is crime ever justified?

Question

in what kind of situation a cime could be justified

Answer 1

Not often is it justified.....I think that the only time it can be is if you were defending yourself.....~!

Answer 2

There's the law, there's life on the street, and then there's geopolitics.

I read all those law abiding and otherwise citizen's responses above mine.

I'd say, ponder this:

Is it correct for: The CIA was able to hire mercenaries in a covert operation, operating inside pakistan, to locate, track, and ultimately assassinate Osama bin Laden.

Would it be correct to: Use an antitank missile to blow up an apartment in New York, where known terrorrists were trying to use a cell phone to call a remote triggerring device on a nuclear weapon, somewhere in manhattan.

What if innocent people were in the apartments around that one, but the powers that be had one minute to decide to shoot?

How about using torture or abusive methods to interrogate a child molester / rapist who has buried their victim alive?

Some guy has just murdered his wife, and one of his children.
His last child is in his house, and he's got a remote switch rigged to a bomb in his hand. He tells police that it is set up so that if he dies, it goes off. He then starts shooting at police with a high powered rifle.

Some journalist has gotten top secret government files from (pick a country). A major scandal, involving murder for hire, coverups, the whole bit. If released it will hang the president, and his cabinet, and throw the country into chaos for a year or more, where many innocent people will be killed in riots as a result. Should it be released? What if this country has declared it will wipe yours from the face of the map?

That's how I see it. Pick a side, and pick your allies most carefully. People eating hamburgers is a crime.. to the cows.

But what about when it becomes not people vs. cows, but people vs. people?

Answer 3

In a very very extreme situation a crime where no one is getting hurt, a life is in danger and you are willing to cover any property damage might be justified.

One situation would be if you were lost, someone was severely and possibly life threateningly injured and you come across an empty house, I could maybe see entering and calling emergency aid, but that would be an extreme and rare circumstance.

Answer 4

Yes. It is justified to steal when you are stealing food to eat because you cannot otherwise feed yourself. It is ok to kill when faced with your own mortality and the choice is to kill or be killed. Their are many more times when the crime is justified, but even more times when it is not. We must be very careful not to label all criminals unjustified just as we must be very careful not to justify crime just for the sake of justifying it.

Answer 5

Stealing food to survive. That is a justified crime....it should not be punished but instead help should be offered to the offender to prevent it.

Answer 6

depends.

crime yes.

self defense no

if gun attacker caught me, I may distract the attacker before I would crack his balls and YELL "FIRE"

because everyone is easy to get attention quickly if a person yells "fire" then everyone will ask where is fire.

if victim yells "help" because mostly people often ignore this word as people think victim is playing around "help" this is why many people don't want to waste the time

hope this helps

Answer 7

there is the regulation, there is existence on the line, and then there is geopolitics. I learn all those regulation abiding and in any distinctive case citizen's responses above mine. i might say, evaluate this: Is it astounding for: The CIA develop in case you prefer to hire mercenaries in a covert operation, working indoors pakistan, to locate, music, and finally assassinate Osama bin weighted down. might it extremely is astounding to: Use an antitank missile to explode an condominium in long island, the area universal terrorrists have been attempting to maintain on with a cellular telephone to call a miles off triggerring device on a nuclear weapon, someplace in massive apple. What if probability loose people have been indoors the residences around that one, inspite of the incontrovertible fact that the powers that be had one minute to come to a decision to shoot? How approximately making use of torture or abusive the spectacular thank you to interrogate a toddler molester / rapist who has buried their sufferer alive? some guy has basically murdered his companion, and one in each and every of his toddlers. His very final toddler is in his abode, and he's have been given a miles off substitute rigged to a bomb in his hand. He tells police that it is desperate up so as that if he dies, it is going off. He then starts off off taking pictures at police with a severe powered rifle. some journalist has gotten appropriate secret government archives from (%. a us of a). a important scandal, with regards to homicide for hire, coverups, the entire bit. If released it extremely is going to charm to close the president, and his cabinet, and throw the rustic into chaos for a 12 months or extra, the area many probability loose people could be killed in riots subsequently. might desire to it extremely is released? What if this us of a has declared it extremely is going to wipe yours from the face of the map? it extremely is how I see it. %. a element, and %. your allies optimum carefully. people eating hamburgers is against the regulation.. to the cows. yet what approximately on a similar time because it extremely is going to become no longer people vs. cows, yet people vs. people?

Answer 8

Killing a rapist in self defense; smoking cannabis; shooting an armed intruder on your property at night.

I <3 living @ TX

Answer 9

No, unless if was in self defense, or for survival.

Answer 10

if some person assaulted ,sexually abused or murdered my child , then i would pop one in em - justified!