Why Muhammad didn't abolish the Arab pagan culture (jahiliyah period) marrying very young girl?

Question

instead he adapt to that culture by marriying Aisyah at the age of 6 and consumate her at the age of 9. If an old man at the age of 50++ want to married Muhammad daughter (Fatimah Zahrah) at the age of 6 and consumate her at the age of 9 would Muhammad allowed it. What would he say or advice to that old man. As a prophet he should oppose those backwards practice. This thing still happen in some Muslim country for example in Pakistan, Afganistan, Iran and etc where the backward tribe custom still marrying this young girl and treat the girl as a comodity or property .

Answer 1

Centuries ago things were different. Men and women were not as educated, knowledgeable as now. The science and technology has not advanced. The living and environment conditions were different. Certain practices developed on the basis of contemporary circumstances and needs. It is not really meaningful to judge what was being practiced long tome ago from today's perspective. What was the culture of the communism in erstwhile USSR is not relevant today but at that time this culture was the product of certain periods of oppression and rebellion against such oppression.

Answer 2

Aisha reached puberty and in Islam when a girl has her first menses she is no longer a child. She is a woman and is able to get married and produce children for her husband. It was a very common practice back then. Plus no one has any idea when Aisha married Muhammad(PBUH*). Also Aisha participated in politics and was very mature for her age. She is an example to all women. Also the practice of marrying 4 year old girls to 20 something year old men is strictly forbidden, has nothing to do with Islam, and is cultural. Marriage is not supposed to be arranged. A woman has the right to choose her own husband. The parents can talk about it but in the end she decides who she wants to marry.

Answer 3

there is in basic terms one occasion of older guy with youthful girls people who i hit upon "perfect" in any stretch of the mind's eye. while i became in college MANY moons in the past, I took some anthropology training. in one in each of them, I discovered some small tribe in South usa (i think it incredibly is the place they have been yet do no longer quote me). in this tribe, the ordinary practice became that the father may be the 1st guy to have family members together with his daughter. of their tribe and subculture, the father became seen the guy who enjoyed and respected and cared for his daughter the main so it became his fantastic duty to accomplish this act. In that tribe, if yet another guy became to do this to a girl he became solid out or punished critically. This became a uncommon occurance nevertheless and all respected and held to this. i will see the way it incredibly is discovered offensive in our cutting-side religoius society, and as an Atheist Agnostic Satanic Vampire I confess to having a knee jerk "ewwwwwwwwwwww" reaction to it to boot consistent with how i became raised and socialized. yet...I understand that there do exist different cultures and tribes and communities with different traditions and historial practices. Now, the version between the Morman occasion and the single I only gave is this: a million. Mormans stay and have existed in a subculture and society that would not condone this habit. 2. Mormans have not got any biblical or non secular foundation to act exterior that ordinary cultural norm or the certainly regulations against it. 3. Mormans specifically do no longer condone this habit and that is not any longer seen a norm. 4. This tribe has existed like this for as long as they have existed and that subculture upholds and condones the habit. 5. There are no longer any regulations against what that tribe does the place and while that tribe does it. 6. This tribe isn't a subset or subgroup of a greater physically powerful team that would not condone this habit. it incredibly is condoned around the completed community so it incredibly is seen the norm. it incredibly is my hassle-free answer. you're able to desire to verify the context and the society and the regulations of the place the habit is happening. it is not a black and white answer.

Answer 4

not everything is about sex. after prophet Muhamma death, this woman called Aishah has recorded almost 25% of his words and teaching. there must be someone who was very close to the prophet Muhammad to stay for the next generation. Muhammad was a shy man, he couldn't answer all women questions, so he used to give them to Aisha. this woman has played very important role to carry this religion to the next generation after prophet Muhammad.

Answer 5

When prohibit Muhammad came to invite people (jahiliyah period) to Islam they have no principles (they was kill girls when they born), when he came he learn people Islam principles and forbid the bad behavior ( forbid slaves , drunk ) .
His married with easha was lesson for people how to treat women .
and every matter in our live have rules to deal with it , Islam correct this behavior , and married should be after be adult ( about 15 ) with condition of a prove both of Equation man and women.
about punish you cant punish people have no rules
that's like new manager punish employee on something in his mind!!!!!!!!
Hope that I explain your question

Answer 6

Power corrupts and Abosolute Power corrupts Absolutely.

He WAS the main man, you know.

Answer 7

it is authenic, muhammad s.a.w. did marry 'aaishah r.a. at 6 & consumate with her at 9, b/c she had her 1st. period at 9. yes 'ali r.a. his cousion & brother in law married ihs daughter faatimah at 12. in authenic islaam, not tribal or culture. a woman CANNOT be forced to marry.

Answer 8

And that, my Friend, proves that Muhammad wasn't talking to God, or any angel of His.

Answer 9

Because its not wrong to marry a girl who reaches puberty.

Answer 10

MUHAMMAD DIDN'T MARRY A YOUNG 6 YEAR OLD... HIS FIRST WIFE'S NAME WAS KAHDIJAH