Is there anything that a Japanese katana blade is incapable of slicing through if so what?

Answer 1

Before I state my opinion, based on physics, metallurgy and common sense, let me make an analogy.

There is a difference between hard brittle.

A diamond is the hardest substance on the hardness scale - it can stratch anything else. However, scratching - the hardness test - is a shearing motion rather than a lateral striking motion.

If you take a common brick - you know, like to build a house and smash it down on a diamond, the diamond can shatter. This is because the brittle test is about lateral striking - the brick can and does win even though the diamond is harder and would thus scratch the brick.

That said, a katana, when talking about the equivalent 'hardness' won't go through anything. Other metals may not break the katana, but they would certainly halt it being able to cut - feudal japanese armor, against common wisdom had metal bands and plates in it - it wasn't all bamboo.

Also, resisteing the cutting motion of a blade is different from twisting or paralel striking to the cutting motion of a blade. The katana was very tough when it comes to durability as far as motion against the cutting direction of the blade. However, a jitte could easily snap a blade when used paralel to the length of the blade - in that direction the blade is brittle.

If a sword were to cut into a tree, it would not break, but if you start moving the blade from side to side, the blade would snap. Either way, the tree would not be cut through - the blade is like the brick. It can't 'scratch' the katana blade, but it can 'shatter' the katana blade.

The katana blade, was sharp and tough, but it was not immune to damage.

Things a katana would not cut through:

Brick
Metal
Wood of sufficient thickness (not that thick by the way)

Furthermore, there are more variables at play than the sharpness of the blade.

Examples: the force of the strike and the toughness of the target (a thin piece of wood might break due to the force of the blow but not the cutting edge of the blade for instance). The same board, cut along a length rather than the face would lodge the blade in the board and if twisted would then break the blade.

I saw a video of a 50 cal machine gun firing at the blade edge of a katana. The katana kept cutting the bullets in half. Amazing, yes, but remember to account for the fact that the bullets are concentrating alot more force in their motion against the blade than a katana strike would concentrate force with a strike of any kind. This is a limit of the wielder rather than the blade itself. On the other hand, the bullets are so heated along their trajectory that they can be treated as if they are a fluid so at that speed and energy, its not as hard for a sharp blade to cut a bullet in half as it might seem - a good kitchen knife might do the same.

Does this mean the katana would break? No. Does this mean the katana isn't sharp? No. Does this mean the katana isn't all it was cracked up to be? No. Does this mean that even though the blade as the unstoppable cutting tool isn't true that the katana isn't the best historically speaking cutting tool known to man? No. Does the mythology behind the katana mean that there is a misunderstanding of the physics of how a blade in general works? Yes.

Answer 2

lots of things.

Katanas- all swords, were designed to cut flesh.

Actually katanas more than others because they have a "harder" edge (holds an edge better), makes them more brittle- the edge. even though differential hardening is used for a katana- the edge is what is striking.

Cutting through brick, steel or even wood can damage a katana's edge. One of the reasons why they avoided blade on blade (not edge on edge- that was REALLY bad, I mean using the blade to guard) contact if possible.

The notion that a katana can cut through steel of another sword, is a myth. any such action is more the weakness in the other blade (weakness of construction or heavy wear and poor upkeep, plus luck) than the stregth of the katana.

if a katana came edge on with steel armor, it would likely chip, not cut through it- the only way it would even be able to cut these substances is if the substance was held fast.

Swords were designed to cut through flesh. They were not the optimal weapon for fighting against armored opponents. Spears, maces, warhammers and mostly bows were the primary weapons of the battlefield against armor.

Answer 3

yeah, there are many thing that katana is incapable slicing through. For example, lower quality katana even will surely damaged if parry with other katana. In fact, most katana will be unusable after 2-3 batlles.

Answer 4

japanese katana blade incapable slicing

Answer 5

In all reality just like any other type of blade it could be broken or damage. It is very common actually to even break a katana while cutting straw matts due to improper technique. Very dangerous in fact. Just like other blades its sharp edge would eventually dull and nedded to be taken to a sharpener and polisher.

Answer 6

In the event that you need to discover pleasant thoughts for woodworking I can propose you to check here http://woodworking.toptips.org

It's perfect in the event that you are simply starting out or in case you're a prepared carpenter.
It has thousands and thousands of woodworking arrangements and you have a CAD/DWG software to view and alter the arrangements. You have regulated instructions with photographs and excellent blueprints and schematics. On the off chance that you are a beginner this is the simplest approach to start your woodworking projects, and on the off chance that you already have experience you can at any rate discover a ton of interesting thoughts!

Answer 7

If you are planning to start on your woodworking project, this isn't something you should use, it's something that you would be insane not to. Go here https://tr.im/UyBoi
Truth is, I've been a carpenter for almost 36 years, and I haven't found anything like this for less than 10's of thousands of dollars.

Answer 8

It's incapable of slicing through American law.

Answer 9

1

Answer 10

Wolverine's bones, laced with indestructible adamantium, have been proven on several occasions to stop a sharp katana.