Amazing Grace was first written in Scotland as "O Miorbhail Gràis." It was brought to America, where Rev. John Newton, an 18th century minister, set English words to the tune. Precious Lord was written much more recently, in 1932 by Thomas Dorsey.
The music of Precious Lord differs with that of Amazing Grace by being somewhat flowier and more rock-and-rolly in rhythm, and Dorsey put some minor chords at the ends of certain phrases for spice. But still, I think I can hear Amazing Grace underneath Precious Lord, as if Dorsey had started with the older song and changed the notes a bit.
2007-03-11
01:23:26
·
7 answers
·
asked by
Anonymous
in
Society & Culture
➔ Religion & Spirituality
An instrumental rendition of Amazing Grace sounds best, I think, with a flute lead and violin accompaniment, as "A Quiet Knowing" performed it for their CD "Canticles for the Heart."
http://www.arkmusic.com/NewFiles/quietknow.html
On the other hand, I think that Precious Lord would be best performed by an oboe duet with tympani percussion.
2007-03-11
04:34:18 ·
update #1