Can you be Jewish without Judaism?

Question

There are so many types of Jews (European, Asian, Middle Eastern etc...) from a vast assortment of cultures, ethnicities and races. Without Judaism what makes a Jew.

Answer 1

Being a Jew is a matter of matrilineal descent or proper conversion. "Being Jewish" has to do with following laws and tapping into a culture and heritage (though the more to the left you get on the spectrum of Judaism, the more focus is on heritage and the less on law and ritual). Judaism is the laws and the heritage -- you can be a Jew just by being born, but Neing Jewish might require a touch more.

Answer 2

Without Christianity what makes a person Christian? The question of "Does Jew refer to religion or nation?" is clear, Judaism is a religion. One of million and one details is that being Jewish (born or converted) can not be undone. Once you are a Jew you can choose not to follow your religion but you are already a member. This differs from Christianity, or at least other religions where your observance determines your status. Similarly observing Judaism doesn't make one a Jew. I like to compare this to being a journalist who was never hired by a newspaper company - you aren't part of the company even though you do the same work.

Answer 3

it's the soul and nature of the Jew... A Jewish person in its nature is more modest, more nice and good with other people (even though I am sure there are a lot of Jews that aren't)

Answer 4

Good god, where do people get the asinine questions? You are jewish if you follow judaism or at least say you do. It's like saying "can I be Christian if I deny Christ's existence and teachings".

PS this is the first time I've actually questioned the question - this really does seem like a stupid one.

Answer 5

My friend is a secular Jew. He keeps his home kosher so he can entertain his Orthodox family and friends and he attends services and holidays with his family because he honors and loves them, but he does not believe in any organized religion.
.