Judas: Hanged himself OR Fell headlong,burst open in the middle and all his entrails fell out?

Question

I know the Bible does not contradict itself, so I'd like to know your thoughts on this. Found in Matt. 27:5 and Acts 1:18 concerning Jesus' betrayer.

Answer 1

Reasoning to dispel the contradiction myth re:the "two" accounts of Judas' death is this...Matthew doesn't necessarily explain how Judas died; he does say Judas "hanged himself", but he didn't specifically say Judas died in the hanging incident. However, Acts seems to show us his graphic demise. Therefore, there is no contradiction between Matthew and Acts re: Judas' `death'.

We do know from Matthew that he did hang himself and Acts probably records his death. It is possible and plausible that he fell from the hanging and hit some rocks, thereby bursting open

Answer 2

Matthew is talking about the events that took place after Judas betrayed Jesus.

Peter is explaining how the prophesy fits with Judas' death. The Jews of the time, like Christians, did not believe anyone who committed suicide should be given proper burial. They would bury them in the ground. Instead of them being wrapped with spices until the soft tissue was gone them putting the bones in their special box, suicides were left to decompose in the ground. For the Jew that constitutes "falling to the ground." If you've ever seen an body in that state you'll easily understand the bursting open.

It's all about learning the cultural facts of the people your reading about.

Answer 3

Judas hanged himself as in Matthew, and the limb broke from his weight hurling him to the ground, and upon impact on the hard ground his midsection burst open, and his entrails fell out as in Acts.

Answer 4

The account of Matthew provides the account from Judas' very own mouth to the supervisor clergymen. The reader sees that Judas is sorry for his sin, needs not extra section in it, yet that he nevertheless falls into melancholy in putting himself. The Matthean account emphasizes that repentance isn't in straight forward terms recognizing your sin and scuffling with it, yet in addition in turning to God, as Peter did after denying Christ. The account of Acts emphasizes extra the punishment that comes from wickedness, and the real nature of Judas' soul--rotten like spewed intestines, which Judas grew to become into no longer able to parent. in case you desire a literal, historic clarification, you ought to element out that, because of the fact the money given Judas grew to become into "blood money," the clergymen weren't waiting to place it back interior the Temple treasury whether Judas tried to return it. i've got recently study that Judas probable did no longer cling himself from a tree, as readers from the West might immediately assume in line with a cultural expertise of the word "hanged." there have been no longer many trees sufficiently vast or stable sufficient for the point, and that's lots extra in all probability that Judas "hanged" himself by making use of leaping from a intense place onto a pointy merchandise, thereby actually "putting" himself and loosing his intestines.

Answer 5

It's not an 'either-or' issue.
Judas hung himself,his body fell down,and his body split open when he fell,due to his weight on the tree.They are two different perspectives on the same event.

Answer 6

He tied a rope around his neck and hanged himself. At some point the rope or limb broke causing him to fall, the impact of which caused his mid section to burst open spilling his intestines.

Answer 7

Both are true just one preceded the other. Investigate what happens when a corpse hangs in the hot sun for a long time.

Answer 8

both, he hanged himself and his guts burst out of his rotting corpse.( I assume he wasn't found for awhile.)

Answer 9

Um, because either the bible really does contridict itself or Judas died two seperate deaths at two different times. A feat never copied.

Answer 10

I think he hanged himself.....it would be more realistic.