does it make me a bad parent if i dont spank my child?

Question

my mother n law makes it hard for me to crect my child she just over rules what i say and then it makes me so angery.i am afraid to spank cause she may turn me in ,she has before just cause she was mad at me for not lettin my daughter stay a week with her when i was seperate from her son.advice please

Answer 1

Spanking does not make you a bad parent and other forms of discipline do not make you a good parent. What makes you a good parent is communicating with your children, making threats that you are willing to follow through with, and always being consistent.

As for your mother in law, this is YOUR child. Period. Yes, many people claim that grandparents are an integral part of the children's lives and I'm sorry, that is not always the case. Unless she has LEGAL grandparent visitation she cannot do ANYTHING to expcet lie to child protective services or the police about you "beating" your child. Spanking your child, using normal force, is NOT illegal.

Leaving bruises or marks on your child is illegal, that is abuse. Neglecting your child is abuse. In order for her to have any legal leg to stand on she would have to take you to court to fight for grandparent visitation. You are an adult and she will continue, just like a child, to push your limits as far as she can. Put your foot down with her. Establish some boundaries and maintain them. Yes it may pi$$ her off beyond all comprehension, yes she may call CPS and lie to them and they may pay you a visit and yes, she may try and call the police on you. The truth of the matter is, it sounds like she has no respect for you at all so it is time for you to give her a reason to respect you and your rights to mother your own child.

Answer 2

you're not a bad parent if you don't spank, not all children need spankings.Some kids need them others don't. I see spankings as a last resort like when taking awa stuff,time outs etc dont work then yo spank .

and if that dosent work...military schoool? i here the have middle school military schools too lol

can you move away from your mil? or you can sit her down and say that this is my child or these are my children, not yours, i am the one who has to raise hem and take care of hem.

you gotta stand up fpr your rights :)

Answer 3

There are so many better ways to discipline besides spanking. I think it will make you a better parent. Is there any way you can distance yourself from mil? I would, in a calm setting, tell her that I was sorry if I ever offended her but she needs to back you up on the rules. Tell her that she is confusing and hurting her granddaughter. You may have to find a way to keep this woman out of your life altogether.

Answer 4

As long as there is good and consistant discipline, spanking is unnecessary. I find grounding the child (and holding to it) works well, as well as "time-outs" for younger children. You need to stand up to your mother-in-law because they are your children, not hers. The fact that you asked this question shows you are a caring parent who worries about her child. If you aren't seperated from the father, ask him to stand up for you. If he takes his mom's side over yours, counseling is in order.

Answer 5

Spanking is a seen punishment meted out by using applying a father or mother or dad or mum to impart a lesson with out inflicting harm. while a guy or woman hits a individual, this is many times accomplished out of the two meaness, self-risk-free practices (it is advantageous), or the selfish anger of now not getting what they choose. Spanking isn't sexual any further than giving slightly one a shower (which additionally incorporates touching). babies are spanked on the butt since the this might nicely be possible-unfastened problem without a bones close the exterior of the skin. I agree in telling little ones to stop first. that's jointly as slightly one does not stop, or breaks a needless to say understood rule that spanking will become needed. babies have been spanked for thus long as mothers and fathers have been having little ones. this is since the spanking has been shown to artwork, as against time-outs that have easiest become well-known in the ideal 30 years or so (except you think little ones are plenty larger behaved on the recent time, than that they have been lower back then). Even distinctive animals reminiscent of cats and domestic canines swat (or chew) their youthful. discomfort is a elementary coach, and this is the mothers and fathers' job to coach little ones nicely habit, practices, and attitudes. that's extensive-unfold to weigh the hazards vs the rewards of doing what we want. Spanking is assisting, better than distinctive punishments to beat the extensive-unfold urge to do incorrect. slightly one to start with might easiest %. to obey her mothers and fathers since the she is frightened of a spanking. over the years, obedience will become a habit. slightly one's habit is a reflection of ways reliable the mothers and fathers have taught. now and lower back mothers and fathers might desire to make confusing selections to ideal misbehavior, undesirable attitudes, and to sidestep long-term wrongdoing. babies are not granted the authority to spank. They an now not do away with distinctive persons's privileges the two. they are able to not floor mothers and fathers or stand them in the corner.

Answer 6

I don't think that good or bad parents are determined by whether or not you spank your children.

We don't spank our children, but I don't think we are better or worse than other parents because of it.