Two Questions about sharia law for Muslim/ Muslim scholars?

Question

Given that sharia law states that it is acceptable for a master to sleep with his slave women wether they will it or no and this is not an offence against Allah, would not a married master who slept with his slaves be guilty of adultery. Secondly does the same apply to a mistress who sleeps with her male slaves or would she be considered a harlot to be punished? If the latter does this not seem at the very least a double standard.

Answer 1

as per usual some idiot ALWAYS has to bring Christianity into any argument.

when will people realise that just cause your not muslim does not make you a Christian.

you also don't have to be christian to hate islam.

Answer 2

Exodus 21:2
When you purchase a Hebrew slave, his service will last for six years. In the seventh year he will leave a free man. If his master gives him a wife and she bears him sons or daughters, the wife and children will belong to the master, and he will depart alone. But if the slave says to you, "I do not want to leave you," because he loves you and your family, and is well off with you, then you must take an awl and drive it through the slave's ear and into the door. He will be your servant forever. If a man sells his daughter as a slave she will not leave as male slaves do. f she does not please her master who intended her for himself he must let her be bought back. If someone beats his slave and the slave dies at his hands he shall certainly be avenged. But should the slave survive for one day or two he will pay no penalty because the slave is his owner's property.


Yes... Christianity makes much more sense.

Answer 3

Next time, provide the actual texts that support your assertion.

The Holy Qur'an is the Basis for ALL Islamic Law, and there is nothing in the Holy Qur'an that says a "master" can go into his slave women "whether they will it or not".

Baseless and unsupported accusations are characteristic of a lesser position.

RM

Answer 4

The sharia law is not Islamic law. Many of the laws were not taken from the Quran. Rather, it is a man made law that it is outdated. Check out these two websites.

Answer 5

thanks for asking question decently. particularly it truly is a wonder for me that a western man or woman can ask question about Islam is this kind of excellent way. you've consumer-friendly important stated as freedom for human beings, the body of ideas of stay and enable others stay. at the starting up, in jap international locations, which will comprise even non-muslim international locations like India, the social values are diverse. For us icons of society and faith are fairly significant and we jointly are too sentimental about them. As freedom is more suitable significant to you which ones could no longer be sacrified at any fee, honour of recognize personalities are even more suitable significant to us. we do not have any issue discussing logically and decently about all individuals, yet expression of insult is something we gained't tolerate. ignore about Prophets, we gained't take someone actual in the journey that they talk undesirable about our father and mom. So, you are able to imagine that your freedom is more suitable, yet by technique of an identical concept we've freedom to imagine that honour of our Prophet is more suitable significant then the freedom of that instructor. BTW, the question even if she truly meant to disrespect Prophet Mohammed PBUH, is altogether diverse. What I particularly have reported above is the reason in the back of our reaction. i do no longer imagine that she meant to precise any dishonour to Prophet. Her mistake became that even after being in Sudan, she did study about how muslims feels about their Prophet. warmth regards.

Answer 6

no. Only Allah can have sex with the slave girl. The master gets the left-overs

Answer 7

How dare you insinuate Koranic error or Hypocrasy. Do you not know that is why Muslims hate the west, you are allways pointing out inconsistancy and want us to think objectively.
I must go now Allah needs me to blow myself and kill innocent people up cause he can not do it himself.

Answer 8

I am not scholars but I will try to answer you even though Allah know best.
1. well , let me tell something before i answer you , some of the master ask their slave women to go to make adultery to bring money for them if they refuse they will beat them . Islam prevent that and said those women are not sinned .
Again . a lot of people thinks when Islam allow men to marry more than one wife why did not Islam allow women to marry more than one husband?
The answer is easy if this woman have baby then whose is the father of this baby
Islam did not allow adultery but since Allah create son of Adams weak and some of them have no money to get married Allah allow them to have sex with their slaves women because if she have son he will be the father,but in case of adultery no one no his father.
Even though it is one of our kids rights to choose a free women.
And Islam ask us to make our slaves free because we are all slaves ,no one is better than other.
Islam shows the way of righteousness which is steep and difficult and also points out the easy and alluring path of vice and disbelief.

Allah has given us not only the faculties implied in the eyes, the tongue and the lips, but also given us the judgement to distinguish between good and evil so as to choose the right way by following the thoroughly purified teachers and guides He has appointed (see Ahzab: 33). Dahr: 3, Shams: 8; verse 10 of this surah assert that man has been given the faculty of reason to distinguish between good and evil, right and wrong, so that he may identify the true teachers and guides sent by Allah and follow the path shown by them.

To walk on the steep and difficult path of righteousness man has to tame, control and discipline his nafs ammarah (see commentary of Fajr: 27 to 30; Yusuf: 53 and Qiyamah: 2).

The difficult path of virtue is described as the unselfish service in the cause of Allah. Freeing the bondmen, feeding the hungry orphans and looking after the poor down in the dust are some of the virtues mentioned in verses 13 to 16. To practice such virtues man must have patience which implies self-restraint and constant reliance upon Allah, along with compassion and kindness towards fellow beings; and those who walk on the steep path of righteousness are known as the people of the right hand (see Waqi-ah: 27 to 40). These are the people who achieve salvation.

The people of the left hand (see Waqi-ah: 41 to 56
Nay! I swear by this city.
[Shakir 90:2] And you shall be made free from obligation in this city--
[Shakir 90:3] And the begetter and whom he begot.
[Shakir 90:4] Certainly We have created man to be in distress.
[Shakir 90:5] Does he think that no one has power over him?
[Shakir 90:6] He shall say: I have wasted much wealth.
[Shakir 90:7] Does he think that no one sees him?
[Shakir 90:8] Have We not given him two eyes,
[Shakir 90:9] And a tongue and two lips,
[Shakir 90:10] And pointed out to him the two conspicuous ways?
[Shakir 90:11] But he would not attempt the uphill road,
[Shakir 90:12] And what will make you comprehend what the uphill road is?
[Shakir 90:13] (It is) the setting free of a slave,
[Shakir 90:14] Or the giving of food in a day of hunger
[Shakir 90:15] To an orphan, having relationship,
[Shakir 90:16] Or to the poor man lying in the dust.
[Shakir 90:17] Then he is of those who believe and charge one another to show patience, and charge one another to show compassion.
[Shakir 90:18] These are the people of the right hand.
[Shakir 90:19] And (as for) those who disbelieve in our communications, they are the people of the left hand.
[Shakir 90:20] On them is fire closed over.



*****
2. the women again who is the father of the baby.
I hope I answer you though I well make better understand in this case.
.

Answer 9

this is wasting question because there is no slaves today

Answer 10

sum of u ppl out der disgust me......u shud learn to respect others religion n God.