.WE SHOULDN'T HESITATE TO GIVE GOD A STANDING OVATION.WE SHOULD ALWAYS BE ON OUR FEET ,LIFTING OUR HEARTS AND OUR VOICES TO OTHERS.IN CARING .


be well be safe god bless

Answer 3

shut up because there is no such thing as shia and sunni or whatever kind of muslims becase muhammad p.b.u.h. said that the muslims are united as one group or they are not muslims the only group that will enter jannah are the ones that follow the prophet and quran so dont say that you are this sect of islam because islam is pure and is not supposed to divided like this !!!!
and i dont consider myself as a shia or sunni or whatever but just as a muslim

Answer 4

Sorry man, i hate to tell you that just because they are a different sect does not make them any less Muslim.
Even though you may feel that way, have some tolerance.
A religeon without love is a life without light
Love thy neighbour
Peace

Answer 5

Uh huh. Just like Catholics aren't Christians. Load of crap. Get over it already. Catholics are Christians and Shia are Muslims. They just don't worship the way you want.

Answer 6

Do they use a different koran? Like this one?
http://cremesti.com/amalid/Islam/Yemeni_Ancient_Koranic_Texts.htm

Answer 7

no they arent fake there are many different forms of muslims who believe different things

Answer 8

Nice to know

Answer 9

i think we are all human, and should stop this ridiculous war. and to be TRUE men, we should put an end to this at at the discussion table.

Answer 10

Tolerance, Dude, tolerance. There's already far too much violence (I assume you speak as a Sunni?).