who is wrong???

Question

someone told me something and they told me not to tell anyone. Now, one of my other friends is mad because i wont tell her what it is. I am not planning on tellin ganyone, but i think that my friend is being really imature about not talking to me. Do you think i should tell her or what??? what should i do???

please help!
- Katie

Answer 1

She is wrong. Don't talk.
You are the better friend. Stay that way and you will go far.

Answer 2

Don't tell her. You can point out that she should be glad you won't tell her because it means you won't blab any of her secrets to anyone either. If she won't talk to you over something that's non of her business, she's not a real friend anyway.

Answer 3

Explain to her that you have sworn to secrecy and that your honor is important to you. If she still refuses to understand, then there is nothing more you can do. In time, she will come to understand that without honor people are no better than animals.

Answer 4

Tell her something else that she would think it is. And then tell her it wasnt a big deal and thats why you didnt wanna tell her.

Answer 5

If your friend is mad because you won't betray a confidence, she is not much of a friend and probably can't be trusted.

Answer 6

If the person told you not to tell anyone, then they expect you not to tell ANYONE! Not even your mother.

Answer 7

don't tell, and she is very immature, just ask her how would she like it if she told you something and didn't want you to tell

Answer 8

I think you should tell me, first!!