Here is a question thats been on my mind. If god decides right away if we go to heaven or hell from the moment we die, how is it possible to revive someone that is legally dead within five min, by using the thing that shocks and starts their heart up again. If their was a god, wouldn't it be impossible to revive someone because they would be in heaven or hell right away. If they did go to one of those places, wouldn't that interfere with gods plans.
2007-03-05 15:44:09 · 21 answers · asked by Anonymous in Society & Culture ➔ Religion & Spirituality
great questioning!
there are a lot of ideas, thoughts on this topic....
YES, there most certainly is a GOD... THE God...
to the question on your mind;
A) there are more judges on each soul.. one being God, Jesus... one being yourself....
when exactly this takes place is something that is up in the air... some believe it is before time... the book of life holds only so many names and though a name may be removed; no more shall be added.....
this book of life holds the names of those who will enter the gates of heaven.... and it has already been decided (God has judged) the names in there to be worthy... but that does not mean that when we walk the earth we can do whatever... during our lives we may mess up...
next judge is Jesus who will judge us on judgement day.. and also our own self...
I believe I was always taught at death we rest, until the Lord God calls our souls to him on judgement day.... and only God knows the day and time of that
it is possible to revive someone because
1) there is always room for another chance.... maybe they needed one
2) if your job is not done.. if you have not learned all there is; you need more time...
3) the things we do not dwell on really... it may be that when the life is ended it was not God's, will but the Demon's attempt to sabotage HIS plans.... and so the Lord brings them back.. which would mean that it was the death interferring and God is just setting his plans right again....
all tools put in our hands...discovered, invented by man were done with the grace of the One Lord... how? he gave us the ability... the "potential" to be the best, to be creative, inventive... he saw a way was needed... he lit the light bulb in someone's head..... and some inovative, wonderful machines were conceived built and used for everyday miracles in our hands.... but?
B) there are times the person is not able to be revived... so that it is impossible at times.... and again, falls into "the plans"
your body remains here as the other person answered; ashes to ashes dust to dust... how answers the question, do not know....
hope this helps
take care
good luck
2007-03-05 16:08:16 · answer #1 · answered by elusive_001 5 · 3⤊ 1⤋
no dear. The soul does not depart the body permanently until God says so. When the heart is in fibrillation, it can be defibrillated back into normal sinus rhythm and "life" restored. In the case of flat line or PEA where mechanical standstill is present, there are methods that can be used to sometimes "jump start" the heart by reversing certain conditions that can cause that to occur in the first place. But when the soul leaves the body permanently is when "death" occurs. I've seen 2 hour codes result in someone surviving when it was against all odds and I've seen someone die "for no reason" that all the resuscitating efforts in the world could not reverse. It is all still in the hands of God's call.
2007-03-05 15:58:21 · answer #2 · answered by wd 5 · 1⤊ 0⤋
That's a good question. But here's the twist. What if the person that was legally dead within 5 min in a place where you will be judged called hades? Or what if their soul was in the process of being judged and God decided that it was not their time and let them continue life? Or what if God wanted the person to experience heaven or hell to help construct the soul for later judgement? Who knows? But I definitely don't think that anything can interferring with God's plan. We all have a different course or role to play and God gives us choices of what to make of it. He knows before it even happens so if we go to heaven or hell, it wasn't designed by Him, but he knows before it even takes place.
2007-03-05 16:00:29 · answer #3 · answered by hardworkur84 2 · 0⤊ 1⤋
The Bible says that it's appointed for man to die ONCE, and then after that, judgment. There's a difference between legally dead, and dead. Someone who was revived wasn't dead, but was in transition heading towards death. Besides, God knows the beginning from the end, He knows who is going to be saved and who's going to Hell before that person was ever born. Nothing takes God by surprise.
2007-03-05 16:00:15 · answer #4 · answered by ted.nardo 4 · 0⤊ 1⤋
You aren't really dead till you have been down at least 30minutes. You are just consider "clinicly "dead when your heart stops beating but you aren't actually dead until your brain is dead and if CPR is start right away then you keep the O2 and blood circulating so that way your brain and tissue are still alive. If that stops for a period of 30 minutes then you are dead and there is no coming back. So that is how people can be brought back to life after being so called "Clinicly Dead"
2007-03-05 15:59:49 · answer #5 · answered by raven_geisha 2 · 1⤊ 0⤋
Actually none of what you said is either valid or correct.
#1.
God doesn't decide anything. He knows everything. Everything, before He ever even started creating. All knowing means He knows everything that ever will, would and does happen, right down to the number of hairs on your head right now.
God gives us 100% free will to do what we like. It's just like having a bird and setting it free. It can go anywhere it likes, but how often will it return to it's Master, out of love or duty, etc. ??? That is what God wants- for us to physically, mentally and spiritually return to Him and follow His Son's ways, as shown in the Bible.
2. When we die; we do not go to heaven or hell. The dead are asleep. When Jesus returns, then and only then will people begin to be resurrected. They are nothing but dust. The word Hell, in the Bible refers to this sleep, being in the grave, covered up (by dirt). That word in the original Greek and Hebrew bibles does NOT refer to Gehenna/ The Lake of Fire Judgement.
3. With our very limited intelligence, when compared with God, someone being resurrected from dust doesn't seem possible, but it is.
With our VERY limited science and medicine, a defibrillator is used to shock someone's heart back into a correct sinus rythym, 'bringing them back to life', sometimes. True.
2007-03-05 16:08:43 · answer #6 · answered by Anonymous · 1⤊ 1⤋
Electroshock cannot thwart the will of God. Science, Medicine, Politics, Armies, nothing can change what God set out to do.
Being physically dead is not the same as being spiritually dead. Physically dead can be brought back to life after death in certain instances. Spiritually dead is permanent. God does not decide at the moment of our death, whether or not we go to heaven. God is all knowing and He knows before the creation of the world, who would accept Him and who would reject Him.
Once a person accepts Christ Jesus as their Lord and Savior, they have crossed over from spiritual death to spiritual glory for all eternity. God Bless You....Peace.
2007-03-05 16:47:31 · answer #7 · answered by Anonymous · 0⤊ 0⤋
Bob isn't basically perfect yet Bob's answer is completely consistent with the present thinking in quantum mechanics that the mere commentary variations the effect of specific experiments. between the biggest problems with information is that almost all of persons who use them don't have a clue approximately information. you're saying "we" have finished statistical attempting out. in case you have been in touch as your use of the term "we" shows the place are your consequences? on the grounds which you have not written your consequences interior the way a statistician might i'm suggesting you're making use of the term "we" to indicate contributors of the human race of which you're additionally a member, or according to danger you're making use of "we" to indicate you're making a distinction between people who have faith in a prayer answering God and people who do not and additionally you're jointly with your self interior the latter group. the two way, you're making mere assertions which at the instant are not supported by potential of genuine information. Your so-stated as test is similar to a documentary I as quickly as observed the place incredibly some non secular people have been praying for specific terminally unwell people. This replaced right into a television stunt that had no medical value i'm afraid. For an test to be scientifically valid you're able to desire to be waiting to regulate all your variables and this replaced into not something like a controlled environment.
2016-10-17 09:13:33 · answer #8 · answered by ? 4 · 0⤊ 0⤋
God doesn't decide that we go to heaven or hell immediately upon death...that isn't decided until judgment day after the book of Revelations prophecy's are all fulfilled...you need to re-read the Book.
2007-03-05 15:51:31 · answer #9 · answered by Anonymous · 0⤊ 0⤋
Bible states when we die, we go into a slumber, a rest. We stay in this "sleep" till judgment day. When Jesus rises the dead and those still alive. Once judgment happens, some go to Heaven (144,000), some go to Hell and the rest come back to Earth to rule Earth for 1000 yrs with Jesus in total peace and harmony.
2007-03-05 15:49:42 · answer #10 · answered by Anonymous · 1⤊ 1⤋