Did the Prophet Muhammad really had sex with a 9yr old?

Question

Or did he rape her? This is not a hate question, it is about facts.

Answer 1

This question was asked zillion times b4, and unfortuantly ive nt read a single answer that captured the truth, so i hope ppl find a bottom line in my answer, but 1st let me thank u for the way u asked ur question, i know its not out of hatred.
Yes, the prophet married Aisha when she was nine yrs old.
1-The scientific fact is women in hot countries reach their puberty at a very early age, sometimes at 7 and 8, (i have a friend who had her period at 8 and half) unlike women in cold regions like russia where they usually start having their period at 15 or 16 yrs old!
2-it is still very common in modern days that women get married at 8 and 9 in some arabian and asian countries.
3- you would -mistakenly- categorise them as girls, but they are full grown women, and they practice a great deal of responsibilities and its all because of the different upringing (like who would imagine a 6 year old boy engagge in a war, and fight bravely as u see the palestenian kids on Tv), they grow up fast due to the social enviroment they are living in!!
4- at the time of the prophet, it was very very natural for women to marry at youn age, Aisha wasnt the only one, actually it was a burden on the family if a girl hits 13 and still not married, that was even normal among jews!
5-Aisha was already engagged to another man b4 the prophet proposed, and the family of that man broke the engaggement cuz they didnt want their son to marry a muslim! (it wasnt yet forbidden for muslim women to marry non muslims), and u know if she had married that guy, no1 would have ever said anything?!!
6- yes she was still playing with her doll, but hey all women even at 30 would be given a teddy bear as a present, and its a gift we women still love and play with, im 27 and i still have dolls!
7-Aisha was engagged to the prophet when she was 7, but she wasnt READY for marriage yet, thats y they waited 2 more yrs, and when she was ready her mother made a fuss and kept urging her husband to tell the prophet!
8- my grandmother married at 8, and had 13 children (im from egypt lol)
I hope now u realise that it was THE common natural normal thing, and Aisha wasnt a little kid, she was a fully grown responsible woman ready for marriage.

Answer 2

This is a good one for the *** PRAYNOGRAPHER***to sink his pearly whites into.There are xristian historians that will tell you that when the so called god , the all mighty, and all knowing,and being had an immaculate ejaculation into the virgin Mary when she was but a teen. That means it could of been anywhere from 13 to 18 years . Some say it was the younger.So it looks like to the ***PRAYNOGRAPHER***that all you gods and mullahs , and aloha's, what ever these perverts were called they,were all doing it. Maybe it was because people didn't live to long in those days, and women came into child bearing years much sooner in those days.As you can see everyone wants to pass judgment on things they have absolutely no knowledge of , or anyway of knowing what they speak of. Sounds like Xristianity to me.The ***PRAYNOGRAPHER***has spoken.

Answer 3

well since Prophet Mohammad is a real redeemer for the whole humanity and this status can only be given to some one who is thourogly pious and pure therefore believe it or not he can not commit such sin he is the most pious man in the universe however to tell you the real matter id like to tell you that as people denies about the completeness of Islam.it gives you a complete code of living because all it rules and regulations have been defined in the light of human nature.
Prophet Mohammad too is human and he married to a nine years old girl who was the gift of God to him.her name was Ayesha and she is the role model for other women.the reason behind her age was that she had to be taught the lessons for the better and appropriate life style of a woman and this age is suitable for inculcating the ideas so that they can be well understood and acted upon and the most important after having full grip preach that to other.that 9 yr old girl has a very respectable place in Muslims she she is also renowned for her knowledge and character
Hazrat Ayesha (RAa), the first woman leader of Islam was a teacher of men and women. In turn her students, men and women, taught others how to govern, how to organise Muslim communities, and how to arrange Muslim family and social life. The great scholars of hadith got their learning from Ayesha. The Noble Prophet bore witness to Hazrat Ayesha’s intellect, understanding, rational approach to life. At a time of crisis she had no hesitation in taking over command of the Islamic army and directing it in the field of battle. In peace time she gave religious rulings and helped the most learned of the Companions of the Prophet differentiate between the right and the wrong. All the Fiqh and Laws of Islam are related to Hazrat Ayesha. It is about time that Muslims started remembering Hazrat Ayesha.

Answer 4

we don't have any record of his private life that, at what age he had sex with her. So, can't comment.
Ayesha lived a normal life even after the Death of Prophet and took active role in muslim affairs. So, its clear that nothing has happened with her which was inhuman or not acceptable psycologocally or sociologically

Answer 5

I'm afraid the answer is yes. But is it rape? I don't think there is evidence to say so. In any case, it would have been easy for a 50 year old man to sweet talk a 9 year old girl into engaging in a sexual act.

Answer 6

He really married her BUT he didn't do any relation with her untill she was adult enough

By the way, there r different opinions about her age, some people says that she was 13 when he married her, other say that she was 16

BUT the real fact that Muhammed (PBUH) didn't do any relation with her untill she was adult enough

Answer 7

she was 6 when they married. she was nine and still immature playing with dolls at the age when they had sex. What a perv!
he divorced some of his wives too. He didnt keep his marriage promises! http://www.muslimhope.com/WhyDidMohammedGetSoManyWives.htm#_Toc137729542
makes you wonder how old are the 72 virgins in paradise... 9 yr old kids?

Answer 8

No, this is misstated by muslim-hating scum of the earth, trying to show the profit in an evil light.

Answer 9

just because your society called those people who have sex with a nine y.o a pervert? you did judge the act as wrong?

our ideas of right and wrong will always be that "ideas", nothing else. they are not the absolute right and wrong. we just decided as a society, that it is wrong. but was it wrong before we decide to call it wrong? hell no!

Answer 10

they were not married until she was about 17.