If God controls when people die, technically speaking, didn't Jesus commit suicide?

Question

Which would mean he did sin.

Considering that God knows everything, I'm pretty sure he knows when, where, and how you will die.

Answer 1

Technically, Jesus is a separate entity from God the father. He scurried away when he could, and petitioned for another way in the garden.

He was taken because he was accused. He did nothing wrong, but had no one to defend him.

God the father planned and executed his death and it pleased him to crush him.

So technically, he was killed by Your choice....
-God the father.
-San Hedrin
-Pilate.

Jesus had nothing to do with it. He was only obedient.

Answer 2

God doesn't CONTROL it. Knowing something is NOT dictating an outcome...

2Pe 3:8 Dear friends, here is one thing you must not forget. With the Lord a day is like a thousand years. And a thousand years are like a day. 9 The Lord is not slow to keep his promise. He is not slow in the way some people understand it. He is patient with you. He doesn’t want anyone to be destroyed. Instead, he wants all people to turn away from their sins... God WANTS everyone saved. IF he controlled events, that is what would happen.

Answer 3

I don't feel that I can honestly answer this question to the degree that I feel I need to. That I I suggest you call a local parish or diocese and see if the priest or bishop there can answer your question, or if he can suggest a book that will explain it. Bishop's are typically well versed in theology and could probibly explain this well, but you will need to make some phone calls. This is a good question, but I don't think I can answer this question.

Here is my best attempt at answering your question.
Jesus was offered himself as the final sin offering for humanity. When Jesus died he didn't die a divine death, only his human form died (remember he was fully human and fully divine). Jesus was also murdered by the order and actions of others. Jesus also had to die, because without the perfect offering of God's son as atonment for the sins of humanity we could never enter heaven. Whenever somone sinned in the old testament they typically offered up some form of sacrifice, typically something had to die in reperation for sin.

It was also a neccessary part of God's plan for revealing himself fully to man. Adam's fall was neccessary for Christ to be needed and helped God reveal himself to man better than he did to Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Elijah(possibly the first human in heaven) and the other prophets did.

Answer 4

No...he didn't tell the people to kill him. Same thing goes for a person who loves someone enough to take there place in dying. If someone comes up to you and another person and says that person must die unless you die in their place for them. It is not a suicide, you do not want to die but you did it out of love for the other person. Jesus actually asked God to take away to "cup" but He was still willing to do it if he must. In that case, you and me were the people subjected to death. if you accept Jesus as your savior than you will be pardoned and will live forever in heaven.

Answer 5

Jesus didnt committ suicide. We dont attribute soldiers on the battlefield that give their lives for the people in the unit suiciders, we consider them heros. Likewise, Jesus gave his life so that we may find salvation. A heroic death serves a greater purpose. Suicide serves no purpose at all.

And no, God typically does not choose when we die. (unless we fall under his wrath)

Answer 6

It is not a sin to lay down your life for your brothers. It is the greatestlove there is. When Jesus gave his life he gave it for everyone that has ever existed and for the people that have yet to be born and for the people living now such as you and I. So he may have commited suicide depending on how you would define it, but he did not sin.

Answer 7

No, God told Him to allow himself to be captured for our sake. Therefore, God was in control. Jesus did not decide to kill himself. If God did not say to do this, He would have continued living.

The word sin means without. The biblical use of the word sin is referring to whatever we do "without" God. So it was not a sin.


(Your awesome, David!!!! :o] )

Answer 8

god doesnt exactly control every thing, see its mostly the fact that he cant help everyone so he doesnt really try to. he knows everything that happens before it happens. we are all of our own free will. besides that jesus was a sacrifice.he was without sin so he was the perfect sacrifice. this is why he was called the lamb of god. so it was really gods will that he died not suicide

Answer 9

God doesn't control when people die, when other people usurp God's authority and commit murder. That is precisely why murder is wrong! Because it thwarts God's eternal plan for a given person, including the time of their death.
.

Answer 10

you do not could examine the "gospel of Judas" to entice close that Jesus deliver Judas to betray him. The gospels in the hot testomony let us know that Jesus instructed Judas to flow and do right now what he had to do. yet that replaced into no longer an endorsement of Judas movements, nor a command to do it, purely an acknowledgement that he already knew what Judas replaced into making plans. formerly Judas left, Jesus warned his disciples that one in all them replaced into about to betray him. So it replaced into no longer something Jesus requested, yet somewhat a betrayal. His lack of life replaced into no longer a suicide, yet a sacrifice. reminiscent of a soldier who jumps on a grenade to save different round him, or a policeman who places himself between a criminal and innocence people. there's a huge enormous difference between those sorts of acts and a suicide. question: If Judas hung himself interior minutes of his betrayal of Jesus, or perhaps as on the crucifixion replaced into nonetheless occurring, how ought to he have written a "gospel" which tells about the shape? He replaced into useless formerly it occurred. The "Gospel of Judas" is a pretend, written a minimum of two hundred to three hundred years after the activities with assistance from an unknown author as a artwork of fiction. it will be treated as such.